3 ms·
I haven't seen any data to suggest that media coverage causes a net increase in the rate of suicide, nor even a clear claim that this is the case. I don't doubt
by baddox 12y ago
I haven't seen any data to suggest that media coverage causes a net increase in the rate of suicide, nor even a clear claim that this is the case. I don't doubt that coverage would cause clustering of suicide timing and method, or that certain types of coverage would cause a net increase in rate relative to other types of coverage. I'm just skeptical that a complete lack of coverage would be the optimum.
- dang 12y agoI haven't seen any data to suggest that media coverage causes a net increase in the rate of suicide, nor even a clear claim that this is the case. "The suicides that follow these stories are excess deaths. After the initial spurt, the suicide rates do not drop below traditional levels but only return to those levels." https://fc.deltasd.bc.ca/~dmatthews/FOV2-00074762/S02DB0598.2/Cialdini%20airplane%20studies.pdf https://fc.deltasd.bc.ca/~dmatthews/FOV2-00074762/S02DB0598.... The studies Cialdini writes about in that chapter are older, because his book is older. If anyone can report on more recent work, please do. This is worrisome stuff.
- thaumaturgy 12y agoThat is an excerpt from a book about using psychology for the purposes of persuasion in marketing. It was not a study on the memetic effects of suicide reporting, which aspects of the reporting might contribute to contagion, or a treatise on untreated depression or suicide. I read that PDF. Twice. It makes some ... great leaps of conclusion and assumption, without much in the way of investigation or data. It concludes for example that young people intentionally fatally drove their cars into trees because they read articles about suicide, but it presents no actual evidence for that case other than a statistical correlation. As is mentioned frequently on HN, correlation in statistics is tricky: http://tylervigen.com/ http://tylervigen.com/ I don't think we have enough information at hand to suppress discussion of depression or suicide.
- dang 12y agoOf course the chapter isn't itself a study of the effects of suicide reporting—it's an overview of such studies. It's an excerpt from a well-known popular treatment of social psychology, written by a researcher and duly stocked with references [1]. Assuming that Cialdini isn't misrepresenting that literature, I don't see how anyone without a preconceived opinion wouldn't take serious pause at the findings he reports. If you're going to dismiss them you'll need to do a lot better than the usual handwave about correlation. Let's hear from someone who knows about the latest work on this, or some evidence that those findings are bogus. 1. I mean the book, not the pdf. Obviously I would link to the book if I could; it happens not to be online. The pdf is, and it at least covers the main points (as I recall them—I read the book years ago).
- thaumaturgy 12y ago> Let's hear from someone who knows about the latest work on this, or some evidence that those findings are bogus. We won't get to, because every time the subject comes up now on HN, someone says, "don't talk about this, it's dangerous."
- dang 12y agoI know it's tricky, because it's a subject that evokes strong feelings (in me too), but a substantive post on serious research into this would not be off topic here.