6 ms·
The manager and the moron (1967)
- mdda 12y agoThis is a great article for the corporate titans of yesteryear, which puts today's 'innovation malaise' into perspective (as well as putting the IT boom in a historical context). For instance : """ Perhaps the greatest shock to our Rip Van Winkle economist, however, would be the fact that, with the exception of the plastics industry, the main engines of growth in the past 50 years were already mature or rapidly maturing industries, based on well-known technologies, back in 1913. """ and """ Within the next ten years, information will become very much cheaper. An hour of computer time today costs several hundred dollars at a minimum; I have seen figures that put the cost at about a dollar an hour in 1973 or so. Maybe it won’t come down that steeply, but come down it will. """ Overall, a very interesting read.
- VLM 12y ago"as well as putting the IT boom in a historical context" From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_world_product http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_world_product The gross world domestic product in 2012, using 2012 value dollars, was a bit under 72 trillion dollars. Gross facebook revenue per google in 2013 was 7.9 billion dollars. Some arithmetic done in my head and to one sig fig facebooks revenue is about one ten thousandth of the worlds GDP. Fortunes can be made in tech, but its always going to be a rounding error compared to food, shelter, etc. There's just too many people eating, for example.
- tgflynn 12y agoIt's amusing and amazing that anyone with so many very wrong notions could have been taken seriously in 1967. I'm not saying he was wrong about everything, just almost everything. Here are a couple of gems: Twenty years hence, an institution that’s the equivalent of a steel mill in terms of mental work—MIT, for example—might well have its own computer. Technically there is no reason why Sears, Roebuck could not offer tomorrow, for the price of a television set, a plug-in appliance that would put us in direct contact with all the information needed for schoolwork from kindergarten through college. So there were no computers at MIT in 1967 (So what was that Whirlwind thing back in 1948) but Sears and Roebuck could have invented the Internet that year. I think by far the most twisted notion in the article is the idea that little changed between 1913 and 1967. I'm pretty sure technological change during that period had more impact on the average Westerner's life than any other 54 year time span in history. It takes a very peculiar world view to completely ignore the invention of television or to consider a biplane as being basically equivalent to a jumbo jet.
- gd1 12y agoStrange, I read it and had the opposite reaction. With the exception of the 'steel mill' quote you mentioned, I think he got it mostly right. Even that can be argued to be right to a degree, for a time the mainframe model was in vogue and now we're moving towards the 'cloud'. The little change mentioned between 1913 and 1967 was with reference to the overall trajectory of industrial economies, not technological innovation. The main thrust was about the increasing importance of knowledge and information, where he was spot on.
- tgflynn 12y agoYes but that's a very broad observation that I suspect many people could have arrived at. Generalization is important but if the person doing the generalizing is so ill-informed about the details of their world I think the likelihood of their generalizations being correct is rather low.
- bewo001 12y agoIf you replace 'steel mill' with 'data center', he was not so far off. At least if you don't count phones, tablets, laptops as computers.
- brazzy 12y ago> So there were no computers at MIT in 1967 You cpmpletely misunderstood that paragraph. He said that MIT would still have its own computer in 20 years because knowledge is its core business, but that other institutions would, instead of owning their own computers, use rented ones remotely. He was basically predicting cloud computing.
- coriny 12y ago"I think by far the most twisted notion in the article is the idea that little changed between 1913 and 1967. I'm pretty sure technological change during that period had more impact on the average Westerner's life than any other 54 year time span in history. It takes a very peculiar world view to completely ignore the invention of television or to consider a biplane as being basically equivalent to a jumbo jet." That's not what it says at all. He states that the 60s economy is still dominated by technologies that pre-date 1913. He even specifically cites the economically dominant technologies, instead of the vague assertion, "I'm pretty sure ...". He particularly notes aeroplanes and computers as being invented during that period and can be expected to have enormous economic impact. Which they did, but hadn't by that point. The same with television. Looking at the rest of your comment, I kind of think you should delete and reread the article. Every criticism is incorrect or unsupported - like the MIT crack. He's clearly talking about the "thin client" approach to providing computing - he was wrong, but it was not an unreasonable supposition to make.
- BWStearns 12y agoAside from the debate over the MIT has/has-not a computer in 1967 or will in 1987, I think the more interesting aspect of the piece is the normative suggestions it has in terms of thinking about how computers should be used in organizations. The notion that it eliminates the instinctual and actually introduces information is actually an incredible insight to have at the dawn of available(ish) computing. One developed, if one had any sense, a reasonably good instinct for what invention was plausible and likely to fly, and what wasn’t. But real information just wasn’t to be had. Now, for the first time, it’s beginning to be available—and the overall impact on society is bound to be very great Looking at the behavior of large organizations it's clear to see that many of them have not internalized this insight. In terms of exploiting what computers can mean for non-technically oriented organizations we haven't gotten much farther than the payrolls he mentions, " I’m not saying we shouldn’t be using the computer for payrolls, but that’s beside the point. If payrolls were all it could do, we wouldn’t be interested in it." It's always nice to chew on some good old thoughts that are still relevant.
