3 ms·
> You can tell who is an entrepreneur and who isn't by those who talk shit about Larry and Oracle. There is room for a variety of entrepreneurial styles. In ec
by javajosh 12y ago
> You can tell who is an entrepreneur and who isn't by those who talk shit about Larry and Oracle.
There is room for a variety of entrepreneurial styles. In economics as in a natural ecosystem, there is room for an astounding variety of survival strategies.
The Disney movie "The Lion King" just isn't referenced enough on HN. Your comment is roughly equivalent to saying "You can tell who is a successful species on the savannah by those who talk shit about Mufasa." The truth is that apex predators like lions are very cool, but, by biomass and evolutionary longevity not nearly the most successful animals in any ecosystem.
And, uniquely to humans, there is a meta-game, wherein what we say about the world influences the world. This effect is so strong that we can indeed redefine what success means with our words. Success in nature is, unambiguously, survival. Live long enough to reproduce, die happy. But we humans can and often do alter this definition. And we do it in economics as well. The traditional definition of capitalist success is (to paraphrase) "die a billionaire". That's a valid definition, and I wouldn't take it away from anyone, but realize there are other valid choices who's existence doesn't affect the validity of Larry's credo.
I would argue that the problem with that definition is the fact that success has to be personally attributable value. Money is, in the end, just a kind of primordial "like". Larry has amassed billions of "likes". But how much more value could he have created had he not worried so much about localizing the rewards?
I'm glad you want to be an apex predator, but I don't think you'll get very far by insisting that the world only needs (or would only benefit from having) apex predators.
- benjohnson 12y agoVery well said. My version of being an entrepreneur includes having enough time to be with my family and raise awesome children who will have the ability to be entrepreneurs as well.
- dllthomas 12y ago"Live long enough to reproduce, die happy." I'm not sure it's relevant to your central thesis here, but this conflates the experience of the individual with the workings of evolution. Living long enough to reproduce (more precisely, having a high inclusive fitness, which typically includes reproducing but strictly doesn't have to) is roughly equivalent to nature saying "more like that" which can be counted as "a win" - but the dying animals are still probably dying in pain.
- parasubvert 12y agoSome good points, but I wasn't trying to equate entrepreneurship with individual success or happiness. I was talking about our broader economic ecosystem, with the managed organization as the primary unit, not the individual. The question was, what approaches are required for the individual (an entrepreneur) that creates such a managed organization to build a sustainably, very high wealth producing capability? In this, I do not think your analogy of apex predators follows. Most companies live and die quickly, those that become pillars of wealth and last 50 years+ have tended to carve out monopoly (by their apex predator?) status in certain areas such that they can diversify into new ones. This is not to say that all organizations need to be pillars of wealth and last two generations. There's plenty of room for survival and happiness with lifestyle organizations. But I wouldn't necessarily call people that start such companies entrepreneurs, I'd call them "small business owners" or "self employed".