3 ms·
This struck me as more representative of other sites. Like, the one we're on now: The No Humor Rule: Humor is a de facto taboo on Quora. While the occasional d
by Karunamon 12y ago
This struck me as more representative of other sites. Like, the one we're on now:
The No Humor Rule:
Humor is a de facto taboo on Quora. While the occasional demonstration of witwill evoke no more than a scowl and shake of the head from the community, more regular use will draw a barrage of down votes and risk the possibility of banishment. The staff attempts to deny that this istrue but fails to convince anyone. Many Quorans simply don't appreciate humor and will automatically down vote any post that contains it.
s/quora/HN/g
That said, the author of this piece tries really, really hard to bash on Quora for their login policy. You have to be logged in to contribute or to read.
Honestly? I think they're reading far too much into that.
- lucb1e 12y agos/HN/StackOverflow/ But I'm not sure it's a bad thing on either HN or StackOverflow. On SO I think it's far worse than on HN, but it might be necessary to keep things under control.
- vezzy-fnord 12y agoI've found that HN is overall tolerant of the occasional bit of humor or even snark, definitely to a point where you do not feel constrained.
- idlewords 12y agoI've found it to be a viper pit of humorless aspies
- tptacek 12y agoAre humorless aspies really all that dangerous?
- cloakandswagger 12y agoIndividually, no. In large numbers they'll spark a chain reaction of humorless over-analyzing which consumes and ultimately destroys the herd.
- idlewords 12y agoIt's a pun on asp/viper OH MY GOD YOU'RE ONE OF THEM
- tptacek 12y agoAnd scene.
- defen 12y agoYour comparison of non-neurotypical people to deadly venomous snakes is not only dehumanizing but also incorrect. Sure, if a person bit you, the wound might get infected and eventually cause problems, but it would almost certainly be treatable with a standard first aid kit. A viper bite would require immediate treatment with antivenom to prevent necrosis, limb amputation, or potentially even death.
- hawkice 12y agoI feel this is precisely the type of post HN needs. Faux-sanctimonious high-wire-act humor. I hope you get millions of upvotes.
- tim333 12y agoI've noticed the lack of humour enthusiasm on HN too. I guess maybe as the article suggests it does not translate well internationally.
- DanBC 12y agoMost "funny" comments are just not funny. Comments that don't add anything to the conversation should[1] be downvoted. Funny comments that are funny tend to get upvotes. Humour is harder than spouting movie quotes or similar meme-based stuff. [1] downvoting on HN is currently perplexing. Easiest way to get downvotes is to make a post with a clear but simple factual error - something easily fixed with a comment and an edit. In another thread someone was told to "go and die" and that comment is still live after an hour or so.
- simias 12y agoI agree with some of the points the author makes (although I've never contributed to quora myself) but I think he's misguided there. In my opinion the problem with humour is not that it can be misunderstood by international readers, it's that it's very hard to find the sweet spot where the comment threads turn into a competition to find the wittiest/stupidest joke/pun on the article being discussed. I think the issue is that most jokes don't really contribute to the discussion and unlike slashdot you can't motivate your vote (+5 funny vs. +5 insightful). There's also the problem that humour is hard to judge objectively and is likely to annoy as many users as it amuses. That being said, if you make a very skillful, spiritual and/or topical joke on HN you might be upvoted, I've seen it happen in the past (with things like poems, lyrics and other "not-so-serious" content). Also, of all the points the author makes, this one is the only one IMO that's really applicable to HN so I don't think it's possible to draw a parallel between Quora and HN (if that's what you were trying to do).
- minimaxir 12y agoA trend I've noticed among Quora posts that attempt to be funny is that they are bad at doing it, such as using Reddit-level responses contained with puns/memes. That type of "humor" died years ago.
- protonfish 12y agoI agree the rules for quality content over nonsense at HN have been widely overshot. I wish comments and submissions were judged on value alone - interesting ideas, new facts, entertaining reading - irrespective of content including some silliness or even gasp potty-language. I have been criticized and downvoted many times for being "snarky" even if I made a factual and well-reasoned comment. This is the goddamn Internet, not tea with the fucking queen. I'd prefer a community that values substance over style and passion over politeness. (Not like there is anything better than HN and I just got downvoting privileges so I am not going anywhere for a long time. Bwa ha ha ha!) And I get it, I can be a real dick. Ask anyone. I don't blame anyone for being mad at me occasionally but I wish others would have enough tolerance to get over their delicate feelings enough to appreciate content that does not jibe with their own self-delusions or is written with uncomfortable emotion. I am feeling a little burned by this today. This morning I clicked a link off the home page to read a rant by weev against people bashing bash and Stallman. Reading that felt like letting loose a fart built up after a long job interview. It was a joy to read something so frank and passionate whether I agree with it or not. (And in this case he made some excellent points.) It made me realize how stuffy and afraid of breaking consensus everything else on HN was. I hit my back button to comment and it was no longer anywhere to be found. Shame on you, HN.
- mullingitover 12y ago> Honestly? I think they're reading far too much into that. I honestly hated them for their login policy. They deserved to fail purely for that stunt alone.
- Karunamon 12y agoWhat "stunt"? Why is this such a big deal to people? I've never found a login to be a particularly onerous thing.