3 ms·
This technical explanation of why glass "can not" flow, does nothing to try and explain the phenomenon where old glass panes are thicker on the bottom than the
by falcolas 12y ago
This technical explanation of why glass "can not" flow, does nothing to try and explain the phenomenon where old glass panes are thicker on the bottom than the top.
A lot of things once thought impossible have been proven to be possible. Offering an explanation of why it's impossible adds nothing to the table.
[EDIT] Missed the bit in the middle. That said, I still find the use of jokes and second hand experiences a bit weak in evidentiary terms. Would have been much more convincing argument if there was a count or documentation detailing how many panels were truly installed one way or the other.
- lisper 12y agoThe article explains this: "Half of the pieces in a window are thicker at the bottom, he said, but, he added quickly, the other half are thicker at the top. My own experience has been that for earlier windows especially, there is sometimes a pronounced variation in thickness over a distance of an inch or two on individual fragments. That squares with the experience of conservators and curators who have handled hundreds of panels. Although the individual pieces of glass in a window may be uneven in thickness, and noticeably wavy, these effects result simply from the way the glasses were made."
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoAlso, if you're a glass installer, you might feel its a best practice to put the heavier end on the bottom. It'll make the pane feel more stable because being top-heavy is like asking for gravity to take your glass and shatter it. With today's production methods and quality control, we really don't have this issue. Glass panes are pretty consistent, but from the point of view of some 18th century carpenter, you probably had to deal with a lot of inconsistent glass panes.
- mnarayan01 12y agoThe portion you quoted is a little misleading (understandably so for conciseness, but it does give the wrong impression). With a bit more context: "Orowan had quipped that there might, indeed, be some truth to the story about glass flowing. Half of the pieces in a window are thicker at the bottom, he said, but, he added quickly, the other half are thicker at the top." Which reads to me as a joke. I note this simply because it seems sub-optimal to introduce myths about the thickness of glass in old cathedrals when correcting a myth about glass in old cathedrals :)
- emodendroket 12y agoThe explanation is rather simple: glassmaking techniques were too primitive to achieve a uniform thickness. It wasn't just "a bit in the middle;" this was addressed pretty extensively beyond the quote someone already gave you.
- Florin_Andrei 12y agoBTW, a little bit of "gedankenexperiment" would show that, if glass really did flow, the panes would not end up so uniformly thin at the top, and so uniformly thick at the bottom, with a smooth transition in between. Rather, they would sag and warp, eventually becoming non-flat if there was any small deviation from verticality. They would remain thicker for longer around the edges (assuming the pane is embedded solidly in a frame) and any support elements that hold it firmly. The top edge would sag more quickly in the middle. Heck, prevailing winds, if any, would slowly push the pane inwards, like a soap bubble. The neat shallow wedge shape simply cannot be obtained via regular viscous flow in a near-vertical pane. --- Also, if mere gravity could change the shape that much, any load-bearing glass element supporting a heavy item would sag visibly in a much shorter time. I'm thinking of the glass table supporting my very large, very heavy plasma TV.