3 ms·
This was 2013 and he never heard of the CLOS arguments against traditional objects as he describes it, and he attributes Alan Kay with generics and method based
by rurban 12y ago
This was 2013 and he never heard of the CLOS arguments against traditional objects as he describes it, and he attributes Alan Kay with generics and method based OO dispatch, the functional approach?
All these arguments were already cleared in the early 1990's, and people still don't get it. CS scholar's shouldn't care about the popularity of certain languages, or do they wanna teach VB or PHP?
Objects are of course evitable, functions can do more, can do it better, and functions can represent not only scoped blocks (variable hiding), but also objects easily.
http://www.gigamonkeys.com/book/object-reorientation-generic-functions.html http://www.gigamonkeys.com/book/object-reorientation-generic... talks a bit about this mindset, mentioning also Kay's simple dynamic message passing approach.
- Confusion 12y agoObjects are a poor man's closures. Closures are a poor man's objects. -- Guy Steele