3 ms·
and the quality was "good enough". People didn't care if Beta looked 10% better than VHS, they were going from a state of not being able to record at all to bei
by bane 12y ago
and the quality was "good enough". People didn't care if Beta looked 10% better than VHS, they were going from a state of not being able to record at all to being able to record stuff. Being longer and cheaper gave it a two out of three advantage.
- avree 12y agoVery true. All these articles like to herald that "Betamax was better!" but a format that's 10% better quality and costs 400% more is not actually an improvement to mosts consumers.
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoCertain problems are like the .50 mag problem. If someone is killed with a 9mm, they are dead. If they're killed with a hand cannon .50, are they twice as dead? This is why cops, except Dirty Harry, don't carry hand cannons. If your product is better, is it better in a way the customer will pay for? If not, it's an expense, not a feature.
- hga 12y agoThis is in part a "which goal do people really care about?" thing like Betamax vs. VHS. In this context, we're legally only able to stop per se, not kill, and ignoring that, we care a lot more about stopping someone before they wound or kill us than killing them. And your examples confound velocity/energy, which at handgun velocities equal (over)penetration and greater recoil, with diameter, which per the experts I prefer increases "stopping power". Therefore .40 S&W at 10 mm diameter is very popular (it's also a shorter, lower velocity 10 mm Auto developed after the FBI etc. realized that round had too much recoil), and the venerable 1904 .45 ACP at 11.5 mm is still quite popular. Many people like me use the latter in preference to rounds with a smaller diameter that can fit many more into a magazine. Like hardware video formats, network effects matter, e.g. an unpopular round won't have many guns chambered for it, and gun models designed for 9 mm can generally accommodate .40 S&W. But they're not overwhelming, it's not a winner take all domain like video tapes or analog video discs turned out to be, or better than DVD digital formats. For that matter, DVD essentially defeated a lot of other digital formats, but I'm not sure if any were near its quality and other advantages.
- InclinedPlane 12y agoAlso remember that we're not talking about viewing video over HDMI to a high def LCD panel, we're talking about viewing over an RF cable link to a crappy little CRT display, often badly calibrated. Under perfect conditions betamax was superior to VHS, under average viewing conditions in the typical household if you'd have done a survey asking people which video signal looked better you'd be hard pressed to get people to admit that either one was noticeably superior let alone get a consistent result showing betamax to be a better choice. It's also worth noting the costs here. In 1980 a VHS VCR cost around $800, that's $2300 adjusted for inflation. The first betamax VCRs were over $250 more expensive ($700 in today's dollars). Paying $700 more for a device which wasn't markedly superior was a sucker's bet, it's no wonder VHS was more widely adopted.