3 ms·
>Why is that the only case where right holders have a "legitimate interest" like this? There are lots of other cases where somebody should have a similar case b
by pessimizer 12y ago
>Why is that the only case where right holders have a "legitimate interest" like this? There are lots of other cases where somebody should have a similar case by a similar standard: obscenity, sex, violence, religion or anything else counter to a group's core beliefs. The law should be consistent one way or another, but it isn't.
I think that's because the only consistent and fair position is to allow all parodies without any restriction other than confusion with the original work. Since they still want to censor, they can't allow that, and instead use a vague term ('discriminatory message') that is unlimited in effect. The racial/religious example in the text isn't a restriction; a 'discriminatory message' could be applied to anything from painting gardeners in a bad light to slandering Texas beef[1].
It's good that it loosens up the law in spirit, at least.
[1] http://articles.chicagotribune.com/1998-01-20/business/9801200126_1_oprah-winfrey-tv-crew-circus http://articles.chicagotribune.com/1998-01-20/business/98012...
"Turner's law is a tribute to the increasing power of the media, and a major reason why at least 12 other states have passed laws making it a crime to denigrate products, mostly fruits and vegetables."