3 ms·
> The big problem is: what happens when a cop comes out on a call and there is clear photographic evidence of a crime being committed (very likely, considering
by tzs 12y ago
> The big problem is: what happens when a cop comes out on a call and there is clear photographic evidence of a crime being committed (very likely, considering the sheer number of things that are technically illegal)? When there is clear video evidence of, say, possession of paraphernalia, assault, public intoxication, or whatever else, it suddenly becomes a lot easier to pick on citizens
Worse, if these routine recordings leak, or if they are available to the public under freedom of information requests or something similar, then every time a cop lets someone off who they could have arrested someone will find a reason to criticize that. If they let a white person off, they will be complaints that they would have arrested the guy if he was black. If they let a black guy off, there will be complaints that they only care about stopping crime in white neighborhoods. Let a woman off with a warning on a traffic stop, and there will be complaints that a man would have received a ticket.
It will not take officers long to figure out that they are a lot better off if they arrest every one of these paraphernalia possessors, publicly intoxicated people, and so on that they see and let the courts sort them out. No one will be happy with this.
- DanBC 12y agoEach officer (I guess, it's true in England) has some discretion. Allowing officers to make it up as they go along does seem like a really bad idea. Evidence-based guidelines about when to arrest and when to have a discussion should be welcomed and would be one consequence of the situation you're describing. Rather than just arresting everyone because the camera shows evidence the officer can point to their guidelines when they don't arrest.