4 ms·
Because what has happened to Lennart is pretty horrible.
by chris_wot 12y ago
Because what has happened to Lennart is pretty horrible.
- freehunter 12y agoI googled his name and as soon as I read what projects he works on I instantly knew his complaint was perfectly valid. Probably the most hated Linux projects ever devised, and for purely political reasons.
- eloisant 12y agoI wouldn't say his projects were hated for political reasons. They were hated because they were a central piece of software (sound for PA the init for systemd) and they were released unfinished. It's certainly wrong to turn that to personal attacks against him, but I can understand why people disliked PulseAudio then Systemd - and even hated these projects because they caused breakage in numerous systems, hours to try to fix it, and ended up with justifications like "it's by design" or "you don't understand why but it's better this way".
- Shish2k 12y ago> they were released unfinished Isn't that how open source is /supposed/ to work? TBH, as a Debian user, I'm quite happy with the "Lennart releases theoretically brilliant but practically buggy apps, Ubuntu / Arch users suffer for a few months, Debian integrates the system once it's stable" workflow :)
- EmanueleAina 12y agoNowadays the workflow is more or less back to the reverse direction: Debian first and Ubuntu later, with the added benefit that Debian maintainers are rather more dependable when choosing the version to be packaged. :)
- EmanueleAina 12y agosystemd has always worked quite well for me and the transition in Debian has been incredibly smooth, so I wouldn't consider it "unfinished". PulseAudio was unfortunately released in Ubuntu even before Lennart & co. declared it releasable, so it was Ubuntu's fault if it gained a reputation of being "unfinished" (indeed it was, but it was not a fault of the PulseAudio team).
- RVuRnvbM2e 12y agoI agree. It's disgusting. Luckily he's a brilliant engineer and was able to withstand the flames long enough for people to recognise how good his software is. Pulseaudio and systemd are two of the best things to happen to Linux in years.
- forca 12y agoPulseaudio took way too long to get ironed out, IMHO. ALSA was bad in a lot of ways, but was workable. I agree moving forward is good, but the issue with alot of OSS software is it's used a replacement for working software when it's not quite ready. PA was not ready for primetime when it was initially released. Everyone knows this. It works fine now after many fixes and considerable time. systemd is the same. A lot of people dislike change and systemd is a radical shift from the init that was. While I still prefer the old init, I'm not shying away from using Debian because of it. What I don't like is the hooks that systemd places into software it has no business touching, like Gnome. Userland software should not be touched by this. Full stop. An init system should do one thing well. Userland software shoudl do what it does well. In too many growing instances, systemd is a requirement for userland software and this should never be.
- RVuRnvbM2e 12y ago> Pulseaudio took way too long to get ironed out, IMHO. Have you considered that a flexible, high-quality OS audio subsystem might be difficult to bang out in one weekend? > ALSA was bad in a lot of ways, but was workable. Are you kidding? Every desktop install before pulseaudio was a crapshoot when it came to audio. > I agree moving forward is good, but the issue with alot of OSS software is it's used a replacement for working software when it's not quite ready. No-one forced anyone to switch to pulseaudio, and has any software ever been perfect in release 0.1? I personally upgraded straight from Debian squeeze (default ALSA) to wheezy (default Pulse) without a single issue, because pulseaudio wasn't integrated until it was stable. > What I don't like is the hooks that systemd places into software it has no business touching, like Gnome. It's not like systemd people sneaked their "hooks" into Gnome. Gnome switched to systemd interfaces (e.g. logind) because they fixed real bugs! > Userland software should not be touched by this. Full stop. It isn't! Developers are just switching because it is better. Wow. This post is a good example of the baseless accusations Lennart has to put up with.
- lmm 12y agoWhat he's done to many people's systems, mine included, is pretty horrible. He doesn't deserve death threats. But users should be able to opt out of his software, and he's deliberately making that as hard as possible.
- chris_wot 12y agoOK, that's a technical matter. That's not what he's upset about, the issue is bullying. I think, also, that you are pretty unreasonable yourself there - he's not making things deliberately as hard as possible. Nobody told the Debian guys to standardize on systemd.
- lmm 12y agoIt's not purely technical. Pottering absolutely has attempted to force adoption, if not directly with the distros then with the gnome integration. Systemd has succeeded where technically better alternatives failed by encouraging downstream software to hard-depend on systemd, rather than offering/conforming to a standardized interface, which is a dirty tactic, user-hostile and technically damaging. And the refusal to accept patches to add support to non-linux systems to systemd is technically indefensible and completely antithetical to the spirit of open source.
- EmanueleAina 12y agoLennart didn't force anything on GNOME, please stop these false claims. The GNOME developers simply had two choices: keep using the old, bug-ridden and still-unmaintained ConsoleKit or switch to the simpler, more powerful logind D-Bus interface. ConsoleKit is still more-or-less supported upstream, but given it's extreme bugginess many distro choose to disable it and rely on logind interfaces. Note that this does not mean that GNOME depends on systemd: as long as something else is implementing the needed logind interfaces (eg. systemd-shims) GNOME will happily run. And no, a maintainer refusing patches is absolutely not "antithetical to the spirit of open source". The spirit of open source is that you can fork if you don't agree with a maintainer. It's simple as that.
- 12y ago