8 ms·
FBI blasts Apple, Google for locking police out of phones
- droob 12y agoThe quote that plants this firmly in pretending-to-be-serious land: “The average pedophile at this point is probably thinking, I’ve got to get an Apple phone.”
- intopieces 12y agoThat was my thought, too. That assertion is a re-working of the sentiment that only people who have done something wrong have something to hide, and it's a dangerous one.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- chernevik 12y agoLet's be honest, improved encryption is going to restrain the government's ability to enforce the law. Beyond pedophiles, there are definitely going to be cases where innocent people get hurt as a result. I'm okay with that. The whole idea of our government and society is that the mass of law-abiding and decent people are stronger than the criminal and malicious minority. People are by and large responsible, which is why they can and should govern themselves. Limiting the government's ability to snoop and intrude on citizens is a crucial check on the very real (if long-term) threat of government over-reach. But let's not kid ourselves that our privacy, and its constraints on the government, is without consequences.
- NotAtWork 12y agoThe government currently kills people as part of exercising its policing powers, which most people agree are overly aggressively used. If this lowers that rate, it's possible that the difference in beatings, shootings, and home invasions will be basically even, because there isn't a large portion of the criminal element which is waiting for better encrypted cellphones to do these things (hint: other things about cellphones make these problematic, and most depend on other evidence anyway when prosecuted), where there is a reason to think that police being restrained in using illegal investigation methods will decrease the rate at which police use other illegal investigation methods.
- otakucode 12y agoPeople that are OK with innocent people getting hurt never seen to realize that this usually guarantees that criminals get away with their crimes by the wrong person being convicted. Is that also something you are OK with?
- threatofrain 12y agoIt's a hard step in logic to go from criminals getting off due to insufficient evidence from encrypted iPhones, to the wrong person being convicted.
- godDLL 12y agoPlease provide the guesstimates, or rework the following formula for me: X = how well the government is currently enforcing the law Y = amount of innocent people getting hurt K = role of encryption in all this Y = X × K What would you say K is? Is it big enough to be talking about it?
- Zigurd 12y ago> there are definitely going to be cases where innocent people get hurt as a result That's only true in a vacuum. Can you think of a case that has no other factors than an encrypted file, where someone, as a result, "got hurt?"
- jandrewrogers 12y agoMaybe he is trying to explain why so many people in his department have recently purchased Apple phones. Latent criminal tendencies are the only possible explanation.
- noobface 12y agoIs anyone falling for this?
- diydsp 12y agoI'm actually quite on the fence. It does seem to me to be conceivable that the FBI would pretend to be outraged when they are not. I really don't have enough information and I don't trust anyone.
- icodestuff 12y agoOf course they're outraged, in the same way that a serial burglar is outraged when they discover that someone's backdoor, which has been wide open for years, is suddenly locked. What's their outrage got to do with anything?
- blueking 12y agoI agree it is a fabrication.
- awt 12y agoFortunately as yet there is no way for the USG to grant a monopoly on the manufacture of mobile devices in exchange for access to the contents. An alternate route they can take is through the monopolies granted on various radio frequencies. FCC approval in the future may require backdooring.
- jedberg 12y agoDon't give them any ideas!
- x86_64Ubuntu 12y agoWould that prevent the end user from adding another layer of security onto the device? Kind of how you can log on to my machine, but that doesn't make it any easier to decrypt my Truecrypt partition (I think...).
- Zikes 12y agoGiving the FBI your encryption keys to fight terrorism would be like giving a serial burglar your house keys because you left your oven on. Edit: -because you think you might have left your oven on.
- mcintyre1994 12y agoBecause they told you they think you might have left your oven on.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoThis is pretty funny. It will be interesting to watch the narrative, and it is surprising how overtly partisan it is. I just wish I had a big PR budget I could use to place articles in the right places to adjust the narrative.
- downandout 12y agoThis story was likely published because the companies themselves told them to take a hike, and they are now trying to garner public sympathy. I don't think they are going to get it. Unauthorized intruders, whether or not they have a piece of paper signed by a guy that wears a robe to work, are not welcome in my phone. I hope Apple & Google take a hard line on this, at least until the US government passes a law making it illegal to engineer things in a manner that makes it impossible for companies to comply with search warrants. I'm sure that will come, but hopefully it will take a while.
