7 ms·
I find the "American model" and the "European model" dichotomy very interesting. American model: individually centered, "pay for what you want", development is
by raverbashing 12y ago
I find the "American model" and the "European model" dichotomy very interesting.
American model: individually centered, "pay for what you want", development is driven by small companies and individual decisions (most of the time). "Works for me"
European model: centered on the community, social support, development by committee/government/consensus. Slow but directed improvements
Germany could not have produced Facebook. But they have a great train network. France puts satellites on orbit and does the TGV.
In the US you have millionaires came out of "nothing" (of course, from nice universities, nice contacts, etc), people jumping at opportunities, while in Europe this would take 2 meetings, 3 viability studies and 4 months.
So, while I'm more towards in favour of the European model someone has to ask themselves what are they missing. Yes, they have a very nice and educated workforce that will be ready to work and be very productive at a big company where they will work hard, sure, but will come out with the least amount of new ideas (that's not their job), and will do the things most likely to be accepted by the majority.
- rbehrends 12y ago> Germany could not have produced Facebook. "Could not" is a bit strong. "Unlikely" I'd agree with. But my rationale is different: German businesses traditionally have a strong bias towards B2B models (esp. the "Mittelstand") and startups eschew consumer-facing business models. For example, America has Microsoft, Germany has SAP.
- ionised 12y agoThe way you describe it makes the EU system sound preferable.
- bharath28 12y agoThis. And that somehow a viable combination of the two approaches can't be built.
- spydum 12y agothat is one of the great part of being human: diversity of thought. it's a shame most people are convinced that they are "right", and assume there can only be one right model. Leads to people trying to establish these monocultures, which usually fail (over time).
- melling 12y agoBuilding a high-speed rail network has nothing to do with our "model". It's 50 year old technology with commercial use before man first set foot on the moon. There are a dozen countries with it. Spain, for example, has a few thousand miles. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_high-speed_rail_lines http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_high-speed_rail_lines
- acadien 12y agoThat's a pretty sweeping statement. Education impacts all things, voting, social norms, behavior, social sentiment... all of which impact how politicians act. In addition the politicians themselves go through the public education system.
- raverbashing 12y agoI'm not talking about the technology, I'm talking about the implementation. Doing this requires a lot of collective work: investment, property acquisition or licensing, railway building, etc This requires collective vision and goals
- aidenn0 12y agoUS population density: 34/km^2 Germany population density: 226/km^2 The Northeast US has a fairly good railway system despite it having a lot of legacy constraints not around in Germany. Most of the rest of the US is far to sprawling for railways to be effective.
- raverbashing 12y agoSee the average speed of Acela trains (time vs distance) compared with TGV/Thalys/ICE And don't you think Germany has more legacy constraints with a higher density and older tracks?
- aidenn0 12y agoAcela trains share track with freight, TGV and ICE certainly don't. This includes the requirement for safe collision with a freight train, which adds a lot of weight.
- psychometry 12y agoWhy do those philosophies have to be mutually exclusive? Can't you apply principles of social welfare to the public sector while allowing entrepreneurship in the private sector?
- raverbashing 12y agoThey don't have to be. But it's complicated. And sure, entrepreneurship is allowed, but then you'll have to convince your family of why are you not getting a nice job as a government clerk or something.
- zanny 12y agoIf you can get investors backing you, you really don't need to care what your family says. It is just as cultural in the US that many families are affronted by their children or relatives that choose to try entrepreneurship over employment.
- psychometry 12y agoOne barrier to entrepreneurship in the U.S. is lack of health benefits when you're self-employed. There's not much of a social safety net here compared to most of Europe. Thus, one would think that Europe would actually be a better place to quit your job and pursue some startup idea. Why isn't that the case?
- ahomescu1 12y ago> Why do those philosophies have to be mutually exclusive? Can't you apply principles of social welfare to the public sector while allowing entrepreneurship in the private sector? Because they compete for capital. The former requires high taxes, which leave a lot less private capital for investment and entrepreneurship. For example, imagine if the government had taxed away 90% of Elon Musk's fortune.
- pessimizer 12y agoGermany could have produced facebook. edit: maybe better framed as a question - why do you think that Germany could not have produced facebook?
- smm2000 12y agoGermany has not so far produced a single website or app that is hugely popular internationally. It does not mean it could not - it certainly have educated population to do it but the fact is it has not.
- sucramb 12y agoZalando made their IPO just yesterday. $768M collected and $6.8B market cap.
- smm2000 12y agoZalando is European company with very few sales outside of EU.
- janmonschke 12y agoYou obviously haven't heard of SoundCloud then ;) (founders are Swedes but company is based in Berlin)
- smm2000 12y agoGood point, I did not know about SoundCloud.
- raverbashing 12y agoSimple answer: because they think it's silly (or think it's too much of a privacy violation) Germans are "very serious" even when they're having fun.
- bratsche 12y agoEven if what you're saying is true (which I'm a little skeptical of), what provides more value to people? Facebook or free education?
- penprog 12y agoAt first glance this question seems easy to answer but on a second thought I could see how someone could argue that Facebook provides more value.
