3 ms·
UChicago’s current situation seems to constitute a worst-case example of the “failure of governing boards to ensure that institutions adhere to their stated pur
by barry-cotter 12y ago
UChicago’s current situation seems to constitute a worst-case example of the “failure of governing boards to ensure that institutions adhere to their stated purpose,” as an August 2014 American Council of Trustees and Alumni report put it. The ACTA correctly lays partial blame for a decline in educational quality and an increase in costs on trustees, but ultimately identifies the problem as a “strategy of passive governance” and recommends greater voluntary engagement and scrupulosity within a system where trustees “are beholden to none.”
The article makes the situation sound like a vile cesspit but "a decline in educational quality", really? U.Chicago is a super-elite university, like HYPS. Undergraduates are at no risk of having instructors of as low a standard as at say, Berkeley.
- cpks 12y agoPerhaps. It's mostly the business school and the law school that are well-renowned. For most other fields, it is a rather generous step down from the Harvards, Yales, Princeton, Stanford, Yale, MIT, Caltech, Dartmouth, Johns Hopkins (and yes, Berkeley), etc. in terms of quality of faculty, students, and research. HYPS and quality doesn't necessarily translate to good classroom teaching. Most learning at HYPS-grade schools happens outside of the classroom, and indeed, the classrooms are often not very good. It translates to good peer group and professors to learn from, good opportunities (e.g. to do research, internships, and have access to labs and equipment for engineering students), and good reputation and network after graduating. Chicago is aggressive in terms of targeting US News and World Report, but a lot of the indicators are non-indicators of quality. For example, 99% of Chicago freshman continue there, and the 6-year graduation rate is 93%. Many other schools are a bit more selective about pruning students who really ought not have gotten in, and have somewhat more rigorous academic requirements. Chicago has good student:faculty in classrooms, since that's in the ratings, but as a result of faculty spending time there, perhaps a bit less faculty contact outside of classrooms (in research and similar settings). Etc. A lot of that might collapse if they run into financial troubles.
- charlescearl 12y agoWell, it seems to rank competitively with Harvard and MIT with respect to Math and Physics if you go by recent Nobel and Fields medals. Granted those are problematic measures along with US News, but publication rates will probably bear that out. And in terms of completion rate, it tends to be a "by nerds, for nerds" institution, that is highly self-selecting -- the kind of place you only know about because you've researched it. The flames aside, the financial straights are quite troubling. Shold a school that many econ Nobel's really be in such straits? Maybe Levitt [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steven_Levitt http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steven_Levitt] should take a crack at this one?
- cpks 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fields_Medal#Fields_Medals_by_Affiliation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fields_Medal#Fields_Medals_by_A... Affiliation upon appointment of Field's Medal: Harvard: 3 MIT: 2 Chicago: 0 Chicago does list a lot of medalists of different sorts on their page, but their affiliation is questionable at best.
- onetimeusename 12y agoI think U Chicago is a top tier school but I don't understand what you mean about Berkeley. UC Berkeley has a low standard of instructors? It is usually in the top 5 for math, physics, and computer science. Were you talking about departments aside from these?
- mooreds 12y agoNot sure. Maybe parent was making a joke?
- geebee 12y agoI'm a little bewildered by this as well... it didn't sound like a joke, but I may be missing it. Perhaps this is a reference to the higher undergraduate student/faculty ratio, and the greater difficulty in getting access to faculty at the undergrad level? I'm not sure what departments would be considered weak at Berkeley - according to the National Research Council, Berkeley has the most graduate departments in the top 10 of any university. Then again… Berkeley and elite private research universities tend to have similar numbers of grad students, and of course access to professors is much higher for PhD students than undergrads. Berkeley has a lot of problems, largely stemming from having a very large number of undergraduates (and a higher percentage of low income students) than most private elite research institutions (there are substantial social benefits to this as well), but quality of faculty is probably Berkeley's strongest suit.