It wasn't just the measure, it was that the experiment was randomized. Peer evaluations can be done for courses without follow ons and are more useful without r

It wasn't just the measure, it was that the experiment was randomized. Peer evaluations can be done for courses without follow ons and are more useful without randomization. I agree that he should be more critical of his own recommendations. It's not clear that faculty would be free of the "gender, and ethnicity, and attractiveness" biases studies suggest students have -- I was hoping he'd have a clever way to blind evaluations.