3 ms·
A big problem with spinning disks is that storage grows inversely with the area of the dots, while reading and writing speed grow inversely with the diameter of
by Someone 12y ago
A big problem with spinning disks is that storage grows inversely with the area of the dots, while reading and writing speed grow inversely with the diameter of the dots.
If you store 100 times as much data, all else being equal, time to write a full disk will be ten times as large.
Ways around that are increasing rotation speed (been there, done that. There is little to gain here without making the disk a lot stronger = heavier, if that is really possible at all) and using multiple heads (harder to do, but may eventually be the better solution, certainly if one can completely do away with head movements)
- Retric 12y agoA 50GB Blueray disk can be written in 12 Minutes with a home burner but a few seconds in mass production. Scaling that up this would be (1,000,000 / 50) = 20,000 times the space but take sqrt(20,000) * 12min = 28 hours to write at home. However, assuming you can R/W at the same rate that's 10GB / second speed which might be tough for a home PC to pull off anytime soon. PS: I suspect if this where ever out into production they would change the form factor to enable even faster R/W speeds and a significantly reduced capacity.
- delecti 12y agoBandwidth increasing proportional with the square root of the storage growth is a pretty great trend. If anything that sounds like a plus.
- tgb 12y agoLooks like it gives 2.9 gigabits per second for a 5cm disk radius at 5000 rpm. http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=5000rpm+*+(2*pi*5cm)%2F(9nm)+in+1%2Fs http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=5000rpm+*+(2*pi*5cm)%2F...
- ridgeguy 12y agoStronger ≠ heavier. The parameter of interest is specific strength, which is the material's (ultimate tensile strength/density). I forget what the plastic in DVDs is, but it could probably be reinforced with carbon fibers (chopped, nanotubes, etc.) to give a useful increase in rotation speed.
- Someone 12y agoYou are right and I am not an structural engineer, but I understand that pure strength isn't the only limiting factor for disk; they start wobbling before they tear apart (http://superuser.com/questions/554717/will-there-ever-be-faster-cd-and-dvd-discs-and-writers http://superuser.com/questions/554717/will-there-ever-be-fas...). That, I think, is more a matter of thickness than of pure tensile strength. Barring the construction of hollow disks, that means heavier ones. Also, now I think a bit more about it: in a 50-speed CD player or a 16-speed DVD player, the edge of the disk moves at about half the speed of sound. Doubling rotation speed would push it over the sound barrier. I guess it would take quite a bit of research to make a CD/DVD/BlueRay player that will work fine at those speeds (a way around that is to make the disk smaller. That would be an option for a disk with the storage density discussed here, but it wouldn't win you more than a factor of four or so, at most)
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoHow about, give up spinning it. Steer the laser, perhaps using phased diffraction patterns, and scan the disk with weightless light?