4 ms·
It seems to me that CloudFlare is positioning themselves as another Google or Facebook, where a key feature of their business is that they get to track the web
by jgrahamc 12y ago
It seems to me that CloudFlare is positioning themselves as another Google or Facebook, where a key feature of their business is that they get to track the web history of a large portion of internet users.
CloudFlare's business model is not offering a free service and figure out how to make money. It's getting people to pay us money and those people are our actual customers who run web sites: https://www.cloudflare.com/plans https://www.cloudflare.com/plans
Unfortunately, their motives don't matter - in a world where "national security letters" Prism, XKeyscore, and the like exist, CloudFlare's motives may not matter.
https://www.cloudflare.com/transparency https://www.cloudflare.com/transparency
- pdkl95 12y agoI get that stuff - their transparency report is, of course, also very encouraging and another boost to their reputation. (I'll mention that they have more "warrant canaries" than I was aware of previously, which IS a good sign, though the utility of such statements is somewhat uncertain) My concern is that the single point of failure still exists. CloudFlare may have the best of intentions, but they aren't going to be able to stop a national security letter or other threat. Also, attitudes (and CEO/BoD) can change. From a purely engineering point of view, one good hack is what stands between those valuable logs or ssl certs and the various parties that would love to have them. Contrast this with the old manufacturing practice of always requiring a second source for key parts or services, though the analogy isn't perfect.
- chrisdone 12y agoYes, transparency reports don't mean anything to me. Just because a company says "we're good guys, seriously, look at some numbers", are we to be so impressed? The flaw is not the company's actions, but the user's misplaced trust in a separate, private entity with their data.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- higherpurpose 12y agoDo they have a Zero Knowledge policy or anything close to it, though? It doesn't matter if they don't make money from it, if they still collect all the data. I don't know how a service that's meant to cache data is supposed to be "zero knowledge", but hopefully they can do something about that - until it's too late and authorities already have a 1,000 requests lined up for their data.
- tomp 12y agoIt's not just supposed to cache data (though it probably makes sense for most static data), it can also act as a firewall for your dynamic data, improving response times and preventing DDoS.
- proggR 12y agoThere was an article[1] from a few years ago about Cloudflare's infrastructure and from the sounds of it they can't link customers to data. Data does exists because that's the nature of a cache, but its defined with an undefined timestamp and is purged regularly in order to have enough disk space. >Unlike most database applications, the cache stored at each CloudFlare facility has an undefined expiration date—and because of the nature of those facilities, it isn't a simple matter to add more storage. To keep the utilization level of installed storage high, the cache system simply purges older cache data when it needs to store new content. >The downside of the hash-based cache's simplicity is that it has no built-in logging system to track content. CloudFlare can't tell customers which data centers have copies of which content they've posted. "A customer will ask me, 'Tell me all of the files you have in cache,'" Prince said. "For us, all we know is there are a whole bunch of hashes sitting on a disk somewhere—we don't keep track of which object belongs to what site." [1] - http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/10/one-big-cluster-how-cloudflare-launched-10-data-centers-in-30-days/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/10/one-bi...