8 ms·
First Blood Test to Diagnose Depression in Adults?
- zoba 12y agoI'm curious what happens if the markers are removed. For example, if one of the markers is that you've got too much X in your system, and you take a drug that binds to X and then is flushed out of your system - do you stay depressed?
- ufo 12y agoI doubt it would help as those mmarkers are more likely an innocuous byproduct than a cause of the problem. RNA is something that does its job inside the cells and I'm actually surprised that they can get useful markers from blood.
- lutusp 12y agoNot likely. Many of these indicators are tangentially related to depression, they're not causative agents -- or we don't know enough to be able to make that claim. This may seem to be a trite example, but many diseases are accompanied by a fever. But treating the fever doesn't treat the disease, and in some cases you're better of letting the fever abate on its own.
- gwern 12y agoAlmost certainly not. Biological systems are deeply complicated intertangled nests of cause and effect; when you measure a correlation between two variables (such as being depressed and lower/higher levels of RNA X), it's not going to be a direct causal link, you're much more likely to have picked up on a distant indirect relationship. (I have an essay on this topic which you might have seen on HN before: http://gwern.net/Causality http://gwern.net/Causality ) In this case, if you skim the depression literature, you'll find depression linked with all sorts of things - too much sleep, too little sleep, weight changes, poorer cognitive performance, high inflammation levels, bad eating habits, stimulants, etc etc. Any of these could be a good predictor of depression but changing them will not help or may harm. (If a depressed person finds modafinil helps them get through the day, a naive investigator may find modafinil correlates with depression - and take it away. Not going to help.)
- pessimizer 12y agoThis doesn't look like a yes/no test; it seems more astrological.
- gwern 12y agoCoyne's "How to critique claims of a “blood test for depression”" http://blogs.plos.org/mindthebrain/2014/09/25/critique-claims-blood-test-depression/ http://blogs.plos.org/mindthebrain/2014/09/25/critique-claim... ; summary: 1. priors for the phenomenon imply many small correlates, and past results have failed to replicate 2. low statistical power for claimed results, from both planned & post hoc perspective 3. small sample biases: can't estimate accurately (without relatively exotic techniques) when p>n 4. measurement error in diagnosing depression: investigators chose a self-report of lower reliability compared to the available alternative data from a more reliable interview that they had, 5. substantial & likely biased attrition of subjects 6. correlational result is confounded by antidepressant usage, smoking, etc (many things correlate with being depressed, so any blood test may be picking out those instead) and by the small sample size, results may not generalize 7. failing multiple-comparison correction of final results
- kens 12y agoIt may not be clear from the above summary that the "How to critique" link discusses this blood test and why it's probably wrong. I really recommend reading it - it's pretty convincing. One other thing, looking at the original paper, the affected RNAs look pretty random. I'd find it more convincing if these RNAs suggested some possible connection to depression, e.g. if they were for brain receptors rather than spleen genes or generic metabolism genes. Of course the body is complicated and anything could possibly affect depression...
- nkurz 12y agoHaving posted this link, I feel bad for calling attention to a weak study when I'd only read the press release. Yet I'm glad that doing so resulted in someone (Gwern) providing a link to this excellent analytical rebuttal that I probably wouldn't have encountered otherwise.
- lutusp 12y ago> Having posted this link, I feel bad for calling attention to a weak study when I'd only read the press release. There's no need to feel bad about this. People here are pretty sophisticated about this topic and we welcome discussions of dubious science -- it tunes our skepticism. :)
- rmxt 12y agoFree link to the published paper, "Blood transcriptomic biomarkers in adult primary care patients with major depressive disorder undergoing cognitive behavioral therapy": http://www.nature.com/tp/journal/v4/n9/full/tp201466a.html http://www.nature.com/tp/journal/v4/n9/full/tp201466a.html
- jrapdx3 12y agoThe article presents a rather stark claim that nine RNA "markers" in a blood sample "were able to diagnose depression". Unfortunately, the article is shy on the details necessary to evaluate the merit of the claim. Since depression is a quite heterogeneous condition, it's unlikely that any particular test will give unambiguous results in every subset of depressed patients. There's bound to be "fuzziness" in a substantial portion of cases. ATM I don't have time to discuss the subject in any depth, but I do think the problem is going to be the media reporting this as an absolute fact, not only terribly misleading to the public, but even worse, undermining the researchers' good efforts.
