3 ms·
Aren't NASA-level standards historically slow and inefficient? I was of the impression that private parties streamlining that process and coming up with a cheap
by Karunamon 12y ago
Aren't NASA-level standards historically slow and inefficient? I was of the impression that private parties streamlining that process and coming up with a cheaper program is what led to NASA (or congress by proxy, whatever) abandoning manned spaceflight to the private sector.
In other words, maybe India is taking a leaf from SpaceX's book rather than NASA's
- hackuser 12y ago> Aren't NASA-level standards historically slow and inefficient? I've seen nothing that tells me that this reputation is anything more than 1) the bureaucracy inherent to any large organization, 2) requirements of very complex, cutting edge engineering and science, 3) requirements of engineering systems that must work perfectly the first time (unlike Facebook, NASA can't 'move fast and break things'), and perhaps most of all 4) the public's habit of attributing characteristics to 'the old established thing' (NASA) and to the 'new shiny thing' (SpaceX, etc.) Name every place in the solar system where NASA missions currently are located. Outside the solar system? Where they have gone historically? Their achievements are staggering; history-making events are routine; they are by far the greatest explorers in the history of humanity. Certainly they aren't perfect and every organization can improve, but they do pretty well. > I was of the impression that private parties streamlining that process and coming up with a cheaper program is what led to NASA (or congress by proxy, whatever) abandoning manned spaceflight to the private sector. Manned spaceflight hasn't been delegated to the private sector, only flying to Earth orbit (or only low-Earth orbit?). NASA has been doing it for 50 years; the technology is mature enough that private companies can do it and NASA can invest its resources in bigger challenges, including a manned mission to Mars (in the long term).
- wavefunction 12y agoNASA has an incredible record of success in cutting-edge technical missions far beyond any private industry that I know of. They are derided as slow and inefficient but when you consider how long those Mars rovers are lasting, well bring on more of whatever NASA is on.
- eru 12y ago> They are derided as slow and inefficient but when you consider how long those Mars rovers are lasting, well bring on more of whatever NASA is on. Depends on the cost. If someone can make a Mars Rover that costs 1% as much but lasts 10% as long, that's progress.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Depends on the cost. If someone can make a Mars Rover that costs 1% as much but lasts 10% as long, that's progress. If the rover itself costs 1% as much, probably not. If the cost of the rover plus getting it to Mars is 1% as much, sure.
- eru 12y agoYes, that's what I meant by `Mars Rover'. A Rover on earth is just an `Earth Rover'.
- ForHackernews 12y agoInteresting article about the processes that go into writing software supporting manned spaceflight at NASA: http://www.fastcompany.com/28121/they-write-right-stuff http://www.fastcompany.com/28121/they-write-right-stuff