5 ms·
ComputerCOP: Dubious 'Internet Safety Software' Police Distributed to Families
- Zikes 12y agoA perfect example of how security theater can do more harm than good.
- freehunter 12y agoAnd a good example of how a lack of technical knowledge is dangerous. Why would they endorse a product if they weren't sure of it's effectiveness? These are government agencies, and they have access to technical resources that could verify the claims of the salesmen. Imagine firemen handing out smoke detectors (like they often do) without verifying that they actually detect smoke. It would be a catastrophe.
- vodenspaw 12y agoIsn't the example more like: Firemen handing out smoke detectors that will detect fires regardless if there is a fire or not? Hmm... Give false positive enabling software to law enforcement that will be disseminated to "Concerned Parents", then spend time investigating "Crimes against children." What is the rate of which this software has been used to investigate crimes? Who designed and programmed this software?
- Yen 12y agoMore like, Firemen handing out smoke detectors that not only beep whether or not there's smoke, but also occasionally light your house on fire.
- roflc0ptic 12y agoYes, this is the correct metaphor. It leaves users vulnerable to things the cops are supposed to be trying to protect users from. What's unclear is, do the cops get access to the keylogged information? Then the metaphor gets silly. It's like... firefighters giving you a smoke detector so they can spy on you in case you're setting fires, which also happens to sometimes cause fires independently.
- roflc0ptic 12y agoOh, actually, I hadn't read far enough. It doesn't look like it sends it back to the cops.
- samrift 12y agoNo. Firemen have incentive to prevent fires. Home fires don't increase their revenue stream and in fact put them at risk of injury or death. Police are not mandated to prevent crimes, and have no external incentives to do so (I state external because some officers want to reduce crime due to morals/ethical beliefs). In fact, in can be argued by looking at civil forfeiture laws and federal programs paying officers directly for certain arrests, that preventing crime is actually against their best interests both organizationally and individually. However, handing out a tool that always indicates suspicious activity and allows them to invade privacy.. well, that fits in exactly with the behavior that laws and rules surrounding them have encouraged.
- duskwuff 12y ago> What is the rate of which this software has been used to investigate crimes? Zero. It's not a forensic tool; any "evidence" collected with it would be inadmissable in court. (And, as the EFF notes, its search functions are pretty much useless anyway - most major OSes have considerably better search built in.)
- wtracy 12y agoSince this product opens users up to all kinds of identity theft, it's worse than that. It's like a fire alarm with a flashing light that triggers epileptic seizures.
- mmastrac 12y agoEven worse, it could be a firm alarm that has the ability to start fires on its own. And you don't know if there are any arsonists working for the company that might remotely trigger a fire for their own pleasure.
- TehCorwiz 12y agoSo, why is this not in malware databases? Seriously, shouldn't this be up there with Conduit Search?
- Rudism 12y agoIn my previous job, I worked at an advertising company in the "downloadables" department for a number of years. Basically we developed browser toolbars, software installers, mobile apps, and other software all with the sole purpose of gathering information about users in order to make money off them. We never (to my knowledge) developed any actual keyloggers, but we would do other equally insecure things with end users' data. For example, sending browser cookies, registry values, files off the hard drive, etc. in plain text to databases on our servers for later analysis. Getting this kind of software through spyware screens in antivirus programs is not too difficult. Some of the antivirus companies have automated processes by which you can upload your binaries to them as false-positives and they'll automatically whitelist them for you. Sometimes it requires a quick email or phone call to the appropriate person at the antivirus company. Occasionally you have to make changes (usually just adding more disclaimers to an already ridiculously long EULA) in order to satisfy them and get on the whitelist. On a few occasions we just had to pay some money to get whitelisted. Some of the more inscrupulous antivirus companies would even take money to bundle our now-whitelisted spyware applications in the installers for their products (as a checked-by-default "also install" option). My takeaway from my time in that industry is that antivirus and antispyware software and companies are, by and large, just as bad as a lot of the spyware and spyware producing companies that they claim to be protecting you from. It's just a big circle jerk where the ultimate goal is to trick people into generating revenue by installing software or seeing ads that nobody in their right mind would ever actualy opt-in to.
