5 ms·
> The article does a good job of justifying this claim, though it goes a bit far in saying that students just cannot help but get distracted. Having just a text
by tzs 12y ago
> The article does a good job of justifying this claim, though it goes a bit far in saying that students just cannot help but get distracted. Having just a text editor to take notes requires some discipline but it's not entirely impossible either
Even if you have the discipline to just use a laptop for simple not taking, research suggests that this impairs learning compared to talking notes by hand. See "The Pen Is Mightier Than the Keyboard: Advantages of Longhand Over Laptop Note Taking", Psychological Science June 2014 vol. 25 no. 6 1159-1168 [1].
Here is an article about that research [2] for those who do not want to deal with the paywall the paper is behind, or who want something more readable than a scientific paper.
[1] http://pss.sagepub.com/content/25/6/1159 http://pss.sagepub.com/content/25/6/1159
[2] http://www.vox.com/2014/6/4/5776804/note-taking-by-hand-versus-laptop http://www.vox.com/2014/6/4/5776804/note-taking-by-hand-vers...
- leoc 12y ago> Even if you have the discipline to just use a laptop for simple not taking, research suggests that this impairs learning compared to talking notes by hand. See "The Pen Is Mightier Than the Keyboard: Advantages of Longhand Over Laptop Note Taking", Psychological Science June 2014 vol. 25 no. 6 1159-1168 [1]. That leaves you with a sheaf of longhand notes. So then you have to, what, go away and type them up into a text editor in order to get them into a tractable form? Well, I suppose that's going to further aid retention ... win-win? I must admit that I have a personal grudge against this nonsense as I can't write quickly enough to take adequate notes; in fact it's touch-and-go even when I can type. But even if you can generally keep up with the lecturer's pace taking notes on his output is a tightrope-walking exercise: one lapse of concentration or understanding and you have a permanent hole in your record. Then of course this whole process is being repeated by each of the n students at the lecture. In this day and age (or really at any time since photocopying got cheap several decades ago) organising a course where getting a complete copy of the important course materials requires you to turn up and spend hours transcribing someone else's speech in person is an insulting farrago and a mass time-wasting exercise. If it's important enough to be examining students on then it's important enough for the teacher to type it out or read it to video camera.
- graeme 12y agoYour comment, while long, did not respond to the cited article. The paper's abstract cites specific benefits to using handwritten notes, including: * laptop note takers’ tendency to transcribe lectures verbatim rather than processing information and reframing it in their own words is detrimental to learning. * even when laptops are used solely to take notes, they may still be impairing learning because their use results in shallower processing. It sounds like the study indicates that processing by hand is different from taking notes on a computer. To rebut the study, you should address those points, rather than just talk about advantages you have perceived to using laptops.
- WalterBright 12y ago> go away and type them up into a text editor in order to get them into a tractable form? Run them through a scanner, store as image pdfs. There won't be enough of the notes to justify making a searchable database out of them. > in fact it's touch-and-go even when I can type. I sometimes wished I'd used an audio recorder, though perhaps that might have made things worse as it'd engender laziness on my focus. > hours transcribing someone else's speech in person is an insulting farrago and a mass time-wasting exercise. Taking notes has the nice benefit of fixing it in one's memory.
- xenophonf 12y agoI bought a tablet PC for this purpose (OneNote is so freaking great) but have still had instructors claim that it would be too much of a distraction. I'm a grown man. I think at this point in my life, I both know how best I learn and possess the discipline to stay focused on class. Having electronic versions of my notes plus the ability to draw diagrams or use multiple colors/highlights is really, really awesome. It beats the hell out of doing the same with paper plus half a dozen pens/markers/highlighters.
- WalterBright 12y agoIt's amazing how advancing technology has made writing on tablets almost as good as paper :-)
- aggie 12y agoThe study doesn't show that writing on paper is necessarily more effective than typing notes on a laptop. The study shows that, when typing, students tends to transcribe verbatim, whereas when writing longhand they tend to paraphrase. This extra processing results in better understanding. This does not mean that you can't paraphrase while using a laptop, just that the students in this experimental setting tended to do that, presumably because they could type fast enough to transcribe verbatim and thus did so. So it's really just an issue of note taking style, not the medium.
- graeme 12y agoGood point. Though it's important to note that the reserchers identified an effect, and hypothesized about the mechanism. It's possible writing improves understanding for some reason other than/in addition to paraphrasing.
- a3_nm 12y agoThat's interesting. But even then, the argument would suggest that you let students take notes the way that works best for them, or just the way they prefer, no matter whether it's statistically less effective or not.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- aftbit 12y agoPerhaps, but what if the comparison is between taking sporadic notes by keyboard or taking no notes at all? When I was in college, if a class banned technology, I either had to pay attention if I wanted to pass, or I skipped the class.