3 ms·
I've never used a mailing list that didn't possess a centralized address like foo-discuss@example.com. And these all require explicit approval to submit message
by kibwen 12y ago
I've never used a mailing list that didn't possess a centralized address like foo-discuss@example.com. And these all require explicit approval to submit messages to the list, in order to keep out spam.
- kazinator 12y agoNo, they do not all require explicit approval to keep out spam. In GNU Mailman, this is a config option: you can allow non-subscribers to post or not. All of the mailing lists that I operate on my own mailing list server allow non-subscribers to post. Due to my anti-spam configuration, this isn't a problem. Traditional mailing lists, before the rise of spam, were usually this way. And anyway, this is a separate issue. A list which does not re-mail postings from non-subscribers can nevertheless not do Reply-to: munging. So once you are on the list and participate in discussions, you're still sending messages to the list, as well as directly to those in the discussion. Earlier this year I was involved in a mailing list discussion in which one of the parties was actually (unbeknownst to me for a while) a "persona non grata": someone banned from posting to the mailing list. His postings were not being seen by the subscribers, but only those in the debate. This list does use Reply-to:; he just (trivially) circumvented it.