4 ms·
> I'd like for people to start thinking about security measures, including encryption, as a cost function rather than as a boolean condition (e.g. safe vs. unsa
by crazy1van 12y ago
> I'd like for people to start thinking about security measures, including encryption, as a cost function rather than as a boolean condition (e.g. safe vs. unsafe; stop the NSA vs. not stop the NSA)
Great point and one that I think typical computer savvy users already do. It is in the security-expert-fantasy-world that the perfect quickly becomes the enemy of the good.
For example, using SSL to send sensitive data like passwords or payment info is nearly ubiquitous. Yes, there are many flaws in SSL's trust model, but the cost is so small, using it is a no brainer.
However, PGP encrypted email is much more rarely used. It has numerous higher costs, from special email software to the social pain of getting your friends to also use it. The benefit is still high, but the cost is high too and that results in far less usage.
In the real world, informed people look at the cost benefit break down of security. Just like we all don't drive semi trucks around even though they are safer in a collision, we all don't communicate in the most secure fashion because there is a cost associated with that decision. With that in mind, the easiest path towards greater security in communications population-wide would be to focus less on improving the security and more on lowering the associated cost.
- peatmoss 12y agoIn a traditional economic sense, the optimal amount to spend on security measures is when the marginal costs equal the marginal benefits.
- qzc4 12y agoYes, but it's hard to quantify the benefits (or even the costs) of a security measure—it's just as much a risk evaluation as it is a cost one.
- peatmoss 12y agoLike so much of economics, the hard part is coming up with a price tag that everyone agrees on in all contexts. How much would you pay to save your grandmother's life from an illness? How much would you accept to allow me to hunt her for sport? So, in that sense, coming up with a precise measure of marginal cost / marginal benefit would be hard in practice.
- narag 12y agoIt has numerous higher costs, from special email software to the social pain of getting your friends to also use it. With 'special email software' do you mean not-webmail? Outlook is still around in many companies, where your colleagues are already connected. IIRC there's a PGP plugin.
- wodenokoto 12y agoA PGP plugin is special software.