5 ms·
Meh. After years of reading hundreds of essays from people complaining about how others use words ("hacker", "professional", "engineer", "artist", "freedom", a
by jasode 12y ago
Meh.
After years of reading hundreds of essays from people complaining about how others use words ("hacker", "professional", "engineer", "artist", "freedom", and hundreds of other words, etc), I've come to the conclusion that the complaint says more about the rigidity of the complainer rather than anything insightful about language evolution.
It's ironic that the blog's name has the word "consulting" in it. When I was in my early 20s, I hated that word. Whenever I told friends I was a consultant, I'd immediately follow up with a self-deprecation: "that's just a fancy label for white-collar prostitute." At the time, "consulting" to me meant McKinsey or Bain and not your bodyshop of Visual Basic programmers. I preferred "contractor" or "freelancer" to the title "consultant". However, the years have gone by and I no longer care. Anyone can call themselves "consultant" and it doesn't bother me at all. It's just bikeshedding now.
Anyone remember the 1990s complaints about the title "webmaster" because (gasp!) it had the word "master" as a suffix? How pompous of those html authors! We should be thankful that "web-jedi" didn't gain any currency and webmaster has already fallen out of favor.
The author suggests "business owner" instead of "entrepreneur". I used to not like that label either. "Business Owner" had connotations of being some monopolist crushing the protesters on Occupy Wall Street or the slavedriver paying his workers minimum wage while drinking their babies blood. Maybe I can call myself "unemployed speculator" or some other circumlocution so as to not offend anyone. Personally, I think "entrepreneur" does not convey any false pretenses about prestige or bootstrapping. It's fascinating that some find a word neutral while others perceive it as putting on airs. You can't win.
If the author doesn't like "entrepreneur" and I have mixed feelings about "business owner", what's a good compromise?
How about other candidate labels such as "wantrepreneur"[1] which is what some of non-HN folks call HN'ers.
Or how about "wannabe philanthropist"? If high-profile charity is the apotheosis of the journey from student->businessman->philanthropist, is "wannabe philanthropist" self-deprecating enough while simultaneously conveying bold aspirations? If family & friends have that puzzled look and ask, "what the heck is a wannabe philanthropist?", you explain the transformation of Bill Gates from Harvard dropout -> CEO -> Gates Foundation. As a bonus, you can throw in words like "camel" and "eye of the needle". And after all that, they'll say "oh for fock's sake, just call yourself an entrepreneur!"
[1]http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=wantrepreneur http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=wantrepreneur
- Dewie 12y ago> I'd immediately follow up with a self-deprecation: "that's just a fancy label for white-collar prostitute" Then what is an employee? A prostitute that is exclusive to one client?
- TallGuyShort 12y agoA mistress.
- cjfont 12y agoWhy not a spouse?
- TallGuyShort 12y agoThat too, although mistress tends to imply a lack of exclusivity, which is often a critical aspect of the business-employee relationship. I don't know if there's a polygamist-specific term for spouse? One that doesn't have the implication of being "the other woman" that mistress has?
- kristiandupont 12y agoAgreed. I'm reminded of this: http://xkcd.com/1314/ http://xkcd.com/1314/ -- I feel that there is some elitist phenomenon here that I can't quite articulate. It's related to the way calling out people as hipsters somewhat protects you from that label yourself.
- Shorel 12y agoIt may work better for pictures of sunsets, but definitely it's much better to enjoy a concert/gig than trying to record it for youtube. However, it's great to see a good recording of it afterwards, with emphasis on good. Not shaky, not blurry, professionally done.
- troydavis 12y agoAnd I sound sillier with any alternative, like when I start with "Well, it’s complicated, see.." and fumble around at explaining what an entrepreneur does, then get asked "So you run businesses that you start? Isn't that an entrepreneur?"