5 ms·
The New York Times’ App Plan Isn’t Working, So It’s Laying Off Staff
- jstalin 12y agoI subscribe to the Times for its news content. No way I was going to pay an additional $6 a month for more opinions. Frankly, the NYT's opinion page already borders on propaganda.
- beerbajay 12y agoYeah, the opinion section is the worst part of NYT, though I'm sure it's a driver of much of the traffic, at least judging from the "most read" and "most emailed" sidebars. I suspect that the by turns vague and inflammatory headlines are great as clickbait, but not something people actively seek out. And anyway, it's not like David Brooks (ever?) has anything interesting to say.
- briandear 12y agoYes. That is ridiculous. $6 for opinion? I have opinions and I'll provide them for free. Their opinion section isn't even that good. I could read White House press releases and come away with more insight.
- matkam 12y agoThis is terrible news, NY Times being one of few news organizations providing quality journalism. Hope they can figure out a way to keep running without degrading their quality.
- brandonmenc 12y agoThey should take donations, as in "$8 a week plus anything extra you can give to help us keep the lights on." Readers feel strongly about this organization - there must be some who want to give more.
- ics 12y agoKeep the lights on in our 52 floor, RPBW/FXFOWLE-designed, midtown Manhattan skyscraper. I'm pretty sure those people who want to give more are probably happier to get their name on the wall in the downstairs lobby rather than pay $10/week for their newspaper. :)
- prostoalex 12y agoThey sort of do https://nytimesathome.com/hd/205 https://nytimesathome.com/hd/205 except they insist delivering you an actual weekday paper in exchange for $4.25 a week donation.
- at-fates-hands 12y ago>>>> organizations providing quality journalism If you're a liberal, I'm sure its pretty fantastic. As someone who considers themselves an independent, this newspaper is unabashedly liberal. Perhaps this is having an effect on its subscribers? Why are subscribers (and advertisers) of The New York Times fleeing to other newspapers (such as the Wall Street Journal, whose circulation numbers have remained steady), or to other avenues such as Fox News, for their news and information? There is only one answer: The New York Times has a proclivity towards left-wing bias and unbalanced reporting of the news. Even a cursory glance of the paper reveals its pervasive editorializing, which comes through loud and clear everywhere from page one to the obituaries. But just as damaging to it than its left-wing slant has been its complete lack of interest in any stories having the remotest possibility of tarnishing the hallowed image of President Barack Obama, an image which it and other members of the so-called "main-stream media" has had such an active role in creating. source (2009): http://www.newsrealblog.com/2009/10/21/liberal-bias-is-killing-the-new-york-times/ http://www.newsrealblog.com/2009/10/21/liberal-bias-is-killi...
- Karunamon 12y agoA 5 year old source consisting of some random blogger with the identical unsubstantiated "liberal media!!!1" canard used by Fox and the like is probably not the best source to use when trying to make a factual argument about media bias.
- JetSpiegel 12y agoWhat does that even mean, "independent"? Independent of what? You just don't care about politics?
- solipsism 12y agoYeah, this person, like many, makes the mistake of confusing liberal-vs-conservative for democrat-vs-republican.
- briandear 12y ago"Quality" .. perhaps in the non-political areas. But when it comes to being objective, they are just an extension of the White House Propaganda department. Their coverage of Lois Lerner, for example has been exceedingly light. Their lack of in-depth Benghazi reporting is also ridiculous. They spend more ink writing about Goodnight Moon than they do about the Nidal Hassan terrorism case. I'm not asking the Times to agree with me.. just cover the news from a fair and balanced perspective. There is little or no diversity in that newsroom. It's all some variation of the N.E. white liberal viewpoint. It's almost like they look with disdain on any ideas that aren't following the party line. It's the US version of Pravda. Though, I do love there coverage on non-political, non-national security issues. I would pay to subscribe to the Cooking section for sure.
- StefanKarpinski 12y agoThe NY Times really needs to stop with the nickel and dime differential pricing tactics. Every time I consider getting a subscription, I look at the options and get pissed off: they are either artificially limited to only some of my devices (phone or tablet, but not both) or absurdly expensive at $8.75/week for access on all devices. NY Times, this is bullshit: if I'm going to be a subscriber, I want a reasonable rate and unlimited access to all of what the publication has to offer but I'm not going to pay $455/year for it. If you stop jerking your readers around and give them a good deal, you may be surprised by how many would be willing to subscribe.
- e40 12y agoAgreed. Back when you could give them somewhere around $8/mo, I did that. A few months later, they emailed saying they were canceling the plan. I think a lot of people would happily give them $8/mo for no incremental cost. That's all to the bottom line.
