2 ms·
> Anyway, it would be really helpful if people like yourself understood what Apple does "right/better" so maybe others, like the open source community, could pr
by laumars 12y ago
> Anyway, it would be really helpful if people like yourself understood what Apple does "right/better" so maybe others, like the open source community, could produce better products.
Slightly rude don't you think? Who are "people like [me]"? And why do you assume that we don't know what Apple does right?
Can we not discuss the contributions of businesses to technology without making cheap shots at one another?
- melling 12y agoYour comments indicate that you don't understand. You think Apple PR rewrote history? Seriously? "I don't know if that's because Apple PR team have done a wonderful job rewriting history; or because Apple happened to build the most successful product of that era that it made other products before it seem forgettable."
- laumars 12y agoI also said "or because Apple happened to build the most successful product of that era that it made other products before it seem forgettable" - it's called giving a balanced argument.
- melling 12y agoCan you answer why they built such a successful/memorable product? Also, consider that Android overtook iOS pretty quickly. http://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/chart32.jpg http://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/chart3...
- laumars 12y agoI already had - a few times in fact. Apple combined a lot of desirable technologies into a well polished and aesthetically pleasing product. I've also repeatedly said they do deserve a place in the history books. I'm not trying to dismiss the quality of the iPhone, I'm only discussing whether it deserves to be defined as "the first modern smart phone" when there were lot's of other similar products before it. And if it does deserve that accolade, then do the other handsets deserve a footnote? I don't understand why it's such a taboo to discuss the achievements of Apple and their competitors, but a lot of people seem to have reacted very negatively.
- melling 12y agoWhat value is there in deciding if Apple had the first modern smartphone? It's a highly subjective opinion, which will probably change several times over the next decade. Just a conversation that takes people in the weeds. Sorry, I don't want to have that nerd fight.