- idiot900 12y agoI hope you're right. Outside of my tech-oriented friends, most people I've discussed surreptitious electronic government surveillance with are either unconcerned about it or actually for it. And these are highly educated people who should know better.
- chris_mahan 12y agoif there was a terror group operating in the US, killing 10,000 children a week in all states with bombs, chemicals, and biological weapons, and you tried to stop the government, police, army, and other federal agencies from doing everything possible to stop that and save the lives of 4 year-old kids, you'd likely find yourself in jail or dead. People in America who grew up on Nintendo and Xbox don't have a clue how stupidly brutal the world can be. This is why these "highly educated people" are "actually for it". I will grant you that these activities should be under the oversight of the US government, State governments, who represent the People of the United States. The FBI is such a federal government agency.
- Shivetya 12y agowhere is my self destruct code? Something that gives them all the appearance of unlocking but just corrupts/erases data.
- CompuHacker 12y ago"Willful destruction of evidence." comes to mind.
- malka 12y agoThey'd need to prove there was evidence.
- biafra 12y agoFor Android you can do this as a regular application. If you're a developer have a look at: https://developer.android.com/guide/topics/admin/device-admin.html https://developer.android.com/guide/topics/admin/device-admi...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ChrisAntaki 12y agoThe FBI is more than talented enough to get into phones, or areas, they just need to invest more time if something's locked. Which honestly, is a good thing. It means they'll have to actually choose on a targeted basis who is worth surveilling, which is more conductive to democracy than just saying, "Give us all your keys". An easy system to crack is an easy system to crack, period.
- malanj 12y agoHe said he could not understand why companies would “market something expressly to allow people to place themselves beyond the law.” - I guess the FBI and the NSA don't talk much?
- spacehome 12y ago> He said he could not understand why companies would “market something expressly to allow people to place themselves beyond the law.” That's certainly rich.
- kenrikm 12y agoIndeed, the FBI routinely likes to forget about the Constitution and place themselves beyond it.
- ColinDabritz 12y agoWell, at least we know it is probably effective, or they wouldn't make such a fuss.
- narrowingorbits 12y agoOr else they're making such a fuss specifically to help sell the supposed effectiveness.
- kenrikm 12y agoHey FBI, if you want the data on the phone get a Warrant that requires the person who owns the phone to unlock it for you - or go to jail for not complying. You don't go to a next-door neighbor who has the key to a house and serve him the Warrant to get into your their neighbors house. Don't go to Apple or Google and make them unlock the phone. 4th Amendment, unlawful search and seizure and all that jazz.
- Rylinks 12y agoPreviously apple would only provide data in response to a warrant. Now they don't provide data at all.
- ChrisAntaki 12y agoWhere did you read that, out of curiosity?
- Rylinks 12y agoThe was a WaPo article[0] posted on HN a while back: >If I understand how it works, the only time the new design matters is when the government has a search warrant, signed by a judge, based on a finding of probable cause. Under the old operating system, Apple could execute a lawful warrant and give law enforcement the data on the phone. Under the new operating system, that warrant is a nullity. It’s just a nice piece of paper with a judge’s signature. Because Apple demands a warrant to decrypt a phone when it is capable of doing so, the only time Apple’s inability to do that makes a difference is when the government has a valid warrant. The policy switch doesn’t stop hackers, trespassers, or rogue agents. It only stops lawful investigations with lawful warrants. 0:http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/09/19/apples-dangerous-game/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014...
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Under the old operating system, Apple could execute a lawful warrant and give law enforcement the data on the phone. [...] The policy switch doesn’t stop hackers, trespassers, or rogue agents. It only stops lawful investigations with lawful warrants. Incorrect: under the old operating system a human at Apple could give anyone the data on the phone. Apple had procedural safeguards that aimed to ensure that no one at Apple would do that without proper approval, but as anyone who pays attention to the news should be aware, procedural safeguards of data do not always prevent humans who are motivated to violate those safeguards. (Including, inter alia, "hackers, trespassers, and rogue agents" -- as certainly the US government is aware; its hardly as if the NSA didn't have procedural safeguards that applied to the data that Edward Snowden released.) The change (which is a technical change, not a policy change) means no human at Apple can do this, and the phone user is protected from humans who might violate Apple's policies, including "hackers, trespassers, and rogue agents." It incidentally means that any warrant for data on the phone will have to be served on the only person who has access to that data, the phone owner. It doesn't "stop lawful investigations with lawful warrants", it reduces the number of people who can access a phone, and therefore the set of people on whom a lawful warrant can be served. But law enforcement has no inherent right to expect that some third party will have access to my private property (whether physical or virtual) that enables law enforcement to serve a warrant on a third person, and that third person having access is always a compromise of my security that makes me more vulnerable to rogue actors. It is not simply a convenience for "lawful investigations with lawful warrants" that provides no risk to me outside of such investigations.
