5 ms·
>Pardon me if I think my nation should tolerate nuclear missiles 90 miles off our coast from a country aligned with our enemies Don't you think people of other
by trhway 12y ago
>Pardon me if I think my nation should tolerate nuclear missiles 90 miles off our coast from a country aligned with our enemies
Don't you think people of other nations may have the same intolerance to their enemies' nuclear missiles deployed right on their borders? The Cuban missiles were symmetric response to deploying the Jupiter missiles in Turkey - which is right on the border with USSR
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PGM-19_Jupiter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PGM-19_Jupiter
"They were all removed by the US as part of a secret agreement with the Soviet Union during the Cuban Missile Crisis."
Do onto others what you don't want others do onto you :)
- kevinskii 12y agoPerhaps the Jupiter missile deterrent was a bit impolite, but the USSR did enslave many hundreds of millions of people while showing every intention of growing this number.
- vidarh 12y agoThe US "enslaved" vast numbers of people through proxy too, and contributed to several genocides by propping up various puppet regimes. The US may have been morally superior at home but played just as dirty in large parts of the world.
- joeclark77 12y agoThe USSR was a totalitarian communist empire openly determined to conquer and enslave the entire world. The USA was a champion of liberty that pursued strategies intended only to defend the free world against the USSR. Your moral equivalency game indicates you're either ignorant of recent history, or that you're on the other side.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mercurial 12y agoI hope this is sarcasm. Sure, the USSR was a totalitarian state. That said, both sides pursued an aggressive, expansionist policy via proxy. The "champion of liberty" installed thoroughly repressive regimes all over South America which had little to envy to the Soviet Union. It didn't prove itself above manufacturing border incidents to trigger the Vietnam war, either. Was the USSR worse? Certainly. But this doesn't make the US the good guy in the story.
- redacted 12y agoThe propaganda of the Cold War is breathtaking in its effectiveness. The USSR are the bad guys, comic book villains out to destroy the world. The US are plucky do-gooders, fighting to save the world from evil yet again (after single handedly winning WWII). There is no room for nuance. There is no grey area in perhaps the greyest of all conflicts since the Great Game. Both the US and USSR inflicted terrible damage to nations all over the world through proxy wars, intelligence agency coups. The ramifications of those conflicts are still felt throughout Latin America, the Middle East, and South East Asia. And that all gets swept aside by "The USA was a champion of liberty that pursued strategies intended only to defend the free world against the USSR." Read the Wikipedia article on "Covert United States Foreign Regime Change Actions" [0], and see how many of those nations benefited in the long run, and how some incredibly brutal regimes were installed or propped up throughout the third world, simply because they weren't communists. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Covert_United_States_foreign_regime_change_actions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Covert_United_States_foreign_re...
- joeclark77 12y agoYou should have said "the anti-American garbage that leftist teachers are feeding to grade-school kids is breathtaking in its effectiveness" but in order to do that, you'd have to have some understanding of the true (not the political) version of history. What's really amazing is that you think your 1960s, nihilistic, self-loathing, theyre-all-the-same cynicism is thoughtful and original, and you assume that the reason I disagree with you is that I haven't heard of such a notion before, and must not be as educated as yourself...
- rdtsc 12y agoPlease. I lived in Soviet Union and United States for decades (in each). Not it wasn't a totalitarian evil empire. It was an empire. It didn't tollerate criticism of its government but: * It provided free healthcare * It provided free housing * Crime rate was law * It provided free and quality education (from kindergarten all the way to the highest degrees) > The USA was a champion of liberty that pursued strategies intended only to defend the free world against the USSR. Wait, are you being sarcastic. I am confused. Poe's Law in full effect here, ladies and gentlement.
- joeclark77 12y agoIgnoring the genocides and the gulags for a minute, let's simply explore your theory that the USA and USSR were morally equivalent. The USSR conquered and imposed brutal slavery on every eastern european nation. The USA did not conquer any of the western european nations. We didn't even conquer Cuba. If we had the military power, why wouldn't we?
- rdtsc 12y ago> The USSR conquered and imposed brutal slavery on every eastern european nation. Slavery, like US had up until the mid 1800 and with the following oppression and segregation laws? Or the country that based itself on ethnic cleansing and genocide of countless American Indians. > The USA did not conquer any of the western european nations No but it raped all the South American states and some East Asian states (Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia). Also Middle East. Started Wars. > We didn't even conquer Cuba. Sure tried. And send saboteurs to plant IEDs, blow up bridges, plants. Destroy machinery. Can you say "War Of Terror" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuban_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuban_Project) > If we had the military power, why wouldn't we? Ok USSR didn't conquer Australia. They had the military power. Why didn't they. Probably didn't want to. And didn't care about.
- trhway 12y ago>your theory that the USA and USSR were morally equivalent. mid-20th century significant share (if not half) of the world population was enchanted with the ideas of socialism/communism with those ideas symbolizing justice and freedom (not mass oppression as it ultimately turned to be). In that respect, _back then_, they were morally equivalent or at least close to it. We know better _now_, after observing of many decades of that failed experiments. >The USSR conquered and imposed brutal slavery on every eastern european nation. The USA did not conquer any of the western european nations. They all had their respective zones of occupation in Europe, Korea, Japan after the WWII. With time socialist regime in USSR zone turned to be the regime of "conquest and slavery", while capitalism in the western zones, South Korea and Japan happened to be more freedom conducting. For example South Korea wasn't fan of being occupied by US (for example among others http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autumn_Uprising_of_1946 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autumn_Uprising_of_1946 ) and it took decades for it to ultimately start benefiting from having been occupied by US instead of USSR. Again, back then, it wasn't that clear for huge number of people, and it took decades for the differences to appear clearly. >We didn't even conquer Cuba. If we had the military power, why wouldn't we? you think it is easier to fight in Cuba jungles than in Vietnam one or that Cubans would be less fierce fighters than Vietnamese?
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoRussia was more than welcome to sanction Turkey.