2 ms·
> The crux of your argument is that "consumers often have no choice but to take whatever deal" and that lack of choice makes this issue important enough for the
by shkkmo 12y ago
> The crux of your argument is that "consumers often have no choice but to take whatever deal" and that lack of choice makes this issue important enough for the government to step in. Is that right?
No, that's completely wrong. "Lack of choice" is not the only or main argument for consumer protection. We don't regulate the arsenic content of toys because parents have no choice but to buy commercially made toys.
The argument is "consumers are being treated by some bad actors in a manner by that interferes with their safety, privacy and dignity". The solution is to look at what the good actors are doing, and mandate that behavior to protect consumers.
> First I would propose spending government time to address those core issues before burning time on this symptom.
Why? Those core issues are incredibly controversial. We shouldn't avoid regulating a new means of loan efforcement because we can't solve fundamental social issues.
> Second, all these rules will make the car more expensive; it's a slight tax on the responsible paid by those who might miss payments.
What are you talking about? This technology (as discussed in the article) only applies to people who's are being offered subprime car loans and are a high risk on not paying. Additionaly, the technology in question should REDUCE the loan costs of subprime auto loans.
> Third, this case is rare and it's unclear its worth the cost and unexpected consequence of regulation.
What are you talking about? The article doesn't give clear numbers for the US market for this technology, but it doesn't seem to be particularly small.
"Corinne Kirkendall, vice president for compliance and public relations for PassTime, which has sold 1.5 million devices worldwide,"
"Roughly 25 percent of all new auto loans made last year were subprime, and the volume of subprime auto loans reached more than $145 billion in the first three months of this year."