- cwyers 12y agoThey used to be able to support their main business with the print revenues, and the online subscribers were all (as you note) marginal money on top of that. With print revenues declining, that may not be possible anymore, and if it still is possible it probably isn't for much longer. They need to find some way to transition to a model where digital-only revenue pays the bills.
- StefanKarpinski 12y agoFinding the right point on the supply-demand curve is key to this. Their current strategy is trying to have their cake and eat it too. What I'm arguing they need to do is stop playing games trying to charge the few people who don't care about cost more and focus on the much larger market of people who are happy to pay what they feel is a fair rate for quality product. Apple nailed this when they priced songs and TV shows at 99¢. Amazon is killing it with affordable kindle offerings. The formula is pretty simple: good content, convenient access, and affordable pricing that feels fair to the consumer. The NY Times is succeeding at the first two and blowing it at the last one. As a result they are failing to capitalize on the broader market.
- protonfish 12y agoNewspapers and magazines were traditionally funding by advertising with subscriptions fees only to cover printing and delivery costs and as a concrete measure of dedicated readership. Moving to web publishing, printing and delivery costs are nearly 0 and readership is easily measured. But, instead of pushing ad revenue into the information age, they've thrown their heavy-handed weight behind subscriptions which work like death to online readership, then crying that it's their everyone else's fault they are losing money. I don't know what mental malfunction caused this unilateral suicide spiral, but they should probably stop making the same mistake and expecting different results and start focusing on innovation in online advertising (especially selling its value to your traditional clients.)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sd8f9iu 12y agoThe internet has been decimating traditional news journalism's profits – whether online or offline – for more than a decade now. What do you mean they weren't "pushing ad revenue into the information age?" What were they supposed to do differently? The only news providers I hear about doing remotely well off of online advertising are ones with click-bait headlines and viral content, quite a different style from the NYT. And how are they "crying that it's everyone else's fault they are losing money?"
- jallmann 12y ago> readership is easily measured This is probably a big part of the problem. Online ad revenues aren't going to equal those for print, simply because there is so much more visibility into targeting, reach and conversions. Thus, advertisers have a much better idea of the value of an impression/click, and can price accordingly, rather than indiscriminately shot-gunning eyeballs as in print. Entrenched cost structures contribute to the problem, but the fact is that paying a professional staff to produce quality content every day costs a lot of money, and online there are fewer dollars coming in per reader, even if the total audience is much larger. The exception to this downward trend is if you have content catering to highly lucrative niches such as insurance or banking (although I don't know how these compare to similarly placed print ads). Premium video has a similar problem; advertising revenue is unsustainable for anything other than indie YouTube shows. The broadcast TV model could never work on the Internet. At least, that's my theory.
- danso 12y agoJudging as purely an outsider...it wouldn't surprise me if the Opinion App was little more than a prestige project for that particular department to have as a feather in its cap, rather than something that the Times' innovators organically thought was a real revenue generator...there's just no precedent for an opinion spin-off app...general news apps aren't even doing that well, why would they seriously think that consumers would have fun juggling through two different news apps, nevermind the news consumers already get through general browsing of the web or through social media? It's not surprising that a large organization would have throwaway products, it's just a shame for a financially-strapped org to continue having such bureaucratic machinations at such a critical time in its history.
- vermooten 12y agoEven if I wanted to subscribe, I can't see anywhere obvious on the home page of how to do it.
- stdgy 12y agoDoes your home screen look different? http://i.imgur.com/FBBIYLR.png http://i.imgur.com/FBBIYLR.png
- secabeen 12y agoApropos of nothing, I hate short term promotional pricing. On that page, you can't tell how much it costs after the promotional period ends.
- Karunamon 12y agoIt's always seemed like a dark pattern to me, since 99/100 times it's combined with automatic renewal. Meaning you'll sign up for a few weeks/months at a decent price and suddenly find yourself with a multi-hundred-percent increase in cost out of nowhere. Hard to imagine they're not relying on that.
- markplindsay 12y agoAlso: try canceling your nytimes subscription online. You can't—canceling requires a phone call with a lengthy wait on hold and a customer-retention sales pitch before they'll let you off the hook. Sometimes I think about subscribing again, but thinking about that wasted 15 minutes of my life is enough to make me forget about it.
- navait 12y agoAdBlock seems to disable that button. I had to go to the bottom of the page to subscribe.
- stdgy 12y agoAh, interesting. I believe it's Javascript based as well, which might have some effect. Doesn't seem to appear until the page has fully loaded.
- tomdale 12y agoI read the New York Times and subscribe to the Sunday paper (grudgingly; the online subscription is perversely more expensive than allowing them to leave a piece of paper on my doorstep every Sunday!) The Times puts up too many obstacles to becoming a subscriber in the digital age, as others have mentioned. Also, either I'm oblivious or they're doing a terrible job marketing their spinoffs. I read the Times daily, on both my phone and at a desktop, and am definitely in their target demo for NYT Cooking, but I haven't even heard of it. I already subscribe to Cook's Illustrated and visit sites like Serious Eats regularly; how is it I didn't know about their new venture? (http://cooking.nytimes.com/ http://cooking.nytimes.com/ looks amazing, by the way. I'm disappointed I had to hear about it in the context of these job cuts.)
