4 ms·
As someone who does a lot-ish of public speaking at conferences as such, let me offer my 2c on tech in audiences. At a conference, people are always going to b
by Swizec 12y ago
As someone who does a lot-ish of public speaking at conferences as such, let me offer my 2c on tech in audiences.
At a conference, people are always going to be using technology. They are always going to be checking their phones, and they are always going to have a thousand things going on. That's just the fact. They're there for a whole day, or even multiple days, emails need to be checked, sometimes coding needs to be done, sometimes they just want to check up on what the talks in other tracks are about and consider switching.
Therefore it is my job as a presenter to make sure nobody is checking their phone. If I am interesting enough, laptops start closing, phones stop being checked, sometimes they even go into pockets. As soon as I lose the audience, all that tech comes back out.
And I think that's what a lot of professors forget - BE MORE INTERESTING. Have a better presentation style. Take public speaking classes. Do something to make yourself stand out above the distraction of internet and devices.
Because here's the thing, those professors who [have to] make attendance mandatory, are without exception the worst presenters. Same goes for banning tech. If you ban it, you're just saying "I suck at public speaking and I would rather you deal with that problem than I"
And yes, it is an amazing feeling when you start with a room of a hundred people each looking at a different screen and end with a room of a hundred people looking straight at you with all laptops closed and phones/tablets put away. It's got nothing to do with tech and everything to do with winning your audience over.
- a3_nm 12y ago> At a conference, people are always going to be using technology. They are always going to be checking their phones, and they are always going to have a thousand things going on. In computer science conferences in research (the area I'm familiar with) this tends to happen as well, but there is a venue (Schloß Dagstuhl) which has (among other interesting traditions, such as mandatory random seating assignments at meals) a policy of not having WiFi in the conference rooms. I think it is clear that had the WiFi been there almost everyone would have used it, yet somehow I only heard people talk positively of the no-WiFi policy... There is, I think, a sizeable proportion of people who see connectivity-induced multitasking as a weakness, and are happy when given an occasion to not indulge in it. > If I am interesting enough, laptops start closing, phones stop being checked Sometimes this is not enough. If you started with a room full of people doing something else, and the talk is sufficiently technical so that you can't start paying attention midway through, sometimes you can be faced with the very hard task of catching people's attention during the first few minutes when they still haven't noticed that someone else was talking... > those professors who [have to] make attendance mandatory (A side point, but from my experience of the university system (in France), mandatory attendance in classes is usually a policy set by the institution more than by the individual teachers.) I agree with your general point that being anti-tech in classes should not be an excuse for giving bad classes. But I don't think that's enough to dismiss the feeling. There's also another thing: professors teaching their students may not feel like it is their duty to earn their audience's attention, to have a slick and attractive presentation style, so as to compete with any possible distraction... They may feel like they can teach the class as they like, and it is the students' role to adjust. I think this balance between the professor's sense of entitlement and the students' varies a lot across cultures (also depending on how much the students pay for tuition, e.g., much less in France than in the US). But this is something where there can be a difference between classes at university, and conferences.
- Swizec 12y ago> Sometimes this is not enough. If you started with a room full of people doing something else, and the talk is sufficiently technical so that you can't start paying attention midway through, sometimes you can be faced with the very hard task of catching people's attention during the first few minutes when they still haven't noticed that someone else was talking... I've come up with a simple script to combat this problem. I start like this: "HI! Wow what a beautiful audience, you guys are awesome! Let me ask you something, <insert question about topic>" The "HI!" is a universal attention catcher, everyone subconsciously responds to that no matter what they're doing. (try it sometime in a busy office or something, just say HI). The second part tells the audience that this is going to be about them not you. And it establishes an instant connection - this trick I picked up from Russell Brand's standup routine. Finally, the question engages people's brain and gets them to start thinking about the topic. Granted, this approach might not work well in a classroom setting. But starting with a question should work great there as well. > There's also another thing: professors teaching their students may not feel like it is their duty to earn their audience's attention, to have a slick and attractive presentation style, so as to compete with any possible distraction... They may feel like they can teach the class as they like, and it is the students' role to adjust. I think this balance between the professor's sense of entitlement and the students' varies a lot across cultures (also depending on how much the students pay for tuition, e.g., much less in France than in the US). But this is something where there can be a difference between classes at university, and conferences. One of the most entitled professors I've ever had, was also the only person I've ever seen fill a classroom on a sunny May afternoon on a Friday. He literally considered students no better than cattle. The only prop he'd ever use was a piece of chalk and a chalkboard. No slides, no computer, not even any notes. Just scribbles on the chalkboard. But he had amazing charisma. When he entered the room, everybody listened and for the whole class, everybody paid attention. It was beautiful to observe. And even he would always start by establishing a personal connection with his audience. Every time. Because, if you want to teach people, the first step is always getting and keeping their attention.
