5 ms·
F.C.C. Chairman Ponders Net Neutrality
- click170 12y agoI feel like there's not much more to be said at this point. Almost every argument I've heard against Net Neutrality that isn't based on "this is the way Peering agreements have always worked" and "its my network, Ill do what I want" have been disproven, or have been shown to be straw-men. Are there any new discussion points that haven't been debated to death? The FCC Chairman himself has been involved with a company that was shutdown due to lack of open access.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoThe strongest argument against network neutrality goes like this: If we had real competition then we wouldn't need network neutrality. And it's a completely valid argument. If we had real competition then we wouldn't need network neutrality. But we don't have real competition. So the only sensible thing to do is to have network neutrality until and unless that changes.
- fredo699 12y agoI am completely against net neutrality. The problem I have is that people think it's a solution rather than a stop-gap. The problem is still, ultimately, that we have monopolies at play. That's the real issue. But for some reason, all of this effort and energy has been focused on getting net neutrality, rather than fixing the actual problem. I also don't think that ISPs would ever do some of the things that people are spreading fud about. I have serious doubts they would ever block certain sites for business reasons. We already have laws against that. I doubt they'd ever turn sites into a package you need a monthly access fee for either. People don't like paying more for less. They'd never so blatantly piss off their entire customer base like that when they really only stand to lose money. It's much more in their favor to keep things working the way they are now, except to allow some sites that need a lot of bandwidth the speeds they need.
- mschuster91 12y ago> I have serious doubts they would ever block certain sites for business reasons. Comcast and other ISPs have blocked (by massively reducing the data rate) entire PROTOCOLS, in this case BitTorrent. Irrespective if you downloaded a Linux ISO or the latest fetish porn movie.
- fredo699 12y agoWell, it's actually well within their right to do that as a business. It's also well within your right, as a customer not to do business with them. However, this whole situation would be solved if we just focused on what was important, like I said: fixing the monopoly problem rather than the "net neturality" problem, if it even is one.
- msandford 12y agoYou said: >>> I have serious doubts they would ever block certain sites for business reasons. Someone replied: >> Comcast and other ISPs have blocked (by massively reducing the data rate) entire PROTOCOLS, in this case BitTorrent. Irrespective if you downloaded a Linux ISO or the latest fetish porn movie. So then you reply: > Well, it's actually well within their right to do that as a business. What I see here is a contradiction. First you say "I doubt they'd ever do that!" and then when provided with an example of them doing very nearly (if not precisely) that, you then say "Well they're within their rights!" I agree with you that fixing the monopoly problem is the real solution. I personally think that muni-run last mile networks are the way to do that and to write new laws that authorize, encourage and otherwise enable neighborhoods to run co-ops be they fiber, copper, wifi, etc. But until such a time as there is robust competition (meaning any one person has say 10 broadband options) I am in favor of net neutrality as patchwork and evolutionary as it is. At least then the "best practices" that ISPs generally lived by for some years would be codified and allow people to sue, thus providing SOME recourse against abusive monopolies. I realize that regulatory capture is a real risk so I'm not overwhelmingly in favor of, it's by a slim margin. The reason I picked a number like 10 instead of say 3 or 5 is basically "look at the cell phone market" It's pretty terrible and I think some of that can be attributed to the big four (AT&T, Verizon, Sprint, T-Mobile) and not much else at least in the way of good coverage national carriers.
- rhino369 12y agoI think the strongest argument against net neutrality is that the US has gone through long periods without it and none of the doomsday scenarios have occurred. I see no reason why we shouldn't take a wait and see approach. I could see paid prioritization having some benefits. The average internet service provider customer is cheap as fuck. They buy the cheapest service and bitch about rising costs. Though if isps going crazy we can always just pass net neutrality.
- pinwale 12y ago>I think the strongest argument against net neutrality is that the US has gone through long periods without it and none of the doomsday scenarios have occurred. Incorrect, the Internet in the United States has been under de-facto net neutrality rules through a patchwork of agreements, policy statements, and regulations. The current debate is just about formalizing the legal method & the scope of any rules to maintain a "Open Internet". (That is the term that the FCC uses for the various net neutrality issues.)
- rhino369 12y agoAs far as I can tell, there was no regulation before the 2005 open internet regulations. The ISPs generally obeyed it before, but they generally obey it now. I'm not seeing the dire need for formal regulations.
- pinwale 12y agoThey all generally obeyed them because those ISPs didn't want to tangle with the FCC and their Open Internet order. (Who does?) Also at various times before the 2005 regulations, certain parts of the internet infrastructure were under regulations that had the side effect of having a neutral internet. The reason why the formalizing the rules is now an issue is because a federal court has thrown out the legal method the FCC had been using to wave at ISPs to be neutral. So now there is no ruling, and the ISPs wouldn't have spent all that time & money on lawyers to preserve what they just took down. So right now, the FCC is going to release new rules on the Open Internet. The question is, will it be under a new interpretation of the old method that was thrown out of court (Section 702), or by calling ISPs common carriers and then forbearing most of the sections in Title II (as the court alluded is possible).
- smutticus 12y agoThis article doesn't actually tell us anything. It's just a mini-bio of Wheeler. Still it's good that the NYT is net neutrality in the news. We've got to keep the pressure on these people. If you have had a terrible experience with Comcast another operator lately, especially if they're denying you service, file a complaint with the FCC. http://www.fcc.gov/complaints http://www.fcc.gov/complaints
- edlebert 12y agoGee, I wonder how it will all go down. I mean, all those people supported comcast by _not_ sending comments to the FCC, right?
- orthecreedence 12y ago"The results are in, amigo. What's left to ponder?" Seriously though, it this just blatant corporate chronyism or what? It's getting to the point where the corporate douchebags running this country aren't even trying to hide the fact anymore. At least before we could pretend we had democratic process. Now we get trampled on day in day out and we don't even get warm fuzzy feelings about it like we used to. And is it just me, or is just about everyone "too busy" to even give a fuck where the country is going?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- snarfy 12y agoWhy should they? They have no reason to fear the government, and rightly so as we don't give them one.
- stevenh 12y agoSame content sans absurd paywall. http://www.dallasnews.com/business/technology/headlines/20140928-with-perspective-from-both-sides-fcc-chairman-ponders-net-neutrality.ece http://www.dallasnews.com/business/technology/headlines/2014...
- jostmey 12y agoIt will be disgusting if the FCC does not side with the will of the populous. So why hasn't a decision been reached? Quite simply Tom Wheeler is letting his name shine in the public spotlight to build political clout.
- deciplex 12y ago"populace"
- angrymonk 12y agoI would like to take this moment to thank everyone for giving the Internet to FCC on a platter. May FCC be the benevolent masters and we be their dutiful servants.
- brandonmenc 12y agoThey'll likely never relinquish control, and only succeed in adding to their Internet regulating duties. This is the organization that considers a nipple slip unlawful television content. Didn't we spend the 90s worrying about exactly this? What one hand giveth...