5 ms·
The solution is not to jail the whistleblowers, or to question the patriotism of those who tell their stories, but to do what Attorney General Edward Levi coura
by ilamont 12y ago
The solution is not to jail the whistleblowers, or to question the patriotism of those who tell their stories, but to do what Attorney General Edward Levi courageously attempted to do more than a third of a century ago – to have the criminal division of the Justice Department conduct a thorough investigation, and then to prosecute any member of the intelligence community who has broken the law, whether by illegally spying on Americans or by lying to Congress.
Until the guilty are prosecuted, there won't be any real change in the way that the U.S. intelligence agencies operate. Half-measures and bullshit platitudes from the powers that be are insufficient. Justice must be served, and if necessary, people need to go to jail.
- TrainedMonkey 12y agoI agree with general sentiment, that things are suboptimal, but when prosecuting people where do you draw the line? This is no easy problem that can be readily solved.
- araes 12y agoWell, the default position for everyone who's there should be that they are innocent. Then, Justice needs to investigate, and determine: 1) Was something legally done wrong (could be what we'd consider "morally" wrong, but still legal)? [If yes, go 2)] 2) Does it appear that it was knowingly done wrong? [If yes, go 3)] 3) Is there an evidence trail supporting that it was knowingly done wrong? [If yes, go 4, else, check the separate case for evidence destruction] 4) Does that evidence supply enough burden of proof for specific individuals that a reasonable case could be built against them with a good chance of Justice winning? [If yes, go 5, else, go 6] 5 - yes?) Prosecute as many of those people as possible to signal that bad social behaviour has consequences (similar to the banker argument) 6 - no?) Is there enough to support a general recrimination of the agency and to press for legal changes to its procedures? [If yes, go 7, else, go 8] 7 - yes?) Recommend a set of changes which in the future would help to ensure that insight / oversight isn't just a paper tiger. 8 - no?) Welp, we're boned for now.
- rdtsc 12y ago> Until the guilty are prosecuted, there won't be any real change in the way that the U.S. intelligence agencies operate. I disagree. There will be changes, but for the worse. Because now those running the programs have a real world validated proof that people don't care and there are no consequences. So that is a good signal to crank up the level a few notches.
- deedeedum 12y agoAnd: The handful of owners of the monopolistic media and entertainment industry have managed to make about 50% of US citizens believe that Snowden is a traitor, not a hero. This means you should not expect any pressure to come from the US public/voters and therefor there is no change to expect from the US as a nation.
- n09n 12y agoIf all the facts are on their side, why do you continue to claim it's worse?
- mikeash 12y agoI think it's worse than that. Many people do care, in the opposite way that we think they should. There are a lot of people who outright approve of these programs because they think they're necessary and that they help keep us safe. I personally think that all the outrage at the government is misplaced. They are ultimately just doing what the people want. The US isn't groping airline passengers and holding terror suspects for years without trial and torturing people for information and spying on its own citizens because the government is running out of control and the people can't reign it in. They're doing these things because "the people", as a whole, want it. Demand it in many cases. If we want change, we must convince the population of our views. The rest will follow naturally if that can be done. No, I have no idea how.
- nitrogen 12y agoThe government may be giving people what they want, but it also knows how to convince people to want what they get.
- zeteo 12y ago> Justice must be served, and if necessary, people need to go to jail. Do you really think sending a few scapegoats to prison will solve anything? The problems are systemic. Some faces may change but the agencies remain organized and financed the same way.
- AnimalMuppet 12y agoBut why are the problems systemic? Because some highly-placed people changed policy. Jail them. Don't jail every peon for following the rules as given to them (though they should not have done so). Jail every high-level person who didn't follow the rules as given to them, i.e., the Constitution.
- theworst 12y agoI recommend reading Hannah Arendt's "Eichmann in Jerusalem". Arendt discusses this very issue WRT Nazis in WW2 -- in most cases, the systems are structured in such a way that there isn't an evil overlord making those decisions. Even amongst the Nazis, most high level people had compartmentalized knowledge that was only evil when combined. Indeed, the subtitle and thesis of the book reflects that: "on the banality of evil." Her theory is that unethical organizations can structure themselves in such a way that almost nobody is actively breaking the law.
- pieter_mj 12y agoMany of the scientists operating/designing these facilities Bamford mentioned in the article were actual Nazis brought into the US through operation paperclip. Hardly surprising the organisations that employ them feel they're above the law.
- herge 12y ago> Hardly surprising the organisations that employ them feel they're above the law. The U.S. Army feels that it is above the law?
- 12y ago
- freedom123 12y agowhich is what i said but its at the bottom of this post.