4 ms·
This is as useless as calling 911. Your only options during an actual attack are either disabling the attacker or escaping, and you have about two seconds to ac
by leephillips 12y ago
This is as useless as calling 911. Your only options during an actual attack are either disabling the attacker or escaping, and you have about two seconds to accomplish either one. Anyone who eventually arrives to assist you will only be there to help identify your body, gather forensic evidence, or load you into an ambulance. This site flashes images of self defense weapons and refers to them as joining the violence. They are peddling a dangerous fantasy. I suggest Sam Harris' excellent essay on the reality of violence: http://www.samharris.org/blog/item/the-truth-about-violence http://www.samharris.org/blog/item/the-truth-about-violence
- mikeash 12y agoI find it odd that you categorize "load you into an ambulance" as "useless". Isn't getting help after the fact still extremely valuable in many cases?
- orclev 12y agoI think his point was more that if you had an actual weapon you could use it to defend yourself and not need loading into the ambulance in the first place.
- Anderkent 12y agoExcept of course the kind of violence that people are often concerned about takes a while, and having a panic button that conspiciously calls for help can be quite useful. If you're just being robbed, you just give them your money; but if you're about to be raped and/or kidnapped, this could quite possibly save your life.
- hga 12y agoSome caveats to that advice: Thus, if someone sticks a gun in your face and demands your wallet, you should hand it over without hesitation—and run. That depends; statistics say those who resist violent crime have better outcomes. It's something you should play by ear rather than blindly follow the above advice, the statistics are undoubtedly biased by people resisting when it makes sense. Even if you are at home, in possession of a firearm, and well trained to use it, when confronted by an intruder your best defense is to get out of the house as quickly as possible. In such a circumstance, a gun is a means of ensuring that no one can block your exit. This above is very iffy advice. Not only do you have much stronger legal protections inside your house, you're likely to have much greater control over the situation, and control is perhaps his main message. You know your house, can benefit from concealment and maybe even cover (that which a bullet cannot penetrate), you don't know the situation outside the house. You might escape only to be surprised by an armed accomplice. Or suppose you do this just as the police arrive; more than a few armed homeowners have gotten shot by police mistaking them for criminals. You also need to balance this advice about decreasing the risk to your physical skin with the psychological toll fleeing takes. Nothing good ever comes to people who allow themselves to be moved to a remote location at the mercy of a violent predator. In my Missouri concealed carry class they ran us through a simulator with police "shoot/don't shoot" scenarios. For mine, I would have been a lot more aggressive and would have tried to shoot at various times if I'd know the terrible statistics of the above which the instructor mentioned after it. As for his advice to flee and leave your spouse or children to the tender mercies of someone who, as he notes, has demonstrated he wants more than your property, if you have any other option I don't want to know you. That includes your being in such a situation because you decided not to procure one or more firearms prior to the incident. After I left home, I only procured firearms after I had a significant other to protect, or vice versa. At that point it was an obligation, no matter what obstacles Massachusetts put in place (which aren't really that bad for long guns, although that may be changing depending on the city you live in). On the other hand, I picked up a very hard rule about hostages from Jerry Pournelle in The Mote in God's Eye: at that point, you mentally treat the situation as if the criminal has killed the hostages, even if you then try to rescue them. In this situation, as the author says, you don't increase the toll by submitting yourself as well. The odds are very high that will make the situation worse. Final note, underlying a lot of what he says: if someone unknown knocks on the door, I don't answer without having a gun in my hand. If I'm expecting someone, I confirm it's them before opening the door. Or per a rule of Marine general James Mattis WRT to being in Iraq or Afghanistan during our recent unpleasantness, which addresses even more points the author made: "Be polite, be professional, but have a plan to kill everybody you meet."
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hga 12y agoI should note that I put my gun away after determining the caller is legit. As for defending the family, going back to frontier times we're not that sexist, e.g. my father taught me and all my siblings how to hunt, fish, shoot and drive, and my younger sister still schools "the boys" when her husband and friends go skeet shooting.
- agarden 12y agoThe first recommended read at the end of the Harris article, _The Gift of Fear_ by Gavin de Becker, agrees generally with Harris but offers a more nuanced approach. He says to trust your gut. Occasionally cooperating does work. Standing up can also get you out of a pickle. But if you have a bad feeling, run with it and don't look back. Couldn't agree more about leaving your family to an intruder. By all means call the police, and by all means stand and fight.
- mikeash 12y ago"...if someone unknown knocks on the door, I don't answer without having a gun in my hand." Holy crap. Do we live on the same planet? Being murdered by an unknown assailant who knocks on my door is so far down my list of risks and fears that it doesn't even register. I'm far more worried about being hit by a bus as I cross the street, or my car spontaneously catching fire in my garage. Sure, it could happen, but so could a meteor that obliterates my house, and it hardly seems worth any effort.
- hga 12y agoIt's a casual yet deadly serious precaution, much like looking both ways and listening before crossing the street, or being careful whenever I smell smoke. "Any" effort? You admit the risk is non-zero (and it's certainly a lot greater than that meteor), for me the effort is rather low, since I keep that gun handy for whenever I go outside and carry it concealed. Let's add an additional dimension: this precaution is so easy it would be downright embarrassing to not take it and then get bushwacked.
- circlefavshape 12y ago> the probability that you will be robbed, assaulted, raped or murdered at some point over the next 30 years is 1 in 16 Isn't this a little disingenuous? "Robbed" includes you being pickpocketed, or someone stealing your TV from your apartment while you're at work. If you're going to be raped or murdered, it's most likely not going to be a predator that does it, but someone you know. What's the probability that you will experience violence at the hands of a stranger? That is the relevant statistic