- virtue3 12y agoI was wondering about the accurateness of a test against the fuzziness of the diagnoses as well. There really is an absolutely huge gamut in severity and type of mental disorder and it's so so painful. I was sincerely hoping this test setup would at least start to help alleviate the "lets try this anti-depressent until you feel better, and if that doesn't work hit you with another one" type random debugging on people's brains.
- Florin_Andrei 12y ago> I do think the problem is going to be the media reporting this as an absolute fact, not only terribly misleading to the public, but even worse, undermining the researchers' good efforts. This tends to apply to a very large fraction of all science-related news.
- roywiggins 12y agoThis isn't even news, it's a press release.
- seanflyon 12y agoI don't think depression is well enough defined for an unambiguous test to even be possible. Google defines depression as "severe despondency and dejection, typically felt over a period of time and accompanied by feelings of hopelessness and inadequacy" which is a reasonable definition, but it really just means "very very sad". When we say someone is suffering from depression does that imply that the cause is medical in nature (not because something horrible happened to them)? How sad does someone have to be before they reach the threshold of depression?
- virtue3 12y agoAs someone that's suffered from depression for a very long time (and totally messed up my adolescence) this is a very good thing. It is _very_ difficult to accurate diagnose these disorders and then half the time people don't believe you anyway. It's a very difficult disorder to convey to other people because it just doesn't resonate unless you've gone through it or have been clinically diagnosed (there's a huge huge difference between being down for a few weeks and having no joy in anything for years seemingly out of no where).
- lutusp 12y ago> It is _very_ difficult to accurate diagnose these disorders and then half the time people don't believe you anyway. Fair enough. Which do you think is worse -- a false positive or a false negative? I ask because this diagnostic category has plenty of both. I would want to be very sure about a depression diagnosis before assigning it, especially to young person with little life experience. These questionable diagnoses can change the direction of a person's life, possibly cause him to think of himself as permanently handicapped, brain-damaged, after a spell of the blues followed by a superficial diagnosis from a "professional". Because of how little we know about depression, most diagnoses are in a gray area. It's not like there's a blood test -- and if you've read the posts in this thread, you know by now that there isn't a blood test, there's only a press release.
- virtue3 12y agoI'm not really gonna go to deep into it but my personal feelings are a false positive would be infinitely worse. Those drugs they give you do shit to you. I've been permanently altered from taking them when I was in my adolescence (I can remember feeling _significantly_ different pre and post drugs, and I've been off for many man years). There's a reason I'm not very keen on the "keep trying them till something sticks" approach that we take with this crap. Especially with developing individuals.
- dang 12y agoNPR covered this the other day: http://www.npr.org/2014/09/28/352290040/finding-depression-in-the-blood-stream http://www.npr.org/2014/09/28/352290040/finding-depression-i... I thought about posting it to HN, but it says nothing about the actual test, other than that it might not work.
- mr_tyzic 12y agoNaively, nine markers sounds like a lot. How high is the risk of curve-fitting?
- michaelhoffman 12y agoVery high. There are standard procedures for avoiding overfitting in developing "omic" biomarker tests, which, of course, the authors did not follow.
- pc2g4d 12y agoN=32 There you go
- erehweb 12y agoWe really need to say more than just "N = 32". If you're tossing coins, and the treatment group gets 16 heads, that's a significant result. Not saying that's the case for this particular study, but general point is that N = 32 is not enough to dismiss a study out of hand.
- pc2g4d 12y agoYou'd have a stronger point if this study was an experimental intervention with binary outcomes. However, what this study was actually doing was fishing for correlations between various blood factors and depression. Thus the small sample size greatly increases the chance that some factor will "just happen" to be more likely in the 32 depressed patients than in the 32 non-depressed ones. So I stand by "N = 32" as a valid critique of the study.
- stared 12y agoThis is "too good to be true". A critique is here: http://jcoynester.wordpress.com/2014/09/23/talking-back-to-the-authors-of-the-northwestern-blood-test-for-depression-study/ http://jcoynester.wordpress.com/2014/09/23/talking-back-to-t... In short - an unexpected result, based on a very small sample and trying to give even further implications (on effectiveness of cognitive behavioral therapy).
- lutusp 12y agoQuote: " ... a breakthrough approach that provides the first objective, scientific diagnosis for depression." Wait ... an "objective, scientific diagnosis" that doesn't identify the cause of the ailment? If I visited a doctor and she said, "You're running a fever, and your blood has cooties," I wouldn't think of that as the height of medical expertise, and it's certainly not science. In science, we establish causes and then measure effects. This test measures effects. No one knows what causes depression, therapy is indistinguishable from the placebo effect, and existing medications have a terrible reputation. This claim is way ahead of the evidence, evidence that in principle would identify the source of depression, offer an explanation to replace these many descriptions, and (at long last) craft a meaningful treatment. EDIT: Okay, before you people downvote my completely accurate post, read this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_theory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_theory Quote: "Scientific theories are testable and make falsifiable predictions. They describe the causal elements responsible for a particular natural phenomenon, and are used to explain and predict aspects of the physical universe or specific areas of inquiry (e.g. electricity, chemistry, astronomy)." Feel free to drop by the source and downvote it too, while you're banging your mouse in ignorance.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> In science, we establish causes and then measure effects. No, in science, we observe and measure phenomena, then form hypotheses about relations between them, then attempt to falsify those hypotheses, and then use the hypothesized relations which we have not yet falsified as a basis for inferring likely causes from observed effects and inferring likely effects from observed causes and inferring likely co-occurrences that are the results of common (and potentially unknown) causes from the other co-occurring phenomena. "Establish causes and then measure effects" is not only wrong, its non-sense. To even be able to establish the likelihood of a causal relation you must first measure effects and the phenomenon hypothesized as the cause.
- lutusp 12y ago> "Establish causes and then measure effects" is not only wrong, its non-sense. All right, so you don't understand science. It's not fatal, and you're hardly alone. From Aristotle, through Francis Bacon, to the present, the centerpiece of science has been the establishment of causes, explanations, not merely observations and descriptions as you're suggesting. Observations often lead to the shaping of a theory, then confirmation of that theory -- that explanation -- through the prediction of phenomena not yet observed, and observations that confirm the predictions (or that falsify the theory). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_theory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_theory Quote: "Scientific theories are testable and make falsifiable predictions. They describe the causal elements responsible for a particular natural phenomenon, and are used to explain and predict aspects of the physical universe or specific areas of inquiry (e.g. electricity, chemistry, astronomy)." I could provide hundreds of quotes similar to that above, but I can't repair your education in a short post. You must accept responsibility for those things you don't understand, but that you feel comfortable reciting to other people in a public show of narcissism.
- vaadu 12y agoHow would the results distinguish between real depression and your down because your cat just died?
- nashashmi 12y agoApart from possibility, one thing bothers me here is that how quickly (and arrogantly) they will match viability of cognitive therapy to RNA markers. Cognitive therapy works and does not work for so many reasons, and none of those reasons have anything even remotely to do with RNA. I am saddened and angry that in the end, the researchers will show and justify the experiment using results based on statistics. What medicines and therapies work and do not work will be left to chance, random trial and error, and complicated numbers. The statistics will fail to acknowledge and show the situations and mental states of the patients at that time in which such and such therapy was possible or not possible.
- mvgoogler 12y agoThis seems like a 21st century version of phrenology more than something that "brings mental health diagnosis into the 21st century". Just replace measuring skulls with measuring "RNA molecules".
- jjallen 12y agoIsn't this the kind of thing that diagnoses itself, in that someone super unhappy will seek the test out? Do they need a blood test to determine if they're seriously depressed or not? Why would someone that isn't depressed ever get this test?
- girvo 12y agoIf it becomes powerful enough, you could be checked for whether or not you're predisposed to depression above and beyond what we currently have (family history, mostly), allowing you to take the steps needed and learn the skills necessary to cope with it. CBT allowed me to beat my depression, but learning it while depressed was nigh on impossible. If I'd known that I suffered from depression or could in the future, I might have had the chance to learn it prior to my first episode, setting me up to be able to live with it far easier and with far less drama than I ended up going through.
- templeos2 12y agoI am trapped in a jail and a nigger-monkey is guard, ten years. It is fucken depressing. God will win in the end.