> Removing public access means he intends to use the land privately The argument was that he wasn't removing public access; he contends public access never exi

> Removing public access means he intends to use the land privately The argument was that he wasn't removing public access; he contends public access never existed: "the Deeney family, which set up the first cabin in 1918, had always charged people to access the beach, a clear indication that it was a private beach prior to 1972"