3 ms·
> But what takes place is just the opposite. Today we work much more than ever before. All you need to do is to compare the pace of our lives and that of our gr
by skrebbel 12y ago
> But what takes place is just the opposite. Today we work much more than ever before. All you need to do is to compare the pace of our lives and that of our grandparents.
A German philosopher says this to a Portuguese interviewer, and it is not questioned? I am convinced that most people in Europe nowadays work less and less hard than they did 40 years ago. I can understand that it is not questioned on HN, given that most of us live in a culture where working 80 hours a week is considered normal, but in Europe? Come on.
I'm from the Netherlands. My grandfather was an old man at 65, tired and broken from a life of hard farm work. When I came to visit as a child, we'd talk a bit and that was it. My parents, now older than my granddad then, play with my son with vigor and love. They're fitter and happier, because they didn't work as hard.
I work 4 days a week. My girlfriend three. We don't consider these numbers a temporary situation. Everybody I know thinks what we do is normal.
I didn't look up the stats, but it seems to me that either I'm really weird, or the quoted philosopher likes to selectively pick out those facts that support his rant.
- jahaja 12y agoPlease do look up the stats before going on an anecdotal evidence binge.
- skrebbel 12y agoNo, I won't. HN is a place for civilized discussion, but not a place where only deeply and scientifically researched observations may stand a chance. It's so easy to debunk an argument with "you have no stats". I bring just as many stats to the table as the philosopher in the article, and we're here, discussing the article, no?
- clarry 12y ago> I work 4 days a week. My girlfriend three. I study six days and two evenings a week. I have trouble affording food.
- skrebbel 12y agoAnd you live in Western Europe? And there are many peers like you?
- clarry 12y agoNorthern Europe. There are others like me, though I don't know how many there are. The problem is that there are some serious holes and twisted disincentives built into the welfare system. Basic income would be godsend. For instance they complain that people spend too much time in their studies, and are trying to incentivize people to graduate faster by granting some benefits related to the student loan if you graduate on a planned timeline. In my case however, I would get more if I had postponed my studies instead of starting studying in UoAS this year. I'd get more still if I dropped out of school entirely and lived on social security, unemployed... I know other people who are in a similar situation. For example, unemployed and unqualified middle-aged men with families and kids to feed. For them, the students' benefits are impossible to live on so they're incentivized against getting an education. They can somehow make it though, through crazy hoops than make no sense for the state nor for themselves.. it makes no sense for anyone. It's not clear what this all will lead to. I'm expected to graduate in about four years. The job prospects in my area have been piss poor (this reflects badly on my CV), and it's not sure yet whether they're getting better or not. So yeah, my lack of money is in part my own choice. I chose to study because I want to graduate sooner rather than later. Either way it sucks. And people around here want to downvote me for not wanting to pay $40 for a game/movie/book/software. Not realizing that it's almost two weeks worth of food for me...
- skrebbel 12y agoGood points. I actually agree with everything you said. I just don't think my grandpa had it better than us.
- clarry 12y agoMaybe. It really is hard to say. But some of the people are in the situation they are in now because some time ago, it was easy to get by. You didn't need qualifications if you were willing to work. That's how we got people who are now in their mid-to-late 40s, with no formal education. And they're suffering for it because today getting a job just isn't the same. And looking at how it goes today, young people are expected to spend a small eternity in educational institutions, and finally they come out with a piece of paper which states that they have the bare minimum of knowledge everyone else in the field already has. So they have to compete against every other fresh graduate, as well as everyone else who's already got a job history & real world experience to boast with. It does make me feel that maybe my grandpa had it better. And no, he wasn't a farmer.
- tokenadult 12y agoA German philosopher says this to a Portuguese interviewer, and it is not questioned? I am convinced that most people in Europe nowadays work less and less hard than they did 40 years ago. I can understand that it is not questioned on HN, given that most of us live in a culture where working 80 hours a week is considered normal, but in Europe? Come on. This is surely correct for a great many working people in many parts of the world. Moreover, the span of life over which people work is shorter at the young end, as people pursue more schooling before entering employment, and a reduced percentage of lifespan at the old end, as people have many years of retirement in reasonably good health with retirement benefits. P.S. I fear there was a mistaken downvote here, because this is a good comment.
- collyw 12y agoOut of interest, did you buy a property before the credit bubble? Here in Spain, and in the UK, people of a certain age (baby boomer generation) seem to be doing pretty well, while it looks like the younger generation are expected to pay for it.
- skrebbel 12y agoHmm, I'm not sure I entirely follow your logic, but no, I bought my house after the credit bubble. Still, it is currently worth less than when I bought it. I'm not happy about that, but I can just stay a homeowner until the prices are back up (if ever) and it won't hurt me much.