3 ms·
Ultimately the problem is that "morality" as practiced generally comes from some kind of religious backing. "Don't mix fabrics because God said so" and boom, it
by bane 12y ago
Ultimately the problem is that "morality" as practiced generally comes from some kind of religious backing. "Don't mix fabrics because God said so" and boom, it is immoral to mix fabrics.
This was an easy crutch for people to use for a long time because it saved them the difficulty of actually thinking about things.
Modern social movements away from religion as a basis for morality has put this kind of lazy thinking into a tailspin. Humans have only ever been able to define morality as having some kind of immovable axiomatic underpinning of the kind religion likes to provide. But if religion is out, and we still want to be moral, what do we underpin it with?
If we say "Science" than Veganism is right out, as it's scientifically proven to not be an optimal diet. And sentience, while interesting, holds no more moral preservation requirements in science as does maintaining an environmental temperature close to absolute zero.
It seems the sad answer is that people arbitrarily embrace some new axiom and then define their morality on top of it. Lazy people just copy this defined morality and now you end up with "angels on the head of a pin" internet fights like "how sentient does an organism have to be...?" or "what's the most free license software should morally be distributed under?" or whatever the nonsense debate du jour is.
Problematically, like all new converts, people who've embraced their new religion want to tell everybody about it, and chastise all the unconverted for their immoral unclean ways.
The truth is, the guiding notion of morals have become antiquated, but humans have resisted coming up with some other guiding framework that doesn't require mindless adherence to some arbitrary axiom.
For my money, if I had a gun to my head and had to choose an axiom to build a moral framework off of, I'd go with "ensure that survival, propagation and continued forward evolution of the species".