5 ms·
People can be so insanely desperate to have children exactly in some arbitrary and specific way. I mean, this woman went through a very dangerous and expensive
by wyager 12y ago
People can be so insanely desperate to have children exactly in some arbitrary and specific way.
I mean, this woman went through a very dangerous and expensive transplant surgery that then required the use of immunosuppressant drugs to prevent organ rejection, when she could have used a surrogate or, gasp, adopted.
I hope they had to pay for this surgery with their own cash. There is absolutely no medical necessity behind it.
Edit: This comment seems to be eliciting some disapproval. I'm curious why; please let me know what you're thinking.
- chrisseaton 12y agoHaving children of their own is life goal number 1 for many people. Asking them to be rational about it is disregarding just how primal this drive is.
- derefr 12y agoI would phrase that as "having children of their own is goal number one for [all adaptively-fit lifeforms that undergo sexual selection pressure]." The genes of all plants and animals alive today came from the subset of their species that wished to procreate. Or, to put it another way, among gene sequences that attain fixation through sexual selection pressure, any sequence that impels procreation as a terminal goal is going to be fixated more quickly than any other.
- kurokikaze 12y agoIt's a scientific achievement.
- dublinben 12y agoA completely unnecessary one. This is just progress for the sake of progress.
- csallen 12y agoSeemingly unnecessary progress might inadvertently lead to important discoveries and useful knowledge.
- nobodyshere 12y agoAre you a member of the necessity committee?
- TeMPOraL 12y agoProgress for the sake of progress is how science should be done, because you can't ever predict what practical uses will come out of research.
- johansch 12y agoThe fertility rate in Sweden is < 2.0. I see it as a worthwhile future investment. Someone's gotta pay our pensions. :).
- wyager 12y ago>Someone's gotta pay our pensions. :). I can almost guarantee you that this procedure cost more than the expected tax revenue of the resulting child. If it was paid for with public money (I'm not sure how health care works in Sweden), this was probably not helpful in paying for pensions.
- johansch 12y agoFor the first one, yeah, no doubt.
- gfodor 12y agoYou're saying that the specific manner of giving birth to a child you carry in a womb in your own body over 9 months that is of your own genetic makeup is "arbitrary," despite the fact that this is the exclusive mechanism of human procreation up until recent history.
- gpvos 12y agoThe counterargument is of course that transplants and immunosuppressant drugs are also artificial, and even more recent. Also, adoption has always been possible. I guess the main point is that it feels closest to the natural method.
- wyager 12y agoYes. If you're asserting that "giving birth to a child you carry in a womb in your own body over 9 months" is somehow inherently preferable or special compared to any other form of child rearing, your argument that "this is the exclusive mechanism of human procreation up until recent history" is an argumentum ad antiquitatem and/or argumentum ad naturam fallacy.
- eropple 12y agoI would suggest considering that rationality is not how people work and that it's easy for professing surprise when people don't happen to be rational to come off as a lil' bit douchey.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoA meta observation: naming someone's logical fallacies seems to be positively correlated with being wrong and/or arrogant, and generally tends to derail discussions quickly. The failure mode Eliezer used to write about[0] seems to be true - in many, learning about logical fallacies tends to induce dysrationalia. Instead thinking about what other side says, one can just pattern-match anything they disagree with to a fallacy and cry foul. [0] - http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Dangerous_knowledge http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Dangerous_knowledge
- 12y ago
- gliese1337 12y agoThis comment seems to be eliciting some disapproval. I'm curious why; please let me know what you're thinking. I expect due to the implied tone. I agree with the general sentiment: there are much easier ways to get a kid, adoption arguably has more positive social impact, so why did they go with this route? But the way you phrase it, it seems rather like an attack that does not leave much room open for discussion.
- quarterto 12y agoSurrogacy is legally problematic in Sweden. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surrogacy_laws_by_country#Sweden http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surrogacy_laws_by_country#Swede...
- zach 12y agoAnd essentially all adoption in Sweden is international - only about 100 adoption cases a year involve Swedish births. Foreign adoptions are troublesome enough to make a womb transplant look like a reasonable alternative. Now you know why this would happen in Sweden. So since you're curious, wyager, it seems a little hand-wavy to say "she could have used a surrogate or, gasp, adopted." Combining sarcasm and hand-waving makes for poor commentary.
- Crito 12y ago> "And essentially all adoption in Sweden is international - only about 100 adoption cases a year involve Swedish births." Why is that? A lack of Swedish orphans? Red tape that exists locally but not internationally? That 100/year figure is shocking to me.