- conductor 12y agoHere is a related note titled "Are Google and Apple On Your Side?" by Bill Blunden - http://cryptome.org/2014/09/google-apple-crypto.pdf http://cryptome.org/2014/09/google-apple-crypto.pdf
- pyrocat 12y ago"Locking police out of" assumes that they have a right to be there in the first place.
- anigbrowl 12y agoWell if they have a well-formed wallet they actually do have that right. The constitution contemplates the issuance of warrants precisely because there are circumstances where seizure is entirely appropriate.
- Zigurd 12y agoYou are confusing a right with a power, granted by consent of the governed, that can be withdrawn and can't rewrite the rules of mathematics. People have rights, and under constitutions written the way the US constitution is written, those rights are not enumerated or limited. You have a right to use strong encryption because you have not consented to give away that right. The government has no actual rights at all.
- xemoka 12y agoThe word is out, the people no longer trust their governments. Big surprise when the governments don't trust their people. The road goes both ways.
- frandroid 12y agoDear Bureau, Please blame the NSA for bringing this upon yourself.
- teleclimber 12y agoNot just the NSA. The regular ol' police gives off the appearance of being at war with the citizens it's supposed to protect sometimes. They are extremely militarized, very technologically advanced, but not always fair and even-keeled.
- phkahler 12y agoFunny: "That led investigators to a Facebook post, made two days after the homicide, in which another man posed in a cell phone selfie with the same gun." You'd think a selfie would be enough to find someone the traditional way, but they seem to think they needed to locate the phone that took the picture.
- porqupine 12y agoThe technology has been there for a while, it's just finally gotten the point where people's mistrust for the government is something tech companies can market to. -
- randyrand 12y ago> “market something expressly to allow people to place themselves beyond the law.” One thing the FBI does not realize, or does not care, is that THEY ARE NOT THE ONLY ONES THE BACKDOORS WORK FOR. A backdoor is a backdoor. Period. When so much private information is on a single device it's not just about being beyond the law (which is a great reason in and of itself because law enforcement is itself beyond the law). It's about being safe.
- opendais 12y agoExactly. The FBI's argument is basically: "Leave your front door unlocked. Just in case we want to search you for drugs/obscene material/weapons/etc." I don't know about you, but I don't want to leave my house unlocked 24/7 "just in case" the FBI wants to serve me with a warrant.
- revelation 12y agoYou're missing the punchline: Apple left the front door unlocked and open, and once they noticed, obviously closed and locked it. Now the FBI complains they can't just go through the front door anymore. Well yes.
- opendais 12y agoI try not to judge the past I suppose.
- anigbrowl 12y agoExcept it isn't. When the FBI has a warrant they are legally entitled to break into your house even if you don't want them to. Edit: downvote all you like, but this is a simple factual statement.
- thirdtruck 12y agoExcept that we still expect them to break in, not simply waltz through the front door after unlocking with their skeleton key.
- bakennedy 12y ago“I’ve been an investigator for almost 27 years,” Collins said, “It’s concerning that we’re beginning to go backwards with this technology.” It's concerning that a veteran police investigator considers consumer privacy "backwards."
- otakucode 12y agoWell, to be fair to him, in his entire 27 years of police work he has never busted a single criminal except through cell phone contents.
- sluckxz 12y agoWhat do the watchers think we should do when we can't even have an open rational discussion about constitutional rights especially regarding new technology and information. I am willing to discuss and debate. My data was yours with a warrant. The tools to go beyond that weren't mainstream. By refusing to communicate the internet is working around you. Rightfully so.