- yupmetoo 12y agoI found it extremely easy to become a subscriber via an online webform, but far more difficult to cancel as you have to do it via phone call with someone paid to keep you subscribing.
- swartkrans 12y agoOne of the New York Times' problems of monetizing is relying on what is an essentially an honor system for accessing content. Anyone can just simply view all of the New York Times for free in an incognito window. To pay the subscription is an avoidance of compunction, but not a necessity. This is probably an irrational business proposition.
- bitroliest 12y agoThey changed their pricing for the crossword subscription too, limiting the back catalog and forcing an upgrade to iOS 7. They lost a long time subscriber, who will probably be switching to Android since that was the only thing keeping me on iPhones.
- subpixel 12y agoI am a digital subscriber and I have never heard of these apps. I login to the site, and I have some iPhone app I got long ago. I think there's definitely a marketing problem, although I can honestly say the idea of paying the Times more than once for multiple apps is a non-starter to me.
- Theodores 12y agoPersonally I am shocked that they still do a print edition that should have gone the way of vinyl records by now. Instead they should have a weekly print edition that is glossy and great for people that like to read actual paper at the weekends - we all have parents like that, don't we? Paywall hasn't delivered the results for Mr Murdoch or anyone else in the UK that have gone that route. The highly invested in The Guardian and the Daily Mail are doing very nicely in the UK and around the world. Which is interesting because the UK is a smaller country than the US and the newspapers-of-old converged on London and gave up on the regions a long time ago. (The Guardian used the be The Manchester Guardian). The problem with U.S. titles is the brands are too geographic - NY Times is New York which is not a global thing and New York really is not the centre of the universe. The Guardian do not make money. However charging people to read the news is not possible in the UK when the BBC do it all for free. Hence The Guardian run the ads, charge for the dating/car-buying/employment options. These news organisations that complain need to go away. It is easier than ever to put together 'news', the extra bits they need beyond the standard newswire feed - Associated Press et al. - can be grabbed off of the internets. Journalists haven't been getting out and about for a while, they just cut and paste. What disappoints me more is this: http://www.schnews.org.uk/stories/AND-FINALLY/ http://www.schnews.org.uk/stories/AND-FINALLY/ A 'zine shutting down.
- briandear 12y agoIf the NY Times would actually be objective and not a shill for a particular political party, then I might care.
- CamperBob2 12y agoYeah, they really turned me off when they started banging the war drums for Dubya's little Iraq adventure. Oh, wait, that's probably not what you were referring to at all, is it?
- declan 12y agoThe New York Times' public editor Dan Okrent addressed this a decade ago; the question has been asked and answered and may not be really worth debating again, I suspect. Some excerpts from that self-critique: "Is The New York Times a Liberal Newspaper? Of course it is. ... These are the social issues: gay rights, gun control, abortion and environmental regulation, among others. And if you think The Times plays it down the middle on any of them, you've been reading the paper with your eyes closed... http://www.nytimes.com/2004/07/25/opinion/the-public-editor-is-the-new-york-times-a-liberal-newspaper.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm http://www.nytimes.com/2004/07/25/opinion/the-public-editor-... "if you're examining the paper's coverage of these subjects from a perspective that is neither urban nor Northeastern nor culturally seen-it-all; if you are among the groups The Times treats as strange objects to be examined on a laboratory slide (devout Catholics, gun owners, Orthodox Jews, Texans); if your value system wouldn't wear well on a composite New York Times journalist, then a walk through this paper can make you feel you're traveling in a strange and forbidding world... "On a topic that has produced one of the defining debates of our time, Times editors have failed to provide the three-dimensional perspective balanced journalism requires. This has not occurred because of management fiat, but because getting outside one's own value system takes a great deal of self-questioning... The NYT is a remarkable institution capable of arguably the best news reporting on the planet when it collectively sets its mind to a task. It will cover the difficult local topics like NYC homelessness and public school failures that are a poorer fit for the Post or WSJ. I have friends who work there; my editor before I left to found recent.io is now a NYT editor. But the above critique was true when written in 2004 and is even more true today.
- nitrobeast 12y agoThe 'pay wall' of NYT is just for show. Use incognito mode to browse as much as you want on nytimes.com
- halayli 12y agoIf their subscription meant no ads showing up then I would have happily kept it.
- cyphunk 12y agothe internet is stateless. you're traction is going to be limited if you only represent a narrow geographically limited viewpoint.