- flexie 12y agoIf Germany couldn't have produced Facebook it's only because of the language. User content on facebook is mainly a written language thing, and it would have been hard spreading a website with mostly German content to English since so few Americans and brits speak German. On the other hand, most young Europeans speak English so Facebook had little trouble spreading from American universities to Europeans. Skype started in Europe (Swedish/Danish co-founders, Estonian devs, offices in London, company in Luxembourg). No "committe/government/consensus" there. Also, Apple and Google are examples of American companies that started with public funding. Finally, many European countries rank higher than the US when it comes to social mobility. Don't most European know several millionaires who "came out of nothing" (or at least from a quiet European middle class background)? I think so.
- raverbashing 12y ago> If Germany couldn't have produced Facebook it's only because of the language No. Most Germans don't even care for FB (or twitter). Or they use it with a limited purpose. They think it's silly. Skype is a nice example, but is one of fewer companies like that. > Apple and Google are examples of American companies that started with public funding Are you sure? A lot of SV companies have had public funding but I'm not sure about them. "Don't most European know several millionaires who "came out of nothing"" Well, this happens pretty much everywhere, even in 3rd world countries (sure, in a much smaller quantity). Social mobility is important, but a comfortable life in a comfy job may also be a prison (better than going through difficulties, sure)
- Quanttek 12y ago> No. Most Germans don't even care for FB (or twitter). Or they use it with a limited purpose. They think it's silly. Not really, atleast from my experiences. Almost the complete youth & young adults atleast use Facebook and a considerable amount Twitter (more Twitter user, the older they get). Older adults and eldery only use FB/Twitter partially (I'd say 20%) and realtively inactive Though, yes, in Germany - on average - Facebook & Twitter are less used, mostly because of privacy reasons
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoSpeaking as a born-and-bred American, America did not produce Facebook. Its content is mostly user-created: the world created Facebook. If we want to talk about specific public policies conducive to the formation of web start-ups, California created Facebook by refusing to enforce noncompete agreements -- building an environment in which "Take this job and shove it! I'll start my own company!" can't be met with "You'll never work in this industry again!"
- raverbashing 12y agoTrue. Yeah, the part about California is important. Or maybe even "The Silicon Valley" produced it.
- colordrops 12y agoI'm not so sure that Facebook is the best example. It's not clear whether its existence has made a positive mark on the world or a negative one. Also, Linux was created in another socialized state, Finland. I would argue that the impact of Linux is at least an order of magnitude more profound than Facebook.
- walterbell 12y agoAnother example, Tim Berners-Lee and the WWW.
- raverbashing 12y agoWWW is actually 3 things: URL/URI + HTTP + HTML ;) Created based on the preceding ideas like Gopher, telnet, etc and some others as well http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gopher_%28protocol%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gopher_%28protocol%29 "On 30 April 1993, CERN announced that the World Wide Web would be free to anyone, with no fees due.[24] Coming two months after the announcement that the server implementation of the Gopher protocol was no longer free to use, this produced a rapid shift away from Gopher and towards the Web. " http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Wide_Web http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Wide_Web Btw, I'm not disagreeing with you, the European idea of making things for "everybody" got into play there.
- dalke 12y agoNor am I disagreeing. Only pointing out that Linux was also created based on preceding ideas like Unix, MINIX, etc., themselves based on even earlier ideas ... just like HTML comes out of SGML, and has its own long history.
- raverbashing 12y agoWell, Linux started with Minix, and of course, after its (initial) creation it had a lot of input from everywhere. I agree it's a more "European" model of development, sure.
- 12y ago
- wffurr 12y agoThat's not the American model–it's the American myth. You're leaving out the parts where Americans are enslaved to their corporate jobs through employer-provided healthcare, lack of unions, and a weak safety net. Combine that with regulatory capture by corporations, extreme concentration of wealth, and legalized bribery of legislators, and now you've got the American model.
- Kurtz79 12y agoYour analysis is very black and white, and reality is probably more nuanced, but I generally agree that Europeans tend to be more risk averse than Americans. It is also true that something as "simple" as starting your own company or working as a freelancer it often involves a lot of paperwork and upfront costs, which discourages a lot of people. Still, I believe things are changing (in some countries faster than others), at least on this account.
- PythonicAlpha 12y agoI don't see the connection here. In the US you have millionaires came out of "nothing" (of course, from nice universities, nice contacts, etc), people jumping at opportunities, while in Europe this would take 2 meetings, 3 viability studies and 4 months. That is a really narrow view and a myth that is just not applicable to the majority of people. Besides extreme things like Facebook, most people of the US are stick to their destiny. If you can't afford to attend an university, you have not much more chance to rise out of the dust in the US than in Europe. Those that succeed are very few. Of course those are presented everywhere, to prove the US dream. People like Bill Gates never came from poor destiny. Gates parents already where rich. The rich in the US also provide, that people from lower classes don't enter theirs. You have to have visited the right university (costly!) or you have to have the right parents to get the well paid jobs -- or both of course. Of course, the possibilities in some sectors like IT are better and when you have ideas, you can easier get some money. Also when you loose, you get easier a second chance ... but all that has nothing to do with the education system and even less with university fees.
- raverbashing 12y agoYou didn't read anything from the '(' on where I mean exactly what you explained.
- PythonicAlpha 12y agoPossible. It was a little short in my opinion and the reader could get the impression, that the US model is superior, because so much "wonders" are coming from it. But the wonders do not have anything to do with the education system, in my opinion.
- dozenal 12y agoWe used German scientists to develop our nuclear weapons and the space program. That must count for something.
- transpy 12y agoExcellent points! Food for thought