3 ms·
Almost certainly not. Biological systems are deeply complicated intertangled nests of cause and effect; when you measure a correlation between two variables (su
by gwern 12y ago
Almost certainly not. Biological systems are deeply complicated intertangled nests of cause and effect; when you measure a correlation between two variables (such as being depressed and lower/higher levels of RNA X), it's not going to be a direct causal link, you're much more likely to have picked up on a distant indirect relationship. (I have an essay on this topic which you might have seen on HN before: http://gwern.net/Causality http://gwern.net/Causality )
In this case, if you skim the depression literature, you'll find depression linked with all sorts of things - too much sleep, too little sleep, weight changes, poorer cognitive performance, high inflammation levels, bad eating habits, stimulants, etc etc. Any of these could be a good predictor of depression but changing them will not help or may harm. (If a depressed person finds modafinil helps them get through the day, a naive investigator may find modafinil correlates with depression - and take it away. Not going to help.)