5 ms·
Are top CS theorists nice people? Would they even talk with you? (comment 25)
- amichail 17y agoIf it is indeed the case that many of them are dismissive to those who are not likely to be useful to them in research, is this logical behavior? CS theory requires the highest IQ of any subfield of CS to succeed at the highest levels, so perhaps this behavior is reasonable.
- mustpax 17y agoYou are making several big assumptions here: 1. Grad students from non-Ivy PhD programs are useless as research collaborators. 2. People doing CS theory need to be smarter than the average CS PhD. 3. People who go to non-Ivy schools are dumber. These all strike me as ego-driven and unfounded statements. (Not to mention the giant question mark around IQ as a valid measurement of general intellectual aptitude.)
- unalone 17y agoI spent a month at Princeton this summer, working alongside current Princeton students and a handful of the people that work at Princeton. Princeton people are usually very bright. Not all of them are—many of them are capable of regurgitating academically and not much more—but overall it's a community of smart people. It is not, however, particularly brighter than a handful of other communities. Perhaps there's less riffraff, so you only have people above average there, but there's this perception that you have to be a genius to be Ivy and that's simply not true. Until my stint at Princeton, I was a "Princeton child". I grew up loving Princeton, I wanted to have a Princeton degree on my resume and live in the enormous castles that Princeton calls dorms. After staying there, I came away with the perception that Princeton's a great college, but it's not head-and-shoulders above any number of other great colleges, and there's nothing special about the people that go there. (They also put up fake ivy on new buildings, which I consider false advertising.) Another way of putting it: The smartest group of people I've ever worked with was a group of twelve writers who I met when I was sixteen. They were all pretty remarkable people. Of that group, two went to Princeton, one went to Brown, a handful went to schools like Vassar and NYU, and a few went to shitty NJ public schools like I did for a year. So when you're talking to people from shitty public schools, remember that there're people there who could put half of Princeton to shame. Not everybody there's going to be brilliant, but not everybody at Princeton's brilliant either.
- yalurker 17y agoWow, I had the luck of meeting Aaron a few years ago. I have actually referenced him as when I learned the limit of my own intelligence - I had a 4.0 gpa as a CS major and thought myself quite bright, until I was simply blown away by the orders of magnitude greater ability to think about complex problems that he possessed. It's incredibly disheartening to read that post. It seems tragic that someone like Aaron would be shut out due to not attending the right school.
- me2i81 17y agoComplaining about "Ivies" in the context of CS theory is a bit goofy. Princeton is in the top echelon for theory, but I'm not sure the other Ivies would crack the top 5.
- kobs 17y ago'Ivies' is used (erroneously)* as a blanket term to descibe a number of elite institutions (think Stanford, MIT, Caltech, Berkeley, top LACs, etc.) ... connotation.
- me2i81 17y agoSometimes people include top-ranked private universities like Stanford, but never for public universities, and never to refer to top schools in a particular field where the rest of the Ivies are notably weak.
- kobs 17y agoIn this context, I think that the "also has a top CS program" attribute is implied. I think most people understand what the author meant regardless of his slightly incorrect choice of words.
- carterschonwald 17y agothe correct term is "top tier" or "tier 1" schools. The "ivies" are a sports league of schools that all happen to be good at academics: dartmouth, harvard, brown, columbia, yale, princeton, upenn, cornell.
- coliveira 17y agoI do research in an area that is tangent to CS theory. My experience with meeting some of these people is exactly this: they will not pay attention to you if you are not from their clique. Also, every time I visit this blog I see comments on the same theme: that theory-oriented conferences are managed by a clique, that others don't feel welcome... So, my general feeling is that they have deep problems in their community (and I don't mean theoretical problems).
- gdp 17y agoThat's actually true of computer science in general. Ever turned up to a web conference? Or an OO conference? or a Java conference? I guarantee you that I feel as out of place and excluded in any of those forums as I'm sure you do in a theory conference. The thing about any "community" that is well-defined enough to justify having its own conferences is that it has its own set of foundational assumptions and jargon, and conventions. If you don't know these things, you're going to have trouble participating at a high level. I don't think it's so much that people will not "pay attention" to you - it's probably just that what you are saying isn't very interesting. The thing about non-theory CS people interacting with theoretical CS people is that they usually present exactly the same arguments/problems/ideas that everyone else does. Believe me, you get _really_ bored by the seventeenth time you have to address the question "but what if the theorem prover has bugs in it?!", pronounced with the swagger of someone who believes they have just hit upon a novel idea. I imagine that if I turned up to a gathering of high-energy particle physicists, I don't think they would pay much attention to my thoughts on the subject either. It's not dismissive behaviour, either. It's actually just a common mistake within CS to believe that you can turn your hand to any part of CS - you're essentially participating in a very high-level discussion. To answer the original question, I've found people in the top echelons of theoretical CS to be extremely patient and friendly. I asked some really silly questions of top researchers (in one-on-one or small group situations) as an undergraduate that probably deserved to be answered with disdain - I still cringe in retrospect. The most biting retort I ever got was "Oh, that's covered in <such-and-such-a-paper>, which is worth reading if you're interested in this". Hardly a telling-off. For the most part, people have always taken the time to explain things from first principles, or re-state them in ways that I could understand. The idea of the ivory tower is a bit of a misconception. You're talking about very, very smart people who are usually more than accommodating when it comes to answering genuine questions or just engaging in discussions. I would jump at the chance to talk to them about anything and everything - it'll be interesting to say the least, and they are some of the nicest people you'll meet in CS.
- davidw 17y agoI met Simon Peyton-Jones at a dinner once, and he came across as a really nice guy. He seemed interested in what I was doing, even though it's leagues away from what he does, and not nearly so 'interesting'. Highly recommended.
- amichail 17y agoHe is not a member of this community.
- oconnor0 17y agoSPJ's not a member of the top CS theorists?
- amichail 17y agoHis research has nothing to do with what is considered CS theory in the US and Canada.
- zjj 17y agoWhat would it be called then?
- more_original 17y agoProgramming Language theory, I think.
- oconnor0 17y agoI guess I see CS theory encompassing PL theory - not that that's correct.
- jamesbritt 17y ago"His research has nothing to do with what is considered CS theory in the US and Canada." So what is considered CS theory in the US and Canada?
- me2i81 17y agoIt's important to understand that when you're young, it can be difficult to tell the difference between elitism and social awkwardness.
- sketerpot 17y agoThat still doesn't explain why conferences in other CS fields felt so much more welcoming to the OP.
- psyklic 17y agoMuch of this is likely psychological -- in casual conversation at conferences, I definitely ask people about what school they go to rather than what their research project is. Whenever I ask someone about their research project, they launch into an often lengthy synopsis which typically requires ten minutes of clarifying questions to even understand. Then, they may offer to forward me their paper which I must accept or feel callous.
- derefr 17y agoHow about "what are you working on, in ten words or less?" it sounds mean, but it really is what you want from the other person, isn't it?
- endtime 17y agoRajeev Motwani was a very nice guy and would certainly talk to you. He's the only top CS theorist I've met.