- mark-r 12y agoThis is really impressive, it shows a clarity of thought and awareness of the impact that trends of the day would have on the future. Most people predicting the future don't do it nearly as well. But even with all that, Peter Drucker couldn't predict Moore's Law.
- markbnj 12y agoHis comments about the perishable nature of knowledge are spot on.
- michaelochurch 12y agoAn exponential function, if you zoom in to your local spot, looks linear. This got Malthus. (Actually, Malthus's model was wrong but his conclusion wasn't far off. The world had been continually experiencing Malthusian catastrophes until about 1850, when the rate of economic growth overtook population growth. Colonialism was, to a large degree, Europe outsourcing its Malthusian catastrophes. For an intra-continental example, see: Irish potato famine.) He thought economic growth was linear, not exponential. OP's claim that 1913 to 1967 was an era of minimal (linear) change couldn't have been more wrong. While many nations returned to economic "trend line" there was a lot of, um, painful stuff in between. Even if you downplay World War I and II, you've still got the 1918 flu, the Great Depression, etc. Also, the US went from a regional power to a superpower in about 30 years, while Europe dealt with poverty (and lingering remnants of fascism) into the 1960s. That's a change. Only Americans (excluding those who served in the wars) had the privilege of saying that 1913 to 1967 was a smooth ride. Oddly enough, this time period (in which he understates progress) was written when world GDP growth was at its all-time (unmatched, even now) peak of 5.7% per year (we're around 4.5% now, which is better than we've been). The R&D efforts that didn't seem to be delivering (because flying cars and AI hadn't been invented yet) were already pushing the economy to grow faster than it ever has (and will have, as of 2014). It got a bad rap ("people in those cushy R&D labs aren't earning their keep") because it underperformed relative to unreasonable expectations, not because it wasn't working. (Oh, and there was that perceptron thing; the bit of high-school geometry needed to show that a single perceptron can't do XOR became "neural networks don't work" became "AI is a dud".) So we have a lot to learn from the 1960s, and as a society, we should consider dumping the Snapchat nonsense in order to some real R&D.
- Aardwolf 12y agoSome pretty funny gems in there, e.g.: "To be sure, the computer has created something that had never existed in the history the world—namely, paying jobs for mathematicians."
- floppydisk 12y agoI thought his comments on management were quite interesting regarding how management would have to change. """ Our greatest managerial failure rate comes in the step from middle to top management. Most middle managers are doing essentially the same things they did on their entrance jobs: controlling operations and fighting fires. In contrast, the top manager’s primary function is to think. The criteria for success at the top level bear little resemblance to the criteria for promotion from middle management. The new top manager, typically, has been promoted on the basis of his ability to adapt successfully. But suddenly he’s so far away from the firing line that he doesn’t know what to adapt to—so he fails. He may be an able man, but nothing in his work experience has prepared him to think. He hasn't the foggiest notion how one goes about making entrepreneurial or policy decisions. That’s why the failure rate at the senior-management level is so high. In my experience, two out of three men promoted to top management don’t make it; they stay middle management. They aren’t necessarily fired. Instead, they get put on the Executive Committee with a bigger office, a bigger title, a bigger salary—and a higher nuisance value because they have had no exposure to thinking. This is a situation we are going to eliminate. From experience, I think this is still somewhat apt today in that we push people to go through the grunt -> middle manager -> upper management chain with a detour through an MBA program possibly tossed in for good measure rather than grooming people to think and develop a different kind of leadership. It's an interesting thought. I'm not sure how applicable it is to entrepreneurship as to small to mid-size companies, but I think it's worth nothing. Interesting stuff!
- bernardlunn 12y agoGreat comment. I think it explains why the "topple rate" is increasing ie more big old companies getting toppled by startups led by entrepreneurs who think.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y agoIs that actually the case now? (that the rate is increasing).
- digikata 12y agoIf anything the problem may be increased today. E.g. IBM in 1960 had around 100k employees, and today has around 430k. The distance between a "line" employee and executive team has to have increased with that scale up of employee count. Communications technology has helped somewhat, but I wonder if large companies might be paying a scaling toll.
- dredmorbius 12y ago"But the real impact will come with the big freight jets, which will make every airstrip in the world a deep-water port. In a few years, they may make the ocean-going freighter, man’s oldest efficient transportation, look roughly the way the railroads began to look around 1950." And yet, it's rather the reverse. Air cargos exist, but they're low weight, high volume. From the US DOT "Freight Transporation, Global Highlights 2010", total world ocean freight exports were 8,032 million short tons in 2007. Total air freight handled by the top 25 world airports was 34.535 million tons. That's 234 tons of ocean cargo per ton of air cargo. The real revolution was in containerization, not air freight. The leading seaport (Shanghai) handled 561.446 million tons of freight. The leading airport (Hong Kong), only 1.462 million. The energy cost of air travel per ton mile is roughly 250 times that of ocean cargo -- about 5.9 ton miles per gallon for a Boeing 777 (I don't have 747 numbers handy), vs. about 1500 ton miles/gallon for a large container ship.