- TehCorwiz 12y agoWow, yeah. I've heard about some of those techniques. I still think it's worth it for the more...upstanding AV companies to blacklist stuff like this. Or at least warn the user of its presence.
- 12y ago
- daveloyall 12y agoConsider https://github.com/ComputerCOP-OpenRemover/ComputerCOP-OpenRemover https://github.com/ComputerCOP-OpenRemover/ComputerCOP-OpenR... You see what I did there? There isn't any code. :) But that can change very quickly via pull requests, right? Any recommendations? Is this the right way to solicit volunteers for a little one-off project? [edit: switched from personal repo to organization repo per feedback.]
- daveloyall 12y agoWell, at least one downvote indicates that this is not the right way to proceed. How about a little feedback to go with that? Thank you in advance.
- icebraining 12y agoWell, I didn't downvote you, but you're essentially asking for free work. If you want contributions, you need to contribute yourself first, usually by writing some code (or paying someone to write if you cannot) and publishing it. A basic version that doesn't work well yet is OK, an empty repo isn't.
- daveloyall 12y agoOk, I can see that point of view. The repo isn't technically empty. :) I put a bit of work into describing the requirements of the proposed software and making suggestions how to proceed. Basically I was volunteering to tend a garden, not just suggesting that someone plant one. I've just added `remover.go` package main import "fmt" func main() { fmt.Println("Limited functionality, WIP.") //Display introduction message and prompt user if they'd like to continue. //Determine if current process has permissions to make system changes //IF yes continue //IF no initiate appropriate OS call to prompt the user to elevate // OR advise user how to quit and start over with perms. //TODO figure out if we're on Mac or Windows //IF Windows... // Look for process CCNet.exe //Criteria: it's insufficient to match the name. Checksum? Publisher name? Install path? //If found //var installLocation string = ?? //record the install location. //terminate process // Look in these directories for installation //C:\Program Files\WinSS\Book //installLocation //defined above //IF found //Delete //IF not found //Prompt user to offer a suggestion // Look in this directory for key log files //C:\Windows\WinCCNet //IF found //Prompt for delete //If not found //Prompt user to offer a suggestion // Remove the Add/remove programs entry // Remove auto-start keys //TODO Where are they? //IF Mac... // ??? } As you can see, it is a work in progress.
- cmdrfred 12y agoATTENTION: IT IS 2014, THERE IS NO EXCUSE TO NOT USE CRYPTO ON ANYTHING TRANSMITTED OVER THE PUBLIC INTERNET. Sorry for the caps but seriously... come on.
- ars 12y agoPeople are often worried about plain text being intercepted by "hackers" in flight, in email for example. Other than WiFi and government agencies, is this really a realistic worry?
- lotsofmangos 12y agoNot if you can trust everyone employed at your ISP and every company they peer with.
- jpollock 12y agoGiven that a child's laptop will likely be connected to the school's wifi, where any other child would then be able to sniff the keypresses... Yes, it's a problem.
- duozerk 12y agoIf you're wired (ethernet): ARP poisoning to get your traffic to route through the attacker, then listening there. Works beautifully on most if not all LANs. Though even if it didn't, WiFi by itself would be concern enough: most if not all the internet-equipped private homes have (often badly secured) WiFi, and all public spaces (airports, schools & universities, restaurants & bars, etc.) usually use key-less captive portal WiFi APs where listening in is even easier. So yes: traffic interception is a very legitimate worry IMHO. And as someone said below, beyond those concerns, you could also be sniffed by techs working at your ISP (and its peering partners) / Law Enforcement / etc.
- Zigurd 12y agoIf anti-virus, firewall, and intrusion-detection products are willing to ignore something as hazardous, cheap-ass, and cheesy as this, think what a visit from the FBI or NSA will convince them to do.