- jordanthoms 12y agoMaybe they should have thought about the backlash _before_ they engaged in mass surveillance?
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoJulian Sanchez wrote a relevant response to Orin Kerr going over the history of the crypto wars and why this is all wrong: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8369963 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8369963
- Tloewald 12y agoVery food link which deserves more attention. It's a non issue.
- nickbauman 12y ago"A policeman's job is only easy in a police state." — Mike Vargas, from Orson Welles' "Touch of Evil"
- franciscop 12y ago> “Our ability to act on data that does exist . . . is critical to our success,” Hosko said. He suggested that it would take a major event, such as a terrorist attack, to cause the pendulum to swing back toward giving authorities access to a broad range of digital information. - related article ( http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/2014/09/17/2612af58-3ed2-11e4-b03f-de718edeb92f_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/2014/09/17... ) USA, get ready for a "foreign terrorist attack" in the next few days (;
- blueking 12y agoDont know if I buy this. The whole DEA cant crack imessage was a PR stunt. I think they are lying together. The trust is gone. Just using encryption isnt enough, it has to be open source and verifiable. Neither Apple or Google are there. Google has a anti privacy agenda, and Apple is closed source. http://www.propublica.org/article/stanford-promises-not-to-use-google-money-for-privacy-research http://www.propublica.org/article/stanford-promises-not-to-u...
- bjornsing 12y agoThat old saying comes to mind: as you make your bed, so you must lie in it.
- Someone1234 12y agoI thought the US government could already run arbitrary code on a running device via means of the baseband OS/modem? e.g. PDF(!) https://www.usenix.org/system/files/conference/woot12/woot12-final24.pdf https://www.usenix.org/system/files/conference/woot12/woot12... So is this whole thing REALLY about the US Government losing access or more about them not wanting to expose their over-the-air code execution techniques? Since presumably if they capture an already running device, they can just get the warrant, and ask the cellular network to send their specially crafted packet (which can unlock the phone, SMS the encryption key, or similar). Sorry but if the Intelligence Services cannot unlock an encrypted device STILL RUNNING then I'll eat my hat.
- nhaehnle 12y ago> So is this whole thing REALLY about the US Government losing access or more about them not wanting to expose their over-the-air code execution techniques? Obviously, the latter. More to the point, the type of regular police who would push for this probably aren't even aware that such code execution techniques might exist.
- mrjj 12y agoI think that under this noise both OS is stuffed with bookmarks heavier than any time before. Ouch, those Apple and Google guys so bad that they following forth amendment, poor and evil FBI and NSA they can't do anything with american companies. They soo-o-o angry about their OS security that you definitely could trust it. And don't, and again, don't use this bad bad TOR and other security stuff of bad hackers full of trashware: http://securitywatch.pcmag.com/apple-ios-iphone-ipad-ipod/321803-fake-tor-browser-app-for-ios-full-of-adware-spyware http://securitywatch.pcmag.com/apple-ios-iphone-ipad-ipod/32... that are suprisingly sticking at the top of your application store.
- hxc 12y agoI can't wait to see the FBI point the finger at the NSA and say something to the fact of "The FBI is trying to protect you, we aren't the NSA violating your right." That would be golden
- mrjj 12y agoYeah, the politics is about giving a good show )
- rakoo 12y agoThe funniest part is that as a customer, I still have very little guarantee that the company can't access the phone's content at will; it's still promises to me.
- Igglyboo 12y agoShouldn't we be valuing privacy over throwing people in jail?
- MCRed 12y agoHey if the FBI were obeying the law, then I might have some concern for them. But they aren't. They're going out there, organizing groups of people, setting them up with terrorist plots, providing them with material and financial support, and then busting them. Whether that's entrapment or not, I don't care--- it is a violation of anti-terrorism conspiracy laws. Not to mention the NSA, and I believe FBI, conducting illegal spying operations. Government has proven it cannot be trusted, now complains when companies stop trusting it? Plus the iPhone is sold globally.
- fbi4life 12y agoStop pulling BS out of your ass and provide a source for your first claim, please?
