7 ms·
How is suicide "unreasonable"? Albert Camus wrote in "Le mythe de Sysiphe": > Il n'y a qu'un problème philosophique vraiment sérieux: c'est le suicide. Juger q
by bambax 12y ago
How is suicide "unreasonable"? Albert Camus wrote in "Le mythe de Sysiphe":
> Il n'y a qu'un problème philosophique vraiment sérieux: c'est le suicide. Juger que la vie vaut ou ne vaut pas la peine d'être vécue, c'est répondre à la question fondamentale de la philosophie.
(There is only one really serious philosophical question, and that's suicide. Deciding whether or not life is worth living is answering the fundamental question of all of philosophy.)
If you arrive at the conclusion that there is no point to any of it, why not end your life on your own terms? We will all die eventually; it seems to me more courageous to decide of the moment.
We regard suicide as the ultimate failure; but isn't it, rather, the ultimate choice? And isn't that the problem?
Suicide in a way is an insult to the living, that's what makes us hate it so much.
Of course, not all suicides are equal; teenage suicide is especially tragic, for the exact reasons given in the article (I had a cousin who killed himself at 24; for everybody who survived him, and esp. his brothers and sisters, and his parents, it's an incredible ordeal, a wound that will probably never heal).
But we should respect the decision of a middle-aged man who had a wonderful and very successful career, and maybe came to the conclusion that he's done. We're not him, we'll never know how he felt anyway.
- DanBC 12y agoSuicide is often not a real choice made with full information. Suicide is usually a feature of illness. Suggesting that the completed suicide of an older person means less than that of a teenager is fucking abhorrant.
- igravious 12y agoTut, tut. They did not say it means less, they said that it was more understandable (and it is). The older person has more experience of life and gotten more from life because they (surprise, surprise) have lived longer than a younger person. And we all know those final years, quality-wise, can be pretty fucking awful whereas a young person has checked out before the complexities of middle age kick in. If you had the choice would you prefer your son or daughter to kill themselves at the age of 22 or 62 if it was inevitable they were going to take their own life? Or you think it doesn't matter?
- philh 12y ago> They did not say it means less, they said that it was more understandable "teenage suicide is especially tragic"?
- Luc 12y agoThe way you curse could be an indication to yourself that you are not approaching this in an even-tempered way.
- DanBC 12y agoOr perhaps I just fucking swear a lot?
- Luc 12y agoHaha, yes, that is possible too!
- jessaustin 12y agoThis seems common in discussions of suicide. One universalizes one's own experience, so that one hears other opinions of suicide in general or even different specific suicides as opinions about the specific suicide of one's own relative or friend. This doesn't lead to rational conversation, since how is some stranger on the internet entitled to an opinion of my loved one's suicide? It would be healthier to realize that any specific suicide is its own event, and that it's not healthy to make of it a Procrustean exemplar of all suicides. However, grief is often heedless of what is healthy.
- seanflyon 12y agoThe loss of a loved one is a tragic painful thing, but I do think that teenage suicide is especially tragic for two reasons. 1) Teenagers lack the perspective and maturity to understand that decision. 2) Teenagers (in general) have much more of their lives ahead of them. I think it is tragic if someone losses the last decade of their life and more tragic if they lose the last 7 decades.
- 7952 12y agoThis kind of philosophical thinking is interesting and all. But it is a mistake to dwell on it too deeply because it is so egocentric. So what if life is meaningless, why does that actually matter? Why does it matter if your actions are couragous or cowardly? When I am around other people I am more likely to concentrate on the practicalities of being happy instead of the abstract study of personal worth. I understand that none of this probably has much to do with serious depression.
- JimmyM 12y ago> So what if life is meaningless, why does that actually matter? Well this is not very far from what Camus effectively landed on, the acceptance of the absurd. There's a lot that's simplified and removed from your statement, but I think you would find a lot more to agree with in Camus than you might expect. He was certainly not a nihilist or solipsist. EDIT: To clarify, Camus thought the opposite of the grandparent comment, and was not on team suicide.
- selmnoo 12y agoThat is the truth that I unfortunately learned too late, at least, way after I spent way too much time ruminating about concepts of free will and determinism. Now, I have a very dispiriting view of humanity (the fact that we evolved from primates who'd fight a lot, rape a lot, etc.), it does much to take away 'meaning' from my life. I wish I'd never spent the time I did thinking so much about all of these things alone in the late night. If I'd been more outgoing, more social, I think I would not have this negative and sorrowful outlook in life. I strongly suspect that others pondering the Camus question of suicide are similarly alone or asocial. I encourage everyone to get busy in social doings -- it does a lot to take this off your mind and let you live life normally.
- Luc 12y agoI think you might get something out of reading 'Happiness' by Matthieu Ricard. http://www.amazon.com/dp/B007K9W0KM/ http://www.amazon.com/dp/B007K9W0KM/ It's a nice rational introduction to Buddhist thought on happiness, which I thought might be relevant because of their acknowledgement of 'Dukkha', i.e. 'suffering'. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dukkha http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dukkha
- return0 12y agoCamus quote has nothing to do with 'rationalizing suicide'. It's in fact about how to rationalize the opposite.
- bambax 12y agoYes, Camus does not defend suicide, and advocates instead living life to the fullest, whether or not there is any "meaning" to it. But the question remains, and if it's not to be only rhetorical, it's certainly possible to answer it differently than he did.
