5 ms·
I am curious how someone can come away from the last decade of Wall Street behavior and conclude the answer to the problem is less regulation.
by slg 12y ago
I am curious how someone can come away from the last decade of Wall Street behavior and conclude the answer to the problem is less regulation.
- awt 12y agoIf there were a law that could prevent regulatory capture then I would say go for it, more regulation.
- chc 12y agoWith or without regulatory capture, I can't see how the problem we face is too much oversight on Wall Street.
- lukifer 12y agoThe counterargument is that regulation hurts small players more than large ones. Citibank can afford an army of compliance officers; most of us can't. I'm generally pro-regulation, if the details are sensible, but regulatory capture is a real problem, and it is not an unreasonable stance that the cure is sometimes worse than the disease.
- wpietri 12y agoRegulatory capture's a real issue, but it's not a given. For those interested in the topic, I highly recommend Shelia Bair's "Bull By The Horns", which is her account of running the FDIC up to and during the financial crisis. It left me with quite a bit of respect for the FDIC's approach, and for what solid regulation takes.
- chc 12y agoThat isn't really a counterargument; it's just a factoid. A counterargument would be something along the lines of "Regulation hurts small players more than large ones, and the scarcity of small players has been the biggest problem with Wall Street over the past decade because _____, therefore the problem with Wall Street is too much oversight."
- wyager 12y agoWhy should people on wall street be forbidden from doing whatever investments they want to, insofar as they are contractually allowed? If you don't like how someone is investing, don't invest with them. If you think certain banks are behaving riskilly, don't give them your money. What are some counter-arguments to this? I.e. why is it a) moral and b) desirable to regulate the activity of wall street traders in addition to the laws they are automatically subject to (like anti-fraud laws)?
- pyoung 12y agoI would imagine most of the laws and regulations are anti-fraud in nature. Outside of that, limiting the risk exposure of banks that carry FDIC insurance, or some other government backing, is in the interest in of all taxpayers. From my laymen's understanding, if you want to start a hedge fund, take some rich people's money, and gamble it all away, nothing is really stopping you. In fact people do it all the time.
- eric_bullington 12y ago>take some rich people's money And there lies the rub. So the wealthy man can take advantage of start-up investing, but the government in its infinite wisdom, forbids the middle-class man from doing the same under penalty of imprisonment for the person offering the security.
- smacktoward 12y agoYes, it is truly a moral imperative that we allow people who can't afford to be ripped off access to the same "investment opportunities" as people who can. Freeeeeeeedom!
- wyager 12y agoYou know how people always complain about the rich getting richer? That frequently happens because they're given exclusive access to those "rip-offs" you're claiming average people should be excluded from.
- tvhiggins 12y agoimo its the fact that we're so reliant on 3-4 big banks as opposed to 100 banks. if it were more decentralized, US could afford less regulation and just let companies succeed/fail on their own. can't do that in the current climate
- chc 12y agoI don't think it would look the way you imagine. There are lots of computer software vendors, but if you wiped out Apple, Microsoft and a few core Linux contributors, you'd pretty much wreck the computer world, even for people who directly use other vendors. The existence of smaller players does not negate the influence of the larger ones.
- wyager 12y agoThe obvious answer is that wall street has never been in a state of no regulation; at least, not for a very long time. When you have a bunch of poorly thought out regulation, much of it designed to exclude competition, that's when things go bad. The cool thing about the internet is that regardless of what you or the SEC or John Q. Public thinks is a bad idea or improper, people are free to experiment with it anyway. Technology has outpaced the ability of governments to proscribe voluntary interaction.
- imaginenore 12y agoRegulation done by math is infinitely better than the regulation done by easily corruptible talking heads. HSBC got caught laundering billions of drug cartel and Iranian money. Do you know how many of the bankers went to jail? Zero. They had to pay a tiny fine equal to less than a month of their revenue. How many bankers or Wall st guys went to jail for the largest freaking financial crisis they had caused? Regulation in finance just doesn't work. Look at who the regulators are and who is in charge of the regulators. Half of t these folks are from Goldman.
- zanny 12y agoBecause there is a tremendous amount of regulation surrounding finance - look at how it is impossible to make a backer liable Kickstarter. You cannot make your own stock market, and you cannot sell ownership in a company through anything but a public stock exchange. I imagine there is also tremendous regulation surrounding venture capital, but I have never engaged in it much so I'm unaware of the complexities. Too bad that, by nature of the fact the finance industry inherently has all the money, that money lets them buy the politicians to then use regulation to prevent competition and line their own pockets, while leaving them impervious to persecution when their greed fucks everything up. I do not see how even the best intentioned regulation can work in finance. It is the proverbial tightening the fist while the actors slip through your fingers - if you try to restrict the flow of money, really big money, like drug money, then all you will find is you suffering for it.
- wpietri 12y agoProtip: If you start by saying "I do not see how", the problem may be that you are just not seeing it. One of the reasons that foreign companies list on US markets is that we have some of the strongest financial regulations in the world. A simple analogy: San Francisco has a vigorous health department, and food safety scores are posted visibly in every restaurant. Does this reduce the vibrancy of the restaurant scene? No, it enhances it. Because I know when a place is likely safe to eat at, I spend more money in restaurants and I'm more willing to try new places. That increases the effectiveness of the market because newer restaurants compete on a more even footing with established ones.
- zanny 12y ago> Because I know when a place is likely safe to eat at, I spend more money in restaurants and I'm more willing to try new places. And the inverse of this, is that if a restaurant listed food safety scores irrespective of state mandate, you would visit those restaurants more, and if most people agreed, those restaurants would prosper and those not adopting food safety scores would suffer. Except in that situation there was no violence of the state to compel the individual restaurants to do something - the market naturally lead to that conclusion. It is not like there is any limit on your ability to learn information about a restaurant - I would say I am surprised that there is not some popular national database of website safety ratings made up of user reviews, but considering I have never searched for such a service - I just go by general user reviews, under the assumption that an unsafe food service locale would get trashed in criticism - I guess it makes sense not to exist. > That increases the effectiveness of the market because newer restaurants compete on a more even footing with established ones. Or it would be a competitive advantage if the markets truly benefited from food safety scores for newer restaurants to advertise them where their entrenched competition does no such thing.
- colordrops 12y agoPeople come away concluding that, because the problem with Wall Street is not deregulation, despite all the propaganda to the contrary. The problem was selective regulation or deregulation, whatever benefited Wall Street, as well as selective enforcement and interpretation of law. In a nut shell, Wall Street is in control and reconfigures the legal apparatus to their advantage; they don't randomly dismantle it.
- ewzimm 12y agoI think people like to simplify regulation as either good or bad and fail to consider how biased it can be. Unbiased software rules that can be openly analyzed and force everyone to play fair are good. Selective regulation written by those with money is terrible.