3 ms·
Let's say a Mariott bus driver was caught racing down the freeway at 100mph in a company vehicle. Do you also wish to shut down Marriott, Inc for this offense?
by stickfigure 12y ago
Let's say a Mariott bus driver was caught racing down the freeway at 100mph in a company vehicle. Do you also wish to shut down Marriott, Inc for this offense? This is actually putting _lives_ at risk. Much more jailworthy than some mid-level manager's decision to violate some FCC rules, right?
- mikeash 12y agoIf the corporation itself is not responsible, then the individual should be punished. If the corporation is somehow responsible (for example, they have a long history of systematic and deliberate violations with supporting policy), the corporation should be punished. Here, neither is happening. The individuals responsible are, as far as I can tell, being completely let off the hook, while the company gets a completely trivial fine.
- stickfigure 12y agoWhy do you think that $600k is not commensurate with the offense? It may be a significant part of that business unit's income. It may be 10X the amount of revenue they obtained by breaking this particular law. It may have resulted in some people getting fired - possibly people who didn't even realize they were doing something illegal. Hell, there are at least a half-dozen switches I could flip in DD-WRT that will violate FCC rules and I have no idea which ones are which. I don't know this, nor do you. The people that do know this are the prosecutors in this case, and they considered that $600k (and the rest of the consent decree) was punishment that fit the crime. Unless you have some special knowledge of this particular case, I don't see why you are in a position to second guess them.
- mikeash 12y agoThere's a long history of wrist-slaps for huge corporate crimes. Two recent examples are BP and Bank of America, both hailed as massive, unprecedented fines for massive crimes, both of which barely hurt either company. Proportionally, my cost for merely retaining a lawyer would affect me more than a $600,000 fine affects Marriott. Never mind the fact that I would probably go to jail and lose out on months or years of salary, not to mention freedom.
- stickfigure 12y agoThere's an odd disconnect between people who on one hand say "corporations are not people!" and then on the other hand anthropomorphize them as if they were a child who needs to be spanked. You can't compare the punishment of a corporation with the punishment of a human, because corporations are not people. They don't have minds, they don't "feel bad" for what they have done, they can't sit in jail and regret their decisions. The best we can do discourage unwanted behavior in the future. Will this particular remedy be effective at preventing the behavior in the future, both from Marriott and other corporations? The prosecutors seem to think so, you think to seem not. You've given me no reason to trust your judgement more than theirs.
- mikeash 12y agoWell, you've given me no reason to trust their judgment more than my own, so unless you're making a "trust the authorities, they are Your Friend" argument, I don't really see the point of repeating that.