3 ms·
How does "government" know exactly when to tell people to look for something else? Do you think it's possible that the "insiders" might try and influence the s
by davidw 12y ago
How does "government" know exactly when to tell people to look for something else?
Do you think it's possible that the "insiders" might try and influence the state to get them to tell that to newcomers in order to gain a bigger share of the pie for themselves?
- pron 12y ago> How does "government" know exactly when to tell people to look for something else? I'm not sure why you put government in quotations, but the government doesn't know; it's supposed to decide through bargaining. > Do you think it's possible that the "insiders" might try and influence the state to get them to tell that to newcomers in order to gain a bigger share of the pie for themselves? Sure, but that's the name of the game. I would hope that politicians who want to get reelected support sensible policy (or at least a sensible "grand bargain"). The way the game is played sucks, but it's a lot better than living at the mercy of those who have more means (not that it isn't like that anyway, but at least democracies give people the power to organize and form an opposing power to capital).
- davidw 12y agoI'm certainly not someone who has bought into the 'Austrian school' of economics, nor "market fundamentalism" in other forms, but some of their ideas were pretty good: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_calculation_problem And as a consequence I think that markets are a more efficient way of calculating some things like "how many people should be taxi drivers" than government planning.
- pron 12y agoGovernment planning and government regulation are two very different things. Regulation is an iterative process, where the market is allowed to determine some things, and then society tries to correct the flaws and to better direct the outcome. The economy is like a river that starts out as a natural process (or, at least something that's hard to control), and along its flow, people may divert it or dam it to make sure it provides the desired benefit and to prevent possible harm it may cause.