5 ms·
That's like arguing that workers who plough a field with their bare hands are less productive than workers who use a plough because someone else owns the plough
by TheOtherHobbes 12y ago
That's like arguing that workers who plough a field with their bare hands are less productive than workers who use a plough because someone else owns the plough.
How much 'capital productivity' would be left if all workers downed tools and stopped producing?
As for [2] - if you bother to read Katz, you'll see that even he admits there's a serious issue with wage polarization, and that in fact his own argument is incorrect - there has been no bonanza of well-paid jobs created by technology, and currently there is no prospect for same.
What has actually happened - and he says as much [1] - is that wealth capture through productivity gains has polarized the market into a few well-paying jobs and a much larger number of poverty-line menial jobs, which a majority of formerly middle class workers have been forced into.
Where are these jobs workers have 'failed to adapt' to? What are they, exactly? If they exist, where can they get the capital to retrain for them?
A lot of unemployed and underpaid people would love to know.
[1] https://www.aeaweb.org/econwhitepapers/white_papers/David_Autor.pdf https://www.aeaweb.org/econwhitepapers/white_papers/David_Au...
- fizixer 12y ago- You're citing a document from 2010, when IBM Watson hadn't beaten humans on Jeopardy, Google driverless car wasn't demonstrated, Boston Dynamics big-dog, atlas hadn't happened, DARPA robotics competition hadn't happened, quadrocopters weren't doing crazy things, Amazon kiva systems, Baxter, etc, etc. Things are picking up pace. (EDIT: hadn't happened or not widely known). - Since then, Paul Krugman himself has covered tech-unemployment in at least one of his blog posts, in which he has expressed surprise at how things are changing but has concluded the post in humor and essentially dismissing the idea (not very wise!). - Politicians lag behind economists in staying up to date, who themselves lag behind technologists. "This time" it would really help if economists try to wake up. - CGPGrey's youtube video 'Humans need not apply' is a must watch for anyone serious about staying aware of upcoming technology. - The accusation of lump-of-labor fallacy is itself a strawman fallacy. Tech-unemployment doesn't require labor to be fixed. It can happen even if labor lump is increasing but not as fast as humans are becoming obsolete, i.e., "this time". - Side-comment: Adaptation almost always happens because of new-entrants (youth learning new trades) so it's a generational thing. Those thrown out of the job market are more likely to retire early or something like that. And "this time", even youth are not going to adapt. - Side-comment 2: Recessions cause quite a bit of damage to social structures which intentionally or unintentionally doesn't get media coverage, or at least doesn't register in public's minds. Just the recent European recession caused suicide in the millions (I came across this article recently but can't find it ATM). - I've put "this time" multiple times. I have to admit it's a claim without scientific evidence, but circumstantial evidence combined with conversation with technologists who agree what is possible in principle, really is a strong indication. Brain emulation has nowhere to go but in the direction of "a solved problem". The estimated time frame is 10 to 15 years.
- maxharris 12y agoI found 'Humans need not apply' utterly unconvincing. For instance, the example cited regarding computer-generated music that was supposed to prove that computers could write great music. But the computer-generated music that was featured in the video sounded obviously like computer-generated music, and not something that I would ever listen to.
- ivanca 12y agoThe irony there is that music is going downhill anyways, without needing to be automatized, because now you buy songs instead of albums/discs or just listen to them using youtube or some free streaming service. Plus there may be a finite number of songs -distinguishable by the human hear- than can be created. Plus, single examples are low-hanging fruit, you need to attack the main reasoning or just assert plausibility.
- Ma8ee 12y agoIt's more great music produced now than ever in history, and it is cheap and accessible for everyone. We are many orders of magnitude before we are even starting to approach the limitations of what humans can distinguish.
- ivanca 12y agoReally, "more great than ever in history"? Tell me one single group that is better than Queen, one single singer better than Syd Barrett, one single song better than Stairway to Heaven. I believe there is good music out there, but saying "more great than ever in history" is just plain false.
- Ma8ee 12y agoAnd most people are stuck in the same music they listened to during their formative years and will always consider everything done after that garbage. Consequently, for you there will never be anything better than those groups, and if I suggested anything made today you would find it incomprehensible that anyone could think that music better than your icons.