- imgabe 12y ago> Deciding whether or not life is worth living This rankles. Why does life have to be "worth" living? What is the yardstick of value you're judging life against? Life simply is. Unless you're in extreme chronic pain, I can't see why oblivion would be preferable. You'll get there eventually anyway, no need to rush it. In the meantime there is more than enough here to explore for one lifetime.
- pinkyand 12y agoSevere depression is a kind of "extreme chronic pain".
- msandford 12y ago> Why does life have to be "worth" living? Why do you get to impose your values on someone else about a thing you literally can't know? Murder is illegal because you're depriving someone else from their right to life. The person who does the killing is the criminal and the person being killed is the victim. But I can't steal money from myself can I? So in that regard, neither can I murder myself. Every person has the moral right to end their own lives even if we don't like it and don't understand it. Of course it's illegal to kill yourself, but not because the justice system has any ability to prosecute a corpse. It's so that people who try to kill themselves and fail badly at it can be temporarily restrained and given medical attention.
- imgabe 12y agoIn what way am I imposing my values on anyone? I'm simply asking a question. Has this comment somehow deprived you of the ability to have your own opinion?
- kaoD 12y ago> Why does life have to be "worth" living? Because life requires effort which some people might not like to spend. > What is the yardstick of value you're judging life against? Against not living. If value/effort < 1 suicide seems like a pretty logical decision.
- Ntrails 12y ago
- segmondy 12y agoI disagree with you. I read a story of a middle aged man that jumped off a bridge and survived. What I recall was that the moment he jumped, he regretted it as he knew he couldn't undo the jump, and realized that he could fix things in his life. He later did succeed in killing himself later. Suicide might be the "ultimate choice", but sometimes, it's the "ultimate irrational choice" because someone is suffering from an illness.
- ProAm 12y agoDo you know why he killed himself later if he felt such regret immediately after the first jump? That seems odd, unless the first jump caused enough problems physically for him going forward?
- dfxm12 12y agoCan't speak to this exact situation, but like the parent said: because someone is suffering from an illness
- dfxm12 12y agoIf you arrive at the conclusion that there is no point to any of it, why not end your life on your own terms? Is it your own terms if your mind is clouded by sickness? I know people decline treatment of diseases for several reasons, but we are speaking philosophically here. it seems to me more courageous to decide of the moment. Is it courageous to leave behind others to pick up the pieces? I know this isn't always the case and I wouldn't call suicide "cowardly", but I might call it "selfish".
- penguat 12y agoActually, that aspect of selfishness is a part of the barrier keeping me from it. It's a terrible thing to inflict upon the people close to you. And yes, I've been pretty depressed sometimes.
- romaniv 12y agoIf you arrive at the conclusion that there is no point to any of it, why not end your life on your own terms? Because... If you don't believe there is any point to life, what makes you believe there is any point in death? At least with life there is a possibility of change, and capacity to help others who don't share your outlook.
- mcguire 12y ago"But we should respect the decision of a middle-aged man who had a wonderful and very successful career, and maybe came to the conclusion that he's done." Consider what it means for that decision to be rational. Or rather, consider just one immediate corollary: Those of us who know we are not going to have "wonderful and very successful" lives, certainly not as successful as Williams, should immediately kill ourselves. Rationality has this weird nature of being prescriptive, right? "Suicide in a way is an insult to the living..." How could a reasonable, rational choice be an insult to anyone or anything? The decision to commit suicide, or to not do so for that matter, is not especially rational. But then, most major questions aren't either.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wavefunction 12y agoI think bambax meant that the living often take the "suicide" of someone we know as an insult, that we perhaps weren't good enough friends or family or that we missed something. This is true sometimes, though often it isn't and there is nothing that could prevent the suicide from eventually occurring.
- nsxwolf 12y agoI envision a day when your thinking prevails and suicide prevention hotlines become controversial - seen as a new kind of bigotry.
- hangonhn 12y ago"We're not him, we'll never know how he felt anyway." Therefore, don't pass judgment on him or anyone else, even the 24 year old. It is a tragedy for the living but that's all we know. There is nothing dignified, rational, or courageous about being able or being unable to decide the manner of your death. You die. That's the fact. The manner of it doesn't change that. Thinking one death is better than another is an illusion that the living imparts on the event. There are certainly painful ways to die but we should withhold other adjectives like courageous, dignified, etc. A soldier getting blown to bits by a shell didn't die a better or worse death than his comrade who live to die of a sudden heart attack. Nor is a cancer patient who endures painful rounds of chemotherapy only to die in some horrifying way any less courageous than one who chooses to end it by suicide. What we do have some small measure of control over is how we live and that's what really matters.
- johndolan 12y agoI think this question is a lot like asking if an obese person wants to eat themselves to death, should we let them? You can debate whether or not it is morally justifiable to allow this to happen, but you can't really argue that it is healthy behavior.
- lutusp 12y ago> ... but you can't really argue that it is healthy behavior. Of course you can. Suppose you've been told that you have inoperable pancreatic cancer and that the end will be painful even with the best medications (often true). How is it healthy behavior to suffer through such an end? The bottom line is that suicide should be accepted as an option in some cases. The fact that it isn't (generally) accepted only shows that public ethical thinking is primitive, shallow and indifferent to the needs of individuals. This is slowly changing. A few U.S. states have adopted assisted suicide laws to deal with scenarios like the example above: http://euthanasia.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourceID=000132 http://euthanasia.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourceID=00...