- TorKlingberg 12y agoI went and checked the statistics. The were 586 domestic adoptions in Sweden in 2014, slightly more than the 546 international adoptions. I assume most of the domestic adoptions are to people who were already close to the child, such as relatives or a parents new partner. In fact 61% were above 18 years old. http://www.scb.se/sv_/Hitta-statistik/Artiklar/Internationella-adoptioner-minskar/ http://www.scb.se/sv_/Hitta-statistik/Artiklar/Internationel...
- car 12y agoMedical necessity is determined by the needs of the patient, which can be physical or psychological. That's really a standard view in medicine, and thus justifies insurance payments for any required procedures. Examples would be gender reassignment, or plastic surgery.
- wyager 12y ago> Examples would be gender reassignment, or plastic surgery. Almost nowhere (as far as I'm aware) offers taxpayer-funded plastic surgery, except perhaps in cases of extreme congenital deformation. I don't think the case presented here is comparable. Many people are sterile, and it doesn't tend to have a cripplingly negative impact on their lives.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- roghummal 12y ago>Medical necessity is determined by the needs of the patient, which can be physical or psychological. Tell that to my insurance company. Bah :(
- Mz 12y agoI am reminded of discussions I had with people about the article "War in the Womb" about what babies do to the mom. Both here on HN (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8155574 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8155574) and elsewhere, I talked a bit with people about how the cells left behind by the baby might impact my genetic disorder. There is an awful lot we do not know about what motivates people to want a particular thing. Coping with my genetic disorder has been a long strange journey and has made me aware of a lot of weird potential explanations for why people sometimes go to crazy lengths for something. We can never know what the path not taken would have led to for this woman. We can never know how her life would have turned out had she simply adopted instead or used a surrogate. We can do studies and we can talk about statistical correlation and so on, but there will never the chance to A/B test this for this specific individual. Maybe she did what was best for her, even if some total stranger on the Internet doesn't approve.
- darklajid 12y agoIt's not arbitrary and specific, it's natural. You're attacking people for their inherent wish to be 'normal' and just have a kid like every other couple on this planet. If we throw out the 'insane' label, I'd rather apply that to your position here. There's nothing wrong with adoption, but it's not the same thing (and usually not the first choice). I cannot even begin to imagine what you're complaining about here and why you consider that attitude worth sharing.
- wyager 12y ago>I cannot even begin to imagine what you're complaining about here It seems pretty simple to me: it's stupid to waste hundreds of thousands of dollars (at least) to satisfy "their inherent wish to be 'normal'". >and just have a kid like every other couple on this planet. There are many couples who don't have any kids. This doesn't mean it's not OK to want to have children if you can't; it just demonstrates that it's probably pretty silly to waste a ton of (public?) money and risk your life just for the sake of having children, particularly when you can acquire them in other ways.
- darklajid 12y ago>It seems pretty simple to me: it's stupid to waste hundreds of thousands of dollars (at least) to satisfy "their inherent wish to be 'normal'". I have two issues with your attitude. 1) The 'waste' here is money spent on scientific progress. The most expensive part is probably caused by the leading word in the headline: 'First'. It's probably a safe bet that this will become cheaper with time. 2) You're again calling these people (I assume you target both the couple and the people that made this possible?) stupid because .. you seem to feel different? >There are many couples who don't have any kids. Those are obviously not related/not the couples I was referring to. >This doesn't mean it's not OK to want to have children if you can't; it just demonstrates that it's probably pretty silly to waste a ton of (public?) money and risk your life just for the sake of having children, particularly when you can acquire them in other ways. That just shows that you're talking about things you aren't familiar with (no offense: I used to be there right with you). Let's just ignore the part where you call others silly again or the part where you judge for others what is worth risking your very own health/body/life for: Getting kids 'one way or another' is not the same thing. It's not like a random gadget and whether you're soldering it at home or order it from Alibaba is really just the same (and .. people _will_ probably disagree with even that statement, deeply caring about some perceived difference in that case). The mother in this case was able to carry a baby inside of her body for 32 weeks. I (father of two) cannot begin to imagine what that means to a woman and by your comments you're even further away from understanding any of this. I guess it's fine if you "don't get it". But it seems you attack that report without any clue on that matter AND you seem to imply that this is a stupid thing in general, for everyone. That's the most arrogant thing I've read on this site for a while.
- RexRollman 12y agoWhat I don't understand is the medical effort to do this in a world overrun with humans. It seems to be that we could be making better use of our time.
- Mz 12y agoSo tell me, are you American? Do you have a car? Do you eat everyday? Are you gainfully employed? Do you have any savings? Surely you should be concerned about starving people in Africa or something instead of, say, wasting time on Hacker News? We all put our time and effort into things that make sense for us. You are free to invest your time, money and effort in those things that matter to you. This mattered to them.