- mariodiana 12y agohttp://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/471/the-convert http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/471/t... http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/terror-prosecution-muslim-americans http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/terror-prosecution-m... http://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/nov/16/fbi-entrapment-fake-terror-plots http://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/nov/16/fbi-entrapment-... http://www.salon.com/2013/07/10/only_1_percent_of_terrorists_caught_by_fbi_are_real_partner/ http://www.salon.com/2013/07/10/only_1_percent_of_terrorists... http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2011/08/fbi-terrorist-informants http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2011/08/fbi-terrorist-in...
- vijayboyapati 12y ago>He said he could not understand why companies would “market something expressly to allow people to place themselves beyond the law.” Perhaps he's entirely unaware of any history where "the law" was used to oppress. Perhaps he's also unaware that something being "the law" does not make it just. For instance, in Washington, where I live, just two years ago it was illegal to own marijuana. Now it's legal. Does this now mean that the moral status of owning and smoking marijuana has changed, or does it merely show that the law is inconstant and often at odds with justice? Much is taken for granted in his rhetorical question.
- eslaught 12y agoSo here's what I don't get: This is just standard, off-the-shelf encryption, right? Like the kind I've been using on my desktop since forever? How is this such a big deal? I realize that from a PR perspective, Apple would like to appear to be privacy conscious. And perhaps Apple was asking for legal fallout by flouting that particular aspect of correctly implemented encryption. It just seems a little too ironic that this is just standard off-the-shelf encryption we're talking about.
- vfclists 12y agoWhen I made a point about Orrin Kerr shilling for the law enforcement agencies https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8349006 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8349006 one or two people didn't agree. I guess it is now obvious what that piece was about. The disingeneous dimension to this issue is that smart phones are basically powerful hand held personal computers which make calls and take photos on the side. Less than 1% of their capability is used for for making calls. Orrin Kerr pretends not to understand this. He wouldn't insist that Microsoft, Apple and Linux developers weaken the encryption on regular laptops, desktops or servers for law enforcement to have access to data. Why should he insist on it for smart phones which these days are just as powerful as PCs, the only difference being that people carry them around, make calls and store contact details on them? Steve Job and Apple's desire to have complete control and have access to users information brought this situation about, and in doing so made themselves virtually accessories to whatever crimes people stored on their phones. Now they realize that it made them appear as agents and collaborators with the investigative agencies, they have decided to extricate themselves from that situation leaving them close to being labelled 'pedophile and terrorist facilitators'.
- javajosh 12y agoWrong, FBI: this is a human rights issue, pure and simple. Our devices augment our minds, and you want to read our minds. And we don't want you to. It is disingenuous to imply (let alone assert, as in this case) that you can't investigate criminal activity without the ability to access our phones/read our minds. Somehow you managed for many decades prior to the iPhone. To claim you need this access now is rather silly. I would suggest that you allow people their private, augmented minds, enjoy the better society that will (hopefully) give us all, and pursue other investigatory avenues, of which there is no shortage and which should occur to your thought.
- golemotron 12y ago> “market something expressly to allow people to place themselves beyond the law.” Why isn't he complaining about Starbucks? Conspirators can meet in a Starbucks and discuss illegal things over coffee. If Starbucks cared about people, they'd bug all of the tables.
- otakucode 12y agoIt would be an awful lot easier for police to catch criminals if they were permitted to simply kick in random doors and raid houses just to poke around and look for evidence of crimes, too. Police do not have an absolute right to easily-gathered evidence. Especially given the malleability of digital content, they should be relying on actual physical evidence more than ever anyway.
- D4AHNGM 12y agoIt's nice to see the media digest and swallow this bull from the FBI & co without bothering to even chew it a little first. "Oh the FBI said something, IT MUST be true!". All it requires is for someone to find that backdoor & its mechanism and that's it, they can exploit the backdoor designed for someone else for their own purposes. And if that someone doesn't have legitimate intentions, what then? Am I supposed to accept making my device that much less secure because the FBI or another state actor may one day decide I'm trouble? The chance of that backdoor being exploited by someone other than the FBI is considerably higher than the FBI ever using it themselves, and the FBI seem to be in lalaland on this.
- cyphunk 12y ago"There will come a day when..." The prefix to every fantasy.
- Zigurd 12y agoEither security works, or forensics works. You can't have both.
- recursion1133 12y agoI don't know. This article keeps saying the new iPhone is very secure. It makes me think it might not be very secure.