3 ms·
> Apple iPhone - First Modern Smartphone. Depends on your definition of "modern". The iPhone wasn't the first to support apps (Windows Mobile / CE handsets ha
by laumars 12y ago
> Apple iPhone - First Modern Smartphone.
Depends on your definition of "modern".
The iPhone wasn't the first to support apps (Windows Mobile / CE handsets had been around for a while, but they weren't nice to use as a "phone". Also plenty of feature phones, eg most of Sony Ericsson's pre-Android range- supported apps too).
If you meant "the first smart-phone form-factor", then there were Nokia and sony handsets long before the iPhone. But they weren't all that great from many of the accounts I heard (which always put me off buying one). Blackberry and Palm (remember them) also had some great offerings for their era too.
If you meant the "first with capacitive touch screen", then LG beat Apple to the market with an iPhone-like device by a few months.
However Apple's iPhone is still the handset we all remember as being the groundbreaker. I don't know if that's because Apple PR team have done a wonderful job rewriting history; or because Apple happened to build the most successful product of that era that it made other products before it seem forgettable. Maybe a bit of both. But in any case, I think if you want to credit the iPhone for it's importance in history then it's only fair to credit the numerous other handsets which preceded it and pioneered the various different technologies and paradigms that Apple then went on and merge together so effectively.
- Aloha 12y agoApple was the first one to put all of those things together in a single package that really worked well - thats what I mean by first modern :-P
- laumars 12y agoWell that's now more a question of personal bias / preference than something that can be defined as cold, hard fact. What worked for you might not have been someone else's preferred method of using a smart phone. As well polished as the iPhone was, I found many of its design implimentations worked against the way I liked to use a smart phone. And I think the fact that Symbian (amongst others) outsold iOS for the first few years of the iPhone's life would suggest that I wasn't alone. So I think even by that measure, it's still unfair to exclude other handsets of the same generation which were just as popular. But then I guess history is written by the victors, not the other pioneers who've since fallen by the wayside.
- Aloha 12y agoApple took the smart phone from something used by technologists and other tech oriented people, and turned it into a mass market appliance accessible to everyone - every smart phone that has come since is related to it in form and function.
- laumars 12y agoIf Apple held a majority market share, then I might agree, but as I said before, Symbian et al had a larger market share so they must have had some degree of mass market appeal as well. edit: just to clarify. I do agree that the iPhone deserve a place in the history books because it did change the landscape significantly. But my point was that the iPhone wasn't the first phone of it's ilk (probably the best all rounder and definitely best at specific criteria, but those are point I'm enjoying discussing here). In light of that, if the iPhone deserves a place then equally the handsets that pioneered much of the technology and paradigms which Apple beautifully combined, those other handsets deserves a mention too (like how scientific papers based on original research still need to draw from the pool of existing research and thus even new theories owe credit other publications)
- coob 12y agoLook at browser stats. Symbian was irrelevant compared to the iPhone is terms of popular usage as an actual internet device.
- laumars 12y agoI accept that, but to a lot of people a smart phone is more than just a web browser.
- nicholassmith 12y agoSymbian had a larger market as Nokia were throwing it on as many devices as they could, irregardless of whether it worked well so they saturated the market. Plus they were commonly called featurephones and not smartphones.
- rimantas 12y agoApart for UI the other major factor was a browser and a browsing experience which did not suck.
- laumars 12y agoI'd argue that the LG Prada beat the iPhone in terms of the first capacitive phone with a touch-centric UI. However I can't comment on how good it's browser was; but even the Prada aside, you make a very good point about how other handsets had terrible web browsers. In fact "terrible" is possibly being too kind.
- melling 12y agoYeah, yeah, everyone stands on other people's shoulders. Everyone knows that. Apple built the phone everyone was waiting for. People had Palm Pilots, Blackberry's, Zaurus', etc. I also had a $600 Microsoft CE phone with a slide out keyboard. The first time that I tried to install Opera, the phone hung and I couldn't use the phone. I'm standing at my bus stop trying to call my ride and the freakin phone doesn't work, won't even reboot! Anyway, it would be really helpful if people like yourself understood what Apple does "right/better" so maybe others, like the open source community, could produce better products.
- laumars 12y ago> Anyway, it would be really helpful if people like yourself understood what Apple does "right/better" so maybe others, like the open source community, could produce better products. Slightly rude don't you think? Who are "people like [me]"? And why do you assume that we don't know what Apple does right? Can we not discuss the contributions of businesses to technology without making cheap shots at one another?
- melling 12y agoYour comments indicate that you don't understand. You think Apple PR rewrote history? Seriously? "I don't know if that's because Apple PR team have done a wonderful job rewriting history; or because Apple happened to build the most successful product of that era that it made other products before it seem forgettable."
- laumars 12y agoI also said "or because Apple happened to build the most successful product of that era that it made other products before it seem forgettable" - it's called giving a balanced argument.
- melling 12y agoCan you answer why they built such a successful/memorable product? Also, consider that Android overtook iOS pretty quickly. http://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/chart32.jpg http://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/chart3...
- simonh 12y agoAll you seem to be saying is that the iPhone was not the first smartphone. That's not controversial, and that's not what was said. The question is, how do we define _modern_ smartphone. >LG beat Apple to the market with an iPhone-like device by a few months Ok, I'm wasting my time.
- laumars 12y agoThe OP said "first modern smart phone"; not first nor modern, but "first modern". So the question I raised was to determine a measure of "modern" which of which other smart phones did not exist. I'm not trying to be controversial nor argumentative. But if someone states something as being the "first modern x" then we need to establish what "modern" means before we can agree on whether it was the first of it's ilk. > Ok, I'm wasting my time. You've only posted one comment. Surely it would make more sense to at least wait for my response before jumping in with derogatory remarks about a pointless argument? And what is it with people being over sensitive on this subject. I've had personal attacks and been down voted several times for just daring to have a balanced conversation about Apple. What the hell has happened to HN that we can't even have friendly conversations any more?
- simonh 12y agoIt's ok, you've convinced me. The LG Prada was the first modern smartphone.