3 ms·
> socialist countries restrict the rewards to the extremely talented, whereas America does no such thing (at a cost to the bottom half of its bell curve). This
by jgrant27 17y ago
> socialist countries restrict the rewards to the extremely talented, whereas America does no such thing (at a cost to the bottom half of its bell curve).
This is just not the common case. Generally speaking, the US does give disproportionate rewards to the 'high-end' of the curve so to speak. However this often comes at a cost to everyone else(or the following generation) whether they realize it or not. It's simply harder to notice this happening when it's spread over a generation or two. Examples being health care, the economic pyramid schemes, 'education', care of veterans etc.
Top tier American schools are highly-overrated and highly overpriced these days. They are a much bigger and slower bubble to burst over here.
http://www.theamericanscholar.org/the-disadvantages-of-an-elite-education/ http://www.theamericanscholar.org/the-disadvantages-of-an-el...
I believe the key phrase in this article is "entitled mediocrity". The author also spent at least 25 years as a scholar and then Professor at Yale and Columbia.
With all that being said, America is still a great place. It just might be better not to look for the rewards in all the popular places and using the popular methods.
- potatolicious 17y agoI didn't disagree with you :) My point that the US disproportionately rewards the high end of a curve was an observation as opposed to a value judgment. This has caused many social problems, and IMHO is the wrong way to run things. Nonetheless, for people who feel that they can profit much more in this environment (i.e. top-end-of-the-curve types) it's very attractive. "Top tier American schools are highly-overrated and highly overpriced these days." Perception, in this case, trumps reality. The reality is that a MIT degree is worth a hell of a lot more in salary than a random eastern European university. Whether or not the education truly is better is moot - people want in on the USA because it generally will lead to a better life than they've got now - assuming "now" is an underdeveloped country.