4 ms·
Yes, but those wages are rising only to the level below which robots can do the jobs cheaper. The days when working in a factory was enough for a good middle c
by mike_hearn 12y ago
Yes, but those wages are rising only to the level below which robots can do the jobs cheaper.
The days when working in a factory was enough for a good middle class life are dead and will never come back. Manufacturing, long term, is likely to look like agriculture does today: employing only a relative handful of people.
This leaves the question of what everyone else does. Computer programming? I'd really like the answer to be "not much because we're all so rich we don't have to work", but it seems our societies are nowhere near rich enough to pull that one off.
- humanrebar 12y ago> This leaves the question of what everyone else does. I have full confidence in humanity's unquenchable appetite for consumer goods. People with extra money tend to spend that money on something (hand-woven organic angora sweaters). People will all their needs met tend to make up new needs (car seats that are 100.000001% safer).
- dismal2 12y agoHow is the vast majority going to buy those goods if they don't have jobs to pay for them?
- zo1 12y agoBecause you're making it out to be some sort of binarized chicken/egg problem, where I'd say it's more of a grey-mush of chicken and egg mixed into one. They feed off of eachother, whether up or down the spiral of wealth.
- YokoZar 12y agoThis line of reasoning still works even if it's only a few people buying things (think excessively rich people buying ever increasing numbers of luxury goods). In reality the marginal propensity to consume is greater the less money you make, so there's an argument to be made that increases in wealth disparity might in and of themselves cause a decrease in consumption. It gets complicated though, as when people don't consume with dollars they invest them, and invested dollars are ultimately spent on something too.
- justincormack 12y agoInvested money is spent on something but only if someone wants to borrow the money. Now the financial system has got very good at recycling the savings of the rich into more borrowing of the poor (subprime loans), but it is hard to see this continuing at that rate. The rich largely want risk free savings (in aggregate), so the banks turned high risk loans into risk free savings, with the government backstopping them. This has not been working too well. The vast majority of wealth is looking for safe assets (except the Elon Musks) which effectively means people need to have jobs to pay the rentiers.
- zanny 12y agoThat, and invested money is not cyclical in the economy. Yes, the invested spend it on something, but only on the pretense that future returns of theirs will go back to the original investor with interest. The only exchange of resources there is the time between having money now and giving more money back later. Compared to more equitable economics where the baker gives the mechanist bread to fix the milkmans car who gives the baker milk, and each of them is using cash received from the other to provide goods for their wants and needs, is much more tantamount of a functioning economy than loans, especially when investment money seeks the safest of avenues for returns, thus the vast majority of potential entrepreneurs are out of scope of getting the money anyway.
- digikata 12y agoWe go explore space because that opens up a wide realm of new possibilities and problems to solve.
- zo1 12y agoI sincerely hope we grow as a society in this regard. And not allow ourselves to be held back by the constant drain of propping up the unproductive, instead of letting them stumble and reach for their dreams.
- redthrowaway 12y ago>The days when working in a factory was enough for a good middle class life are dead and will never come back. Manufacturing, long term, is likely to look like agriculture does today: employing only a relative handful of people. I'd modify that somewhat. The days when working in a factory as an unskilled labourer paid a middle class income are over, but someone still needs to install, maintain, and program the robots. Those jobs are likely to pay better than the unskilled labour the robots made redundant, but there will be fewer of them.
- donrememberpass 12y agoA lot fewer...
- eli_gottlieb 12y ago>This leaves the question of what everyone else does. Computer programming? I'd really like the answer to be "not much because we're all so rich we don't have to work", but it seems our societies are nowhere near rich enough to pull that one off. In the First World, we are that rich (in terms of per-capita GDP/national income/mean income), but people have an irritating tendency to hold that not-working-for-a-living is a capital-V Vice and that working-for-a-lot-of-money is a capital-V Virtue. It can go to such extreme lengths that people often believe (sometimes against their own class interest) that (high productivity) white-collar jobs are less virtuous than (low productivity) blue-collar ones, and often believe low-salary jobs (like teaching, factory work, manual labor, service-sector positions, and trades) are less virtuous than high-salary jobs (like banking, corporate law, programming, and management).
- vinceguidry 12y agoI dunno. I like work. I like going into work, I like solving the problems that get presented to me at work, I like the challenge of working with other people to get shit done. A lot of people hate their jobs. I think it's these people that are hoping one day that the technological wonderland comes where nobody has to work, but the real answer is to manage human labor better. I think that even if we implement basic income, I think after a little while we'll all be back to work. Reason is people have this deep need to feel useful to each other. They want to feel like they matter. Most people don't at their jobs, but like I said, I think it's because management hasn't evolved to that point. I don't think we'll ever get a world where no one has to work, at least not until we find the world where nobody wants to not work.
- bronbron 12y ago> I think that even if we implement basic income, I think after a little while we'll all be back to work. The point of a basic income is that people will go back to work on things they're truly passionate about, without fear of becoming homeless. e.g. a mailroom worker might be really passionate about woodworking, but isn't skilled enough (or confident enough) to make it his profession. With a basic income, he might decide that he can make a go at woodworking without starving to death.
- Ma8ee 12y agoOur societies as a whole are rich enough that we all could work much less than we do. That would of course require quite a different distribution of the wealth that we produce.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoThat point about manufacturing looking like agriculture hit me hard - it's brilliant - thank you. Worrying too, but insightful.