2 ms·
Mods: what happened to the word "suicides" in the title of this story? It's not omitted to fit the 80 character limit; the title with the word included is stil
by smacktoward 12y ago
Mods: what happened to the word "suicides" in the title of this story?
It's not omitted to fit the 80 character limit; the title with the word included is still underneath that.
It's not omitted because the article isn't about suicides; there's three of them discussed.
I submitted the link, and I could have sworn I just copied and pasted the full title it's running under at Re/code, which is "The Downtown Project Suicides: Can the Pursuit of Happiness Kill You?"
If I'm misremembering and the word wasn't in the submission, I apologize in advance. But if it was there, and someone took it out, that seems like it does a real disservice to the article by downplaying the gravity of what it's actually about. (I'd edit it myself to put it in, but it looks like my window for editing the submission has closed.)
- dang 12y agoWe took it out because it's obviously baity. "Kill you" is enough bait for one title. Edit: My mistake; we'll put it back. Edit 2: Now that this thread has subsided, there was another reason why I edited the title that way. Ever since I read Cialdini's "Influence" I've been sensitive to the dismaying evidence that publishing suicides encourages some people to kill themselves. I felt uneasy having a title blaring the word "Suicides" about a tragic story—in the startup world, especially—on HN's front page. No doubt the Werther Effect is small, but this is a law-of-large-numbers situation, so I'd rather over-react than under-react. If anyone happens to be having suicidal thoughts around here: please tell someone. If you don't have anyone to tell, tell me. My email is in my profile.
- crazygringo 12y agoThe whole article is about suicides. It's in the title, it's in the first paragraph and continues throughout. The article isn't about anything except for suicides. And the word "suicide" is much clearer than "kill you" -- which is so vague it sounds like it could be recreational drug overdose, for instance. Sorry, but there isn't the slightest thing "baity" about it.
- zorpner 12y agoRemoving "suicides" and leaving "kill you" makes it sound far more like Betteridge link-bait than the original. Also, it's pretty disrespectful to the author to remove words at random from their chosen headline because you think something sounds better.
- RangerScience 12y agoDefinitely agreeing with the others that "Kill you" is more bait than "Suicides", particularly given the actual story. One of these implies an article about things that have actually happened, the other an article about things that might... How about something like "The Downtown Project Suicides: The danger with pursuing happiness" or even just "The Downtown Project Suicides"
- ObviousScience 12y agoMan, you guys consistently make poor edits to titles. Remove an informative part of the title to leave the baity bit? Must be Hacker News!