3 ms·
I wanted to like FireChat, as it was previously possible to use it entirely offline, in a purely P2P fashion. While this is still possible, you are now forced
by LeoPanthera 12y ago
I wanted to like FireChat, as it was previously possible to use it entirely offline, in a purely P2P fashion.
While this is still possible, you are now forced to first create an account online, and subscribe to a bunch of internet-based channels, before the app will let you use the P2P portion.
This is frustrating. The market is wide open for someone to make a pure P2P communications app that doesn't require internet access at all, even initially.
- sounds 12y agoservalproject.org is free (and open source) P2P voice, chat and online status. Uses Ad Hoc networking, which iirc FireChat uses bluetooth so servalproject should get better range. I'm not affiliated with the project in any way (I'm not in Australia) but I've happily used it for some tests.
- sixQuarks 12y agoterrible name!!! They need a catchy name like FireChat.
- notastartup 12y agothis is interesting what is ad hoc networking and how does it work offline? Firechat uses bluetooth but doesn't work with iphone to android communication?
- benliong78 12y agoThey somehow managed to do that: allow communication between two platforms. No one is quite sure how though. It's their secret source that they aren't open sourcing.
- jschwartzi 12y agoYou could conceivably do this with Bluetooth Low Energy, which has pretty diverse support nowadays. Mesh networking is one of its touted capabilities.
- higherpurpose 12y agoFireChat also doesn't encrypt communications, which makes it rather dangerous in such situations. There have already been reports of government agents infiltrating in the protest movement to install malware in their phones.
- sp332 12y agoWhat's the point of encrypting public chat?
- Florin_Andrei 12y ago> you are now forced to first create an account online, and subscribe to a bunch of internet-based channels, before the app will let you use the P2P portion. Hm, I don't know. I've unsubscribed from all internet-based channels, and the P2P still seems available.
- LeoPanthera 12y agoRight, but you're still forced to sign up in the first place.