3 ms·
Sounds to me more like an argument against leaving basic medical and pharmaceutical research up to the private sector. All of humanity benefits from this resea
by CamperBob2 12y ago
Sounds to me more like an argument against leaving basic medical and pharmaceutical research up to the private sector. All of humanity benefits from this research, so all of humanity should fund it... and no subset of humanity should be permitted to monopolize it, much less be encouraged to do so.
He took his Ivy-league physics PhD to Wall Street, because you're never going to get rich working in a research lab.
Probably the right choice. I doubt he'll miss out any Nobel Prizes as a result.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sliverstorm 12y agoSure, maybe it belongs in the public sector. But with current estimates of $1-5B R&D per successful new drug, it's not exactly chump change. The US gov't doesn't have a couple spare hundred billion kicking around, ready to point at drug research. So that will be a long time coming...
- lappa 12y agoHow do you propose having all of humanity fund it? A country could pay for it with their tax dollars, but then it is only a subset of the world having their paycheck decreased in order to help the entirety of humanity. You need a certain amount of wealth in the country to be able to fund all this research and the US probably could afford it, but since were not going to use patents, taxpayers may become upset that a large portion of their tax dollars are going to foreign aid rather than domestic aid.
- CamperBob2 12y agoIdeally, it wouldn't be a case where one country shoulders the burden. If there are any justifications at all for multinational cooperation, this would probably be an easy sell. We already devote a massive amount of funding to foreign aid -- about $48 billion in economic and military assistance in 2012 according to Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_foreign_aid http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_foreign_aid). We sent about $13 billion to Afghanistan and Pakistan alone in 2012, according to nationalpriorities.org. This is a pretty good match for private-sector pharmaceutical R&D expenditures, about $51 billion in 2013 according to one industry lobbyist (www.phrma.org).
- Retric 12y agoI don't know if the 3+ billion in military aid to Israel sould really be in the same bucket as say fighting Ebola. Then again the pharmaceutical R&D numbers are also vastly inflated.
- CamperBob2 12y agoYeah, I was just addressing the point about the American public being upset about so much money going to what could be construed as foreign aid. It already does, and nobody evidently cares.
- lappa 12y ago$48million is a few cents per person. The US private R&D spending is over $100billion. Spending $3000 per person on what would be mostly foreign aid (7bn vs 300mn people) would be controversial.
- CamperBob2 12y agoThat's 48 billion in US terms (1 x 10^9).
- lappa 12y agoThanks for the correction. Anyways, at least tripling foreign aid (maybe multiplying it by 10-100) is something that would be controversial.