2 ms·
> is community members willing to upvote opinions that are substantively presented and add to the discussion even they disagree with them. The status quo prove
by Someone1234 12y ago
> is community members willing to upvote opinions that are substantively presented and add to the discussion even they disagree with them.
The status quo prove that that is a failed strategy. It has been tried and tried again, it doesn't work. Nobody has been able to make it work, I don't see that changing without any other variables changing. People innately want to downvote to disagree, that's how people have proven they work.
> Adding more user choices won't stop people from using the one intended to suppress inappropriate comments on comments they disagree with if they, in fact, want to suppress disagreement.
It will for the reasons I set out above: Flagging stops them interacting with the comment (replying, disagreeing) and a "disagree" is a public disapproval rather than a private one which likely suits many people's ends better.
Additionally you now have more metrics (data) to measure a comment's quality on (e.g. agree, disagree, and flag) rather than two. More data might make it easier to detect flag-button abuse.
> I think this rests on a false assumption -- private use of flag doesn't reduce the incentive to use it, it just reduces accountability.
The upvote and downvote arrows have no more or less accountability, so I don't follow what you're getting at. The flag arrow just wouldn't be recorded in the comment's public scores, accountability remains identical (in that there isn't any).
> it would be stupid to use the UI option to "disagree" after you flagged anyway, since that would negate the effect of your flagging on its only purpose -- suppressing the opinion you disagree with, rather than publishing your disagreement.
It would on paper, it wouldn't for real people. While there are people who sit there and figure out how to best game the system, the majority just knee-jerk react to things they find "offensive." So they would hit flag, then disagree, then reply with "you are dumb." If we take away 2/3 of their toys if they hit flag incorrectly, they're less likely to utilise flag and instead just disagree and reply.
Plus it re-focuses flag's purpose. If you flag a comment you literally don't think it should exist, therefore you should have no need to interact with it. Heck you could go one step further and auto-hide it for that individual user.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> The status quo prove that that is a failed strategy. It has been tried and tried again, it doesn't work. I disagree, I think it works quite well on HN, and the vast majority of the specific instances of it supposedly not working I've seen pointed to are nonconstructive comments -- some of which supported viewpoints I agree with a non-constructive way -- which I agree should have been downvoted for non-disagreement reasons. I do think there will always be people who are to prone to use suppressive options when they disagree with a comment, but I think that HN currently has a community where that isn't the dominant model and the people that complain about a problem of use of downvote-for-disagreement being a real problem with the community are people that are a selectively blind to the negative qualities of comments that happen to support points of view that they like. > It will for the reasons I set out above: Flagging stops them interacting with the comment (replying, disagreeing) and a "disagree" is a public disapproval rather than a private one which likely suits many people's ends better. For the people with which a public interaction suits their ends better, responding already exists. For people for which suppression suits their ends better, flagging will be superior even if it isn't the intended use of flagging. I don't think people who do use downvote-for-disagree in a community with clearly articulated norms of what downvoting is for generally do so out of ignorance or lack of options, they do so because downvote suppresses and that is exactly what they want to do. Or because they genuinely can't separate whether something is non-constructive (and thus should be downvoted) from whether it is a viewpoint they agree with -- much the same as the people who have an excessive tendency to perceive any downvoting of a comment they agree with as the downvoter using downvote-to-disagree. And people who can't support "inappropriate" from "I disagree" are going to keep flagging as inappropriate based on disagreement, no matter what options are available. OTOH, feel free to set up your own community site with the features you discuss and prove how those options solve the supposed problem.