- nmrm 12y ago"And I think that's what a lot of professors forget - BE MORE INTERESTING. Have a better presentation style. Take public speaking classes. Do something to make yourself stand out above the distraction of internet and devices." Have you done a lot of teaching? As a matter of fact, managing a course-long sequence of lectures in a way that keeps everyone engaged is infinitely more difficult than keeping everyone engaged in a one-off conference presentation. Your entire comment supposes that the content is interesting to the entire class, that you're moving at an appropriate rate for everyone in the course. This is never the case. I don't care how engaging the lecturer is. If it's a lecture on linked lists (or something else I already know about) then, unless I plan on teaching in the future, I'm going to get work done instead of listening. Similarly, if the lecturer takes a class period to pound in an important concept I've already internalized, I'm going to get something done while s/he catches the rest of the class up. The only way to make sure everyone has good reason to pay attention is to teach a very difficult topic. Which is why "not paying attention" is nearly non-existent in canonically difficult courses, regardless of the quality of presentation style.
- Swizec 12y ago> Have you done a lot of teaching? > As a matter of fact, managing a course-long sequence of lectures in a way that keeps everyone engaged is infinitely more difficult than keeping everyone engaged in a one-off conference presentation. No I haven't and yes that's totally understandable. But in my experience a lot of lecturers don't even try (or they probably do, but fail to different extents) > The only way to make sure everyone has good reason to pay attention is to teach a very difficult topic. Which is why "not paying attention" is nearly non-existent in canonically difficult courses, regardless of the quality of presentation style. Not in my experience. I've been to plenty of classes that were extremely difficult, but I just could not bring myself to pay attention to the presenter for longer than a minute at a time. I just couldn't.
- henrikschroder 12y ago> but I just could not bring myself to pay attention to the presenter for longer than a minute at a tim Then maybe the problem is you, not the presenter.
- mrweasel 12y agoI wonder why people bother showing up at conferences and talks if they can't but down their laptop, phone or table for the duration of the talk. For most going to a conference involve setting aside time to travel to the conference, pay for a hotel and perhaps pay for the ticket and taking time of if it's not work related. Either way your wasting money and time by going and not paying attention. You go to conferences to learn, so put the gadgets down. How will people know if your interesting if they're not paying attention?
- Swizec 12y ago> I wonder why people bother showing up at conferences and talks if they can't but down their laptop, phone or table for the duration of the talk. The so called Hallway Track. It is very unlikely you will learn anything at a conference you couldn't learn on your own. At best you're going to get interesting ideas for what to look up next, or get a pulse on what the next direction in your field seems to be. And you are also very unlikely to be able to meet so many [passionate] people from your industry at the same time without going to a conference. You don't need to pay attention in talks for any of those benefits. It might even be detrimental.
- a3_nm 12y ago> You don't need to pay attention in talks for any of those benefits. It might even be detrimental. It might be detrimental to attend to many talks rather than chatting with people, etc. But while you are sitting there you might as well pay attention; most of what you are doing on your phone/computer could probably be done at another time. I know about the fact that the point of a conference is much more than the talks, but I still think that people usually don't make enough of an effort to pay attention to the talks while they are attending them.
- ColinCera 12y agoMy experience with many conferences is that only a few sessions turn out to be worthwhile. If I'm there for 3 days with 5 sessions per day, perhaps 5 or 6 of the sessions I attend will be interesting, but in the other 9 or 10 I will know within the first 5 minutes that the presenter is unlikely to say anything interesting/educational. But what am I to do? Get up and leave? That's mildly rude and other sessions are probably already full. I don't have anywhere else to go and I paid to be here, so I might as well sit through the session on the off-chance the presenter might say one or two things of interest. Meanwhile, all those people back at my company who are still working are sending me emails, and I have other actual low-focus tasks I can be knocking off my to do list, and there's random web surfing I can be doing, all while keeping one ear tuned to the presenter. Frankly, if I only focused on the presenter's irrelevant talk, I'd probably fall dead asleep. Even if I didn't doze off, I would be fighting to keep my eyes open and not getting anything else done.