4 ms·
It's complicated, and it's been abundantly discussed on the internet, if you'd care to use a service like Google to research it. Let's keep this thread about h
by davidw 12y ago
It's complicated, and it's been abundantly discussed on the internet, if you'd care to use a service like Google to research it. Let's keep this thread about helping this one guy, rather than debating the merits of various health care systems.
- adamnemecek 12y agoAt the same time, maybe it's situations like this that influence peoples' opinion on the matter.
- davidw 12y agoThen let it speak for itself (I think it does). Politics are a poisonous topic for sites like this and are off-topic according to the guidelines. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6120530 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6120530
- tzs 12y ago> Politics [...] are off-topic according to the guidelines Most submissions about politics are off-topic according to the guidelines. Nothing in the guidelines says that comments about politics are off-topic.
- davidw 12y agoLong term, you can have one of these things: * A high quality site, with interesting, possibly spirited, but civil discussions about various topics. * Politics. Your call.
- tptacek 12y agoWe've all three been here long enough to know what the guidelines are trying to say. It drives me nuts that they won't update them. In the meantime: we're all on the same page on this, so this is probably a fake discussion.
- rtpg 12y agoIs there a real debate? Literally every other highly-developed nation in the world does not have this problem. A significant portion of HN are US-based software engineers or related. That probably means significant amounts of disposable income and some possibility of changing this. We should help this guy, but we should also be donating to political candidates not afraid to tackle this problem. We should be as loud as possible about how as a country, we have failed to create an environment where people can exert their right to a modicum of healthcare access without first having to lose everything they own (through bankruptcy or otherwise). Look at these cases straight-on and acknowledge that this is an absolute disgrace.
- byEngineer 12y agoPlease, please, please don't look on healthcare just from money perspective (i.e. affordability). Look on it from life saving efficiency too. Actually foremost. Renial Cancer I was suspected of having had chances of recovery in Germany of 60%. In the US over 90%. Yes, in Germany it is funded by taxpayer. Yes in the US I would be bankrupt. But I think it is obvious which system is much better in that particular case. I think that all of us would rather be bankrupt than dead. And this is big issue that just isn't discussed in the politics and media.
- VikingCoder 12y agoI'll take your numbers at face value... That's great that Germany gave you a free 60% chance of recovery! If you couldn't afford the 90% chance in the US, your chance of recovery was probably 0%. So, presenting it as 60% or 90% is a false comparison. Nothing prevents you from spending more on your recovery, if you have the money. What you fail to understand is that many people in the United States would like the same 60% chance funded by the taxpayer that you enjoy in Germany. To quote some other numbers at you, Infant Mortality rate (deaths per 1,000 live births) by the CIA 2013 estimate in the United States is 5.2, in Germany it's 3.48. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_infant_mortality_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_infant_mor... So, it's not like healthcare is uniformly better in the United States than other countries, and it absolutely is inaccessible to many of our citizens